Rose McGowan and Robert Rodriguez to take on Red Sonja...

[Charles3669]

Originally Posted by Aygie

Ok i'll go paragraph by paragraph,

I never mentioned Art?! I was saying that Sin City is not "his only good film". IT IS A GOOD FILM! Don't get me wrong i love Sin city but i though your statement was too harsh. Sin City IS his most commercial film ( well maybe Once Upon time in Mexico too) in the sense of budget, talent etc.

NOTHING wrong with him making money, as you'll notice i enjoy his work so hell yeah i want him to make money form it.

Spirit comic books don't have the Sin City style. 300 comics don't have the Sin City style. They have their own distinct style and yeah he is copying himself. I this case i dont think its a good thing. Why copy

Sin City stood out from everything else because (like you said) they copied the comics so well, but can you honestly tell me Sin City would be here today without RR? No chance. The amount of crap he had to go through to get Miller to even to talk was ridiculous. Thats why i don't think he deserves as much credit as he got FOR THE FILM! He deserves all credit for writing and art direction but like i said it was RR's talent as a director to bring it to life.

Who do you think was there getting the actors to act? knowing what every piece of green was going to be?

Just a couple of things, if you felt i was attacking you in anyway my apologies, that was not what i was trying to do but don't turn around and stereotype me into "people like you". Like i said i have and love Millers comic work,

Well I thought you were saying that Frank Miller sucked and was giving rodriguez credit for the whole thing but I see what your saying now.

[aygie]

Originally Posted by Charles3669

Well I thought you were saying that Frank Miller sucked and was giving rodriguez credit for the whole thing but I see what your saying now.

Thanks, i appreciate that.

[Bullseye]

Beautiful woman but way too short to play Red Sonja.

[Batman00]

We dont have to worry about Robert and Rose, according to this article they are no longer an item

http://www.thebadandugly.com/2008/07...t’s-good-news/

[aygie]

Originally Posted by Batman00

We dont have to worry about Robert and Rose, according to this article they are no longer an item

http://www.thebadandugly.com/2008/07...t’s-good-news/

Best news i've had all day.