How many films do you rate as having perfect AQ/PQ?

[42041]

Originally Posted by Carlos2992

Wizard of Oz cannot be considered as a perfect PQ disc in any way. Considering the reviews I read about PQ on this disc, it is EXTREMELY overrated. Do studios pay some sites to get great reviews for discs with bad PQ as Wizard Of Oz and Gone With The Wind or what ? ( Movie itself is not questioned ).

People who are interested in classic films on Blu aren't interested in how well they hold up to Transformers, and these sites are correctly reviewing them on their own merits. Wizard of Oz is likely about as good looking as it could look given its age.

[Carlos2992]

Originally Posted by 42041

People who are interested in classic films on Blu aren't interested in how well they hold up to Transformers, and these sites are correctly reviewing them on their own merits. Wizard of Oz is likely about as good looking as it could look given its age.

I understand your point. My point is that according the PQ reviews I saw of WOZ I was specting a transfer a la The Searches. Cheers.

[KingBing]

This is tough but for PQ I say Baraka, AQ Transformers 2

[KubrickFan]

Originally Posted by Carlos2992

I understand your point. My point is that according the PQ reviews I saw of WOZ I was specting a transfer a la The Searches. Cheers.

I think even more work went into the Wizard of Oz master than into The Searchers. The latter only looks better because it was shot in VistaVision, which has a higher quality than regular 35mm.

[robertc88]

I didn't check the thread but kudos to whomever (if anyone) listed Letters From Iwo Jima. Eyes wide open when I've watched this BD in the past! It has a great natural like to it and I hope studios take the hint.