What is the PS3's Best Game (FOR ITS TIME)? Poll

[BigFoot]

Valkyria Chronicles
Uncharted
Uncharted 2

I voted for VC.

[Lt. Aldo Raine]

for its time, i would have to say, drakes fortune, it came out in 2007, and it had amazing graphics and amazing gameplay for a earlier ps3 game, and ppl are still rushing to buy it.

oh and the best game for online play ever is, call of duty 4, maybe a poll soon?

[jeabombers]

I voted "other" for Resistance. As another poster said, it was the ONLY game to own for a long time, and maybe one of the best opening launch week games of all time....

[Beefbowl]

Originally Posted by RatedRstar

As much as I love Uncharted. I went for Killzone because it has the best multiplayer on PS3.

Edit- Where's Resistance? Resistance was the only reason people owned a PS3 for the first 9 months of release.

I was playing Heavenly Sword. Don't remember when that came out though. I voted for Uncharted 2, but now that I think about it, Uncharted DF had more gameplay so I should have voted for the first one.

[detroitechno]

WARHAWK!

1000+ hours and counting...

[Layd Dly]

Metal Gear Solid 4 still takes the cake for me, everything about that game is so detailed and polished. I pray that some day it will get trophies.

But Uncharted and Uncharted 2 are a very close 2nd & 3rd

[Xerios]

Uncharted: Drakes Fortune.. it toook soooo long to get the ball rolling for this game, it was initially a failure and the most unhyped misunderstood game.... once i played it i couldnt help but realize this is pure gaming bliss.... there is no loading time, the game plays as 1 big chapter, you walk right into the next chapter with no loading, thats good developing, the scenery is beautiful, it makes you wonder how lazy some other devs are (Terminator Salvation)

[Hedchekr]

Originally Posted by jeabombers

I voted "other" for Resistance. As another poster said, it was the ONLY game to own for a long time, and maybe one of the best opening launch week games of all time....

Resistance was the only game to get for it. Resistance really wasn't that good of a game though. With how botched Warhawk started out (losing the single player, bad multiplayer at first), I would say that rules that one out.

To me it leaves Uncharted, Uncharted 2, Killzone 2, and Metalgear Solid 4 to battle for the top spot. I voted for Uncharted 2, but later down the road I feel we will have a new champ in God Of War 3!

[ngkf7]

Uncharted...as one of the first games I owned on PS3 it was truly memorable. U2 would be a close second, but there are just so many other fantastic titles out there these days that it doesn't stand out nearly as brightly.

[Terjyn]

Originally Posted by ngkf7

Uncharted...as one of the first games I owned on PS3 it was truly memorable. U2 would be a close second, but there are just so many other fantastic titles out there these days that it doesn't stand out nearly as brightly.

I guess I view this the opposite way. Those other fantastic titles are what makes Uncharted 2 stand out so brightly...as good as those games are they just don't compare.

[Monkey]

I bought Warhawk via download just to get it before the stores. It was fantastic from the first minute I fired it up. True, I was very sad that they didn't keep as single player game. I still think on that incredible engine a single player game would be amazing.

I have to agree on Uncharted 2, the fact that it completely eclipses every other game coming out now is further sign of its greatness, Drake's Fortune was much the same and held the title for best game this generation until its sequel hit. Both games raised the bar several notches on multiple levels when they released.

[GamerPS3-X360]

U2 then U1...

[GLaDOS]

Easiest poll ever: Uncharted 2 is hands down GOTY 2009.

[Morphine]

Something tells me CoD MW2 is going to blow everything out, but is in a genre not every1 likes.

[surfdude12]

why only exclusive? personally if a game kicks a@@, i couldnt care less if its exclusive.

Oblivion: Elder Scrolls IV - still hasn't been matched (for its day), looking at replayability, scope of play and interactivity.

I love Encharted, but I don't think I'll still be playing that 2 years after release like Oblivion

[RatedRstar]

2006 - Resistance
2007 - SP Uncharted, MP Warhawk
2008 - MGS4
2009 - SP Uncharted 2, MP Killzone 2

[Bizdady]

oh Exclusive? Uncharted 2 else Batman Arkham Asylum would be up there.

[Teufel Hunden]

Originally Posted by rike255

warhawk for me. Mgs4 and uncharted 2 are better games, but warhawk definitely was the best "for it's time".

+1

[ksalmon]

Originally Posted by surfdude12

why only exclusive? personally if a game kicks a@@, i couldnt care less if its exclusive.

Oblivion: Elder Scrolls IV - still hasn't been matched (for its day), looking at replayability, scope of play and interactivity.

I love Encharted, but I don't think I'll still be playing that 2 years after release like Oblivion

I second this. Have not seen another game with replayability quite like Oblivion.

[surfdude12]

Originally Posted by ksalmon

I second this. Have not seen another game with replayability quite like Oblivion.

yeah. dont get me wrong, I love Uncharted (have still to play U2), but another thing that made me prefer Oblivion to Uncharted was that Oblivion isn't a linear game like Uncharted (i.e. where you HAVE to proceed in one path or direction through a level). In oblivion, you can proceed through a mission, or just go randomly explore the land. you're not confined to only going in one path/direction. i hope U2 at least has some wrong paths to go down, otherwise its just a matter of finding where "the path" continues.