Rate the collection of the poster above you

[Travis]

Originally Posted by Leonidas_King

Lots of action and super hero films. Nice! 9/10

Great collection. Lots of the same titles.

10/10

[toddly6666]

Originally Posted by Travis

Great collection. Lots of the same titles.

10/10

I think I could be best friends with you. Your collection is very similar to my taste and I give you props for having films (watership down, action jackson, perfect weapon, westworld, greystoke, oliver, shogun, allen quatermain, bednobs & broomsticks) which brought back memories of films/shows that left a mark on me during my childhood.

10++/10

[drmb1990]

Originally Posted by toddly6666

I think I could be best friends with you. Your collection is very similar to my taste and I give you props for having films (watership down, action jackson, perfect weapon, westworld, greystoke, oliver, shogun, allen quatermain, bednobs & broomsticks) which brought back memories of films/shows that left a mark on me during my childhood.

10++/10

Great variety, lots of films I would love to own myself someday.
10/10

[huntauk]

Originally Posted by drmb1990

Great variety, lots of films I would love to own myself someday.
10/10

Massive collection with a lot of good and watchable titles in each genre. However for me; too much throwaway stuff in there, and just mainly post 1980's Hollywood films in the collection. Too many classics and favorites of mine not included - so good at what is there, but room to expand beyond films produced in L.A. 7.5/10

[Drudge]

Originally Posted by huntauk

Massive collection with a lot of good and watchable titles in each genre. However for me; too much throwaway stuff in there, and just mainly post 1980's Hollywood films in the collection. Too many classics and favorites of mine not included - so good at what is there, but room to expand beyond films produced in L.A. 7.5/10

Very cool collection 8/10

[onetet]

Originally Posted by Drudge

Very cool collection 8/10

9.5/10 Very large collection that still reflects excellent curation guided by personal taste... a love of genre cinema that encompasses mainstream, cult, classic, and international fare alike.

[poke smot]

Originally Posted by onetet

9.5/10 Very large collection that still reflects excellent curation guided by personal taste... a love of genre cinema that encompasses mainstream, cult, classic, and international fare alike.

Wow...talk about variety and mix of titles...9/10

[OneWayFilms]

Originally Posted by poke smot

Wow...talk about variety and mix of titles...9/10

As close to PERECT as they come. BRAVO!!!!!!! LOVE your categories and your taste in movies is AWESOME!

10/10

[RedSabbath]

Hi...long time member, starting out poster.

Bolt, nice collection. Am I supposed to give it a "A thru F" rating? Okay...B+. Clerks fan can't go wrong.

Okay, gimme Hell guys....

(Oops, I didn't reply to the last post, sorry)

[malakaheso]

^^Great genre collection. 8.5/10

[PLG1962]

Originally Posted by malakaheso

^^Great genre collection. 8.5/10

Good selection 8/10

[OneWayFilms]

Originally Posted by RedSabbath

Hi...long time member, starting out poster.

Bolt, nice collection. Am I supposed to give it a "A thru F" rating? Okay...B+. Clerks fan can't go wrong.

Okay, gimme Hell guys....

(Oops, I didn't reply to the last post, sorry)

Welcome to Blu-ray.com and to the rating thread. Since you're new, I will go ahead and give you a quick tutorial on how to do this. You always go the last poster of the thread and click on their Blu-ray collection found under their name. After you examine their collection, you can come back and QUOTE their last post so everyone can be clear on who you are rating.

We normally give a rating of 1 - 10, (1 being the lowest and 10 being the highest). We also give a quick description, a short reason for our rating. I try to be encouraging to all, and I personally always include the categories presentation in my grade.

Originally Posted by PLG1962

Good selection 8/10

Wow, How can I say anything negative about a collection of THIS size and magnitude? Only drawback might be your choice of categories....how can you have genres AND a category for decades? I noticed you have a musical section with Little Shop of Horrors. How do you chose which category to place that in? 80's? or Musical? What standard do you use? It seems a bit broad. Otherwise....WELL DONE!


