Best intimidating voice and interrogator: TDK's Batman or Watchmen's Rorschach?

[Gamma_Winstead]

Originally Posted by P|-|3@R

Aslo going towards Batman cause that interrogation when he is beating up The Joker, is one of the best interrogation scenes

Rorschach wins... Meat cleaver to the face FTW! Rorschach has no one rule... so that makes him awesome.

[Mike53421]

Originally Posted by gamma626

Rorschach wins... Meat cleaver to the face FTW! Rorschach has no one rule... so that makes him awesome.

Repeatedly. That was awesome how he kept striking him!

You know, the more I think about it, the more I want to rewatch this movie.

[GreenScar]

Here's what the JEH had to say about filming the cleaver scene. Chilling!

AVC: It’s mostly that you’ve spoken often in interviews about what an intense, visceral experience acting is for you. But you’ve never been on such a big-budget, effects-heavy, green-screen movie before. Some actors complain that they don’t get the same charge when the acting is so broken up into tiny scenes, and dependent on the tech.

JEH: You know, it was just so different. It’s kind of like apples and oranges. You’re right, some of it was choppy, but so much of it wasn’t. A lot of the actiony stuff would kind of get choppy, and even some of that scene with Bryce. [Spoiler warning: Bryce is a murderer whom Rorschach kills. —ed.] That, surprisingly, was filmed at two different times. We shot half of it one week, and I thought we were done with it, and then a week later, we were going back in. I’m like, “What are we doing?” And it’s like, “Oh, the dummy’s ready.” And there’s this dummy that looks just like the actor.

And we go back into that room, and that’s such a turning point for this character, so I’m dealing with all of it very—Rorschach’s emotional experience of crossing that line and deciding to forever become Rorschach and leave [his original identity] behind. It was so emotionally charged. For it to be broken up over time, yeah, it’s tough. But at the same time, when we did those moments, we took our time, and it didn’t seem broken-up when were doing it. And it was a trip, too, when we got back and it was time to do the rest of that scene with the dummy. It was freaky, because it was so lifelike. There was something about that… First off, the dummy looked real. Then I took off my glasses, and it looks even more real. Then I put on my hood, and I’m looking through a slight gauze, right? Even more real. Then I’m starting to wield the weapon. The dummy felt incredibly real, and you layer that in on top of emotionally what’s going on with the character, and it was just ****ing freaky.

[Darkhawk9587]

I think it has to be Rorschach. Sure, Batman will smack you around some, but Rorschach is insane and will kill you if you don't give him what he wants. Plus, Bale tried way too hard for Batman's voice in TDK, IMO.

[(Fe)Man]

Rorschach. It's nice to hear what the intimidator's voice is trying to say.

[Blu-Malibu2009]

Originally Posted by (Fe)Man

Rorschach. It's nice to hear what the intimidator's voice is trying to say.

LOL, so true!

My favorite thing about Rorschach is that he breaks people's fingers, etc. Talk about brutal.

[GreenScar]

How about this one?

"Not even in the face of Armageddon. Never compromise."

[Neftali]

Batman sounds like he needs a cough drop!!

[GreenScar]

I would also note that Rorschach and Walter Kovac's voice was the same (no trying to change it) which I thought was pretty cool.

[Blu-Malibu2009]

Originally Posted by jasonbird

I would also note that Rorschach and Walter Kovac's voice was the same (no trying to change it) which I thought was pretty cool.

Well, he was a bit softer with some of the lines as Walter, though when he's pissed he sounds just like Rorschach (such as the "I'm not in here with you, you're in here with me" line).

[STARSCREAM]

I was so close to hitting the button for Batman and then decided to vote both.

[matthieuxdetoux]

Originally Posted by Rev

+ 1000000000

Rorschach's by a mile

+1 more.

It's hard because when your playing Batman you have to do SOMETHING with your voice, unless your George Clooney.

Haley's Rorshach was more low key, and it didn't deviate when he didn't have his mask on which is a definite plus.

[Mike53421]

Originally Posted by matthieuxdetoux

It's hard because when your playing Batman you have to do SOMETHING with your voice, unless your George Clooney.

"I'm uhh, Batman."

I also noticed how mask or no mask he sounded quite similar, that was cool.

[Monkey]

I love the Batman movies but I don't like Bale's voice as Batman.

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by Darkhawk9587

I think it has to be Rorschach. Sure, Batman will smack you around some, but Rorschach is insane and will kill you if you don't give him what he wants. Plus, Bale tried way too hard for Batman's voice in TDK, IMO.

exactly you just can't mess arounf with that dude

[SquidPuppet]

Originally Posted by blu-mike

a write in for jack bauer lol

+1

[SS316SRV]

Johnny Depp as the Riddler.