Top 10 Youtube Movie Critics

[spanky87]

Kermode is a legit film critic so I'm not including him in this list, but yea that guy is awesome.

Here's my top ten:




(fart noise)

[The Fallen Deity]

The Nostalgia Critic is pretty cool imo.

Sure he hams it up but that's part of his act but he can also be very thoughtful, insightful and non-hammy when he's doing plain old Doug Walker videos.

[JeffTheMovieGuy]

Originally Posted by The Fallen Deity

The Nostalgia Critic is pretty cool imo.

Sure he hams it up but that's part of his act but he can also be very thoughtful, insightful and non-hammy when he's doing plain old Doug Walker videos.

I've gotten kinda sick of his shtick

[Foggy]

Originally Posted by JeffTheMovieGuy

I've gotten kinda sick of his shtick

I'm kinda the same, his older stuff was pretty well done, but his newer stuff has gotten a bit too ambitious that they lack real focus and innovation, instead turning into gimmicks. That and he's just a bit annoying and not nearly as clever as he thinks he is.

[JeffTheMovieGuy]

Originally Posted by Foggy

I'm kinda the same, his older stuff was pretty well done, but his newer stuff has gotten a bit too ambitious that they lack real focus and innovation, instead turning into gimmicks. That and he's just a bit annoying and not nearly as clever as he thinks he is.

His recent Transformers Age of Extinction review really hammered it home for me, I actually turned it off mid way through because I just couldn't take his annoying over the top antics anymore.

[DanTheMan]

Chris Stuckmann
Jeremy Jahns
AMC Movie Talk
Shmoes Know
Screen Junkies (on occasion)
The Flick Pick (also on occasion)

[Lord Method Man]

Originally Posted by JeffTheMovieGuy

I've gotten kinda sick of his shtick

He became insufferable back in 2010.

[JavaJulien]

Originally Posted by JeffTheMovieGuy

I've gotten kinda sick of his shtick

I think the editorials he does are ok, but yeah, it became apparent that the character ran it's course when he tried to retire it, but then his fans threw a fit.

[sega3dmm]

Agreed. RedLetterMedia is such a perfect blend of humor and information. I love what they do.

I also have been watching Jeremy Jahns. Very casual and hardly serious.

CinemaSins got rotten pretty quickly. It first started out pointing out obvious flaws in movies, then the sins are just bad jokes and not about the film at all.

I hate The Nostalgia Critic the more I see him, but I occasionally put on one of his newer videos to admire the awfulness.

[nashcameronn]

I really like Stuckmann. Really respect his opinion and he's very professional.

[Dispatch Ninja]

Just watched some rlm videos and I found them pretty annoying. I'll stick with stuckmann, amc movie talk, and the schmoes.

[Buzz201]

Originally Posted by spanky87

Kermode is a legit film critic so I'm not including him in this list, but yea that guy is awesome.

I'd personally argue YouTube film criticism is "legit", but I see what you mean, which I'm assuming is that he's not an amateur, he works for the BBC on 5live and BBC News, and has a job at the Observer.

One would also point out his YouTube videos all originate from elsewhere, the reviews are from the 5live Film Review, and the Kermode Uncut blogs are all from the BBC website.

[Spirit Zero]

Well I hope you're all voting

Personally I'd like to offer you Oliver Harper for consideration. His reviews are like mini documentaries and give you nice bits of info plus he has a solid retro games channel also.

Movie reviews
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4z..._sLA1TC8_kU0gQ

Retro game reviews
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC7x...eerM7KaFrEr3tw

[mrr1]

I like Red Letter Media the best.

I find that their movie tastes and senses of humor totally jibe with mine.

[MrBlonde]

Originally Posted by mrr1

I like Red Letter Media the best.

I find that their movie tastes and senses of humor totally jibe with mine.

Best of the Worst may be the best thing on the internet.

[mrr1]

'Best of the Worst' is absolutely hysterical.

[Kaiju]

Red Letter Media > Everyone else

Your Movie Sucks is also a solid reviewer... other than that, everyone else is pretty mediocre.

[Trigger89]

FlickPick for me.

[Agent Bond]

My Top 3:

MovieBob

The Guy With The Glasses

ConfusedMatthews

[Foggy]

Originally Posted by MrBlonde

Best of the Worst may be the best thing on the internet.

Actually been slowly been going through there stuff the past couple of weeks after watching there discovery of SOS.