Buy this sub or go with the SVS?

[Anti-SD]

So I recently made a thread about my current sub, ED A300, which was making a weird noise. Well before I had a chance to try and fix it, the thing pretty much died on me.

So now i'm in the market for a new sub. I've heard lots of great things about the SVS subs and had my mind set on getting this one

http://www.amazon.com/SVS-12-inch-30...=svs+subwoofer

but i've just seen a JBL sub whose price has gone down 60% from its original. I guess it's a labor day sale

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product?ASIN=B00166ZFSO


seems to have good specs and all and its only $200.

Anyone got this sub and is it worth the punt? Or should I just go with the SVS? Thanks