Air-Flow and Standing waves?

[jeff92k7]

Airflow, as with temperature and humidity can have an effect on audio waves but the effect is very minor and typically is not something to worry about until you get into VERY large rooms (arenas). For a typical home theater, or even a full size cinema, airflow is not a concern.

In most cases, airflow from air handling systems or cieling fans is moving at such a slow rate that the audio will pass right "through" it as if it weren't moving at all.

[Audiophile_At_Birth]

Originally Posted by jeff92k7

Airflow, as with temperature and humidity can have an effect on audio waves but the effect is very minor and typically is not something to worry about until you get into VERY large rooms (arenas). For a typical home theater, or even a full size cinema, airflow is not a concern.

In most cases, airflow from air handling systems or cieling fans is moving at such a slow rate that the audio will pass right "through" it as if it weren't moving at all.

I beg to differ. Cieling fans do have a significant effect on standing waves or any sound waves for that matter. When I play my Sax in my room with the fan on, I get horrible sonic resonance from the horn and throughout my room.

[jeff92k7]

Originally Posted by Audiophile_At_Birth

I beg to differ. Cieling fans do have a significant effect on standing waves or any sound waves for that matter. When I play my Sax in my room with the fan on, I get horrible sonic resonance from the horn and throughout my room.

But how much of that is caused by the airflow and how much of that is caused by the sound waves hitting the fan blades themselves. I would argue that what you are hearing is the sound of the sax going up and hitting the fan blade one instant, then all the way up to the ceiling the next, and so on. In that case, it's not the movement of air that is causing what you hear. It is the fact that sound waves are reflecting off of a moving object.

You can hear this effect by speaking into the front or back of a box fan, or any other fan with a safety guard on it. (Never, ever get that close to a moving ceiling fan or any fan without a safety guard on it). In this case, you will note that there is only a very minor difference, if any, in sound between speaking into the front of the fan as opposed to the back. For airflow to have a noticeable effect, there would have to be a noticeable difference between the front and the back since sound is moving in opposite directions on each side.

I should have been more clear and noted that in my first post but since the question was about airflow affecting sound waves and not how the fan blades interact with sound waves, I failed to do so. I stand by my original statement that the moving air will have very little effect on the sound waves - standing or otherwise.

[bluseminole]

Originally Posted by jeff92k7

But how much of that is caused by the airflow and how much of that is caused by the sound waves hitting the fan blades themselves. I would argue that what you are hearing is the sound of the sax going up and hitting the fan blade one instant, then all the way up to the ceiling the next, and so on. In that case, it's not the movement of air that is causing what you hear. It is the fact that sound waves are reflecting off of a moving object.

You can hear this effect by speaking into the front or back of a box fan, or any other fan with a safety guard on it. (Never, ever get that close to a moving ceiling fan or any fan without a safety guard on it). In this case, you will note that there is only a very minor difference, if any, in sound between speaking into the front of the fan as opposed to the back. For airflow to have a noticeable effect, there would have to be a noticeable difference between the front and the back since sound is moving in opposite directions on each side.

I should have been more clear and noted that in my first post but since the question was about airflow affecting sound waves and not how the fan blades interact with fan blades, I failed to do so. I stand by my original statement that the moving air will have very little effect on the sound waves - standing or otherwise.

I don't know much about acoustics, but with all respect, I would have to agree that airflow does make a difference. When I play piano (a grand), it doesn't matter whether its open or closed, if the ceiling fan at the other end of the room is on, the sound seems to bounce all over the place and have the kind of "wahWAHwahWAH" effect, similar to the one you get when you talk right into an oscillating fan. It's quite noticeable when the fan is on high; turn the fan on low, and the effect disappears.

I don't know

[hagar852]

It is as Jeff explained it. Airflow doesn't affect the sound. It is the fan blades causing that.

[Sir Terrence]

Originally Posted by bluseminole

I don't know much about acoustics, but with all respect, I would have to agree that airflow does make a difference. When I play piano (a grand), it doesn't matter whether its open or closed, if the ceiling fan at the other end of the room is on, the sound seems to bounce all over the place and have the kind of "wahWAHwahWAH" effect, similar to the one you get when you talk right into an oscillating fan. It's quite noticeable when the fan is on high; turn the fan on low, and the effect disappears.

I don't know

Once again, this a reflection off the fans, not an airflow issue. While wind can assist sound in traveling further if blowing hard enough, a ceiling fan can hardly achieve that.

[hagar852]

in comparison. Current doesn't effect ocean waves. In a room air flow hardly matters at all. The only thing that effects sound is other sound to interfere with it.

[bluseminole]

I stand corrected. This is why I hang around forums...

[Sir Terrence]

Originally Posted by Audiophile_At_Birth

I beg to differ. Cieling fans do have a significant effect on standing waves or any sound waves for that matter. When I play my Sax in my room with the fan on, I get horrible sonic resonance from the horn and throughout my room.

Standing waves are room related, and unless the room size is adjusted they re not altered by wind. What you are hearing are reflections from the fans blades, not the effect of standing waves. Your Sax does not go low enough in frequency to even create a standing wave in your room.