9/10

[Gizz]

Originally Posted by OneWayFilms

Welcome to Blu-ray.com and to the rating thread. Since you're new, I will go ahead and give you a quick tutorial on how to do this. You always go the last poster of the thread and click on their Blu-ray collection found under their name. After you examine their collection, you can come back and QUOTE their last post so everyone can be clear on who you are rating.

We normally give a rating of 1 - 10, (1 being the lowest and 10 being the highest). We also give a quick description, a short reason for our rating. I try to be encouraging to all, and I personally always include the categories presentation in my grade.


Wow, How can I say anything negative about a collection of THIS size and magnitude? Only drawback might be your choice of categories....how can you have genres AND a category for decades? I noticed you have a musical section with Little Shop of Horrors. How do you chose which category to place that in? 80's? or Musical? What standard do you use? It seems a bit broad. Otherwise....WELL DONE!


9/10

Awesome collection there my friend. 10/10

[KillaCam]

Originally Posted by Gizz

Awesome collection there my friend. 10/10

You have quite a nice collection with many titles I would like to add to my own. It would be easier to browse if you organized it with categories though. 8/10

[Peachy]

Originally Posted by KillaCam

You have quite a nice collection with many titles I would like to add to my own. It would be easier to browse if you organized it with categories though. 8/10

A collection full of testosterone

Your Scream Factory category is just awesome, but you have movies I particularly like in almost every section (well done for Berserk or Birdman )

No doubt, a great 8/10 dude

[Badas]

Originally Posted by Peachy

A collection full of testosterone

Your Scream Factory category is just awesome, but you have movies I particularly like in almost every section (well done for Berserk or Birdman )

No doubt, a great 8/10 dude

Damn amazing. 10/10

[jwblu]

10/10 - your collection is sweet.

[bunkz323]

Originally Posted by jwblu

10/10 - your collection is sweet.

Small collection but great imo. 10/10

[PLG1962]

Originally Posted by OneWayFilms

Welcome to Blu-ray.com and to the rating thread. Since you're new, I will go ahead and give you a quick tutorial on how to do this. You always go the last poster of the thread and click on their Blu-ray collection found under their name. After you examine their collection, you can come back and QUOTE their last post so everyone can be clear on who you are rating.

We normally give a rating of 1 - 10, (1 being the lowest and 10 being the highest). We also give a quick description, a short reason for our rating. I try to be encouraging to all, and I personally always include the categories presentation in my grade.


Wow, How can I say anything negative about a collection of THIS size and magnitude? Only drawback might be your choice of categories....how can you have genres AND a category for decades? I noticed you have a musical section with Little Shop of Horrors. How do you chose which category to place that in? 80's? or Musical? What standard do you use? It seems a bit broad. Otherwise....WELL DONE!


9/10

Yes it was tough but I went with genre's/companies eg Arrow/Criterion over years etc eg one of Kubrick isn't in the Kubrick section because its Criterion [The Killing] I would love it if a film could be in multiple categories would make "life a little easier for me" but its all good
Thanks for the remark id love to not have a wish list its one of my goals but being out of work has stunted my buying especially from overseas for the time being

[OneWayFilms]

Originally Posted by bunkz323

Small collection but great imo. 10/10

I noticed you were skipped due to a response from a newbie, I will grade you and give some instructions for him.

Your collections started out AMAZING with some really cool categories, but then it just stopped and everyone got mixed into OWNED. It seem incomplete, so I hope you are still working on it. Keep it up, you're off to a great start. Good title selections by the way.

7/10 for now......when you finished, I bet this will increase.

Originally Posted by PLG1962

Yes it was tough but I went with genre's/companies eg Arrow/Criterion over years etc eg one of Kubrick isn't in the Kubrick section because its Criterion [The Killing] I would love it if a film could be in multiple categories would make "life a little easier for me" but its all good
Thanks for the remark id love to not have a wish list its one of my goals but being out of work has stunted my buying especially from overseas for the time being

Just another word of caution: NEVER post in this thread without rating the last poster. Then, the next poster will rate YOU and the person who posted before you get's skipped. It's an unfair disappointment to be skipped.

Most people respond in PM's (like you did to me), but never in this thread, unless they rate the person before them.

You'll get the hang of this....keep it up.