Push vs Jumper!

[Jtodd]

Just wanted to know what movie everyone thought was better.I just watched push lastnight after a blind purchase and thought it was a excellent movie and well done! However i still think jumper was alittle bit better.Either way i like both movies!

[Batman1980]

I still haven't seen Jumper so I have to go with Push for sure.

[Jtodd]

Originally Posted by Wolverine1980

I still haven't seen Jumper so I have to go with Push for sure.

Yeah push was surprisingly good!

[mugupo]

I think acting and plot is better in push.
Push is focus in one area (Hong Kong)
While Jumpers is in many places
The GCI is better done in jumpers, especially the scene of bus and car jump.
The ending plot from push is brilliant while jumper is let down.

I like push better cause of the story plot and has many chinese language spoke in the film which i understand them. Jumper to me is more like a reference disk to show the good cgi.

[aramis109]

To me, it's sad how similar these movies were. However, I liked Push better. Jumper bothered me in a number of scenes (including the baton-weapons that didn't really work). There were some things in Push that I thought were really clever (and some that were really inane too). Overall, I'm debating picking up Push and would never get Jumper personally.

Also- casting. I don't like Hayden and think that Sam Jackson is completely overrated, while Push has Djimon and Dakota Fanning.

[GhOsTGrEgG]

I think Push was a terrible movie. Jumper was better in my opinion. Jumper was simple and to the point. Push has too many different "abilities" that they never really went far into. The Asian girls future seeing ability was totally different from the little girls future seeing ability? That aspect seemed to draw me away from the whole powers idea.

Atleast in Jumper you had much better special effects and Different locations to look at.

I'm a tough critic when a movie just doesn't grab me and pull me in. Push was not one of those movies.

Glad I did not blind buy.

[aramis109]

Originally Posted by GhOsTGrEgG

I think Push was a terrible movie. Jumper was better in my opinion. Jumper was simple and to the point. Push has too many different "abilities" that they never really went far into. The Asian girls future seeing ability was totally different from the little girls future seeing ability? That aspect seemed to draw me away from the whole powers idea.

Atleast in Jumper you had much better special effects and Different locations to look at.

I'm a tough critic when a movie just doesn't grab me and pull me in. Push was not one of those movies.

Glad I did not blind buy.

It's your opinion, and I'm not trying to change you on it, but there's no reason that their abilities wouldn't manifest themselves in different ways. We're not talking super-powers here, we're talking about psionics here. Mental abilities could work in multiple ways.

[GhOsTGrEgG]

Originally Posted by aramis109

It's your opinion, and I'm not trying to change you on it, but there's no reason that their abilities wouldn't manifest themselves in different ways. We're not talking super-powers here, we're talking about psionics here. Mental abilities could work in multiple ways.

OK, I can see you point. But they should not throw stuff into a movie and then just "make it work" for the plot to progress. That seemed like a forced script addition. Like .. during the writing of the script someone said. Wait a minute.. how do we explain how if two people can see the future, why does one see the outcome differently than the other..? I have an idea. lets make one of the girls see decisions your going to make in the future rather than what actually happens.. But ONLY for one part of the movie.. the rest she can see what happens just fine..

Its just too "thrown in" for me.

[chewbacca511]

Originally Posted by GhOsTGrEgG

I think Push was a terrible movie. Jumper was better in my opinion. Jumper was simple and to the point. Push has too many different "abilities" that they never really went far into. The Asian girls future seeing ability was totally different from the little girls future seeing ability? That aspect seemed to draw me away from the whole powers idea.

Atleast in Jumper you had much better special effects and Different locations to look at.

I'm a tough critic when a movie just doesn't grab me and pull me in. Push was not one of those movies.

Glad I did not blind buy.

i agree. I watched push, and really didnt like it, a concept that could have been awesome, ends up crap, lol

[PS3-Playb3yond]

I would pick Jumper. I was really disappointed with Push. I guess I had high expections from it.

[My_Two_Cents]

Hmmmmmm....

dog turd vs. goose crap - which one would you rather step in?

[Deadset]

Originally Posted by Ricshoe

Hmmmmmm....

dog turd vs. goose crap - which one would you rather step in?

I'd have to say goose crap edges out dog turd by the white crusties...whew that was a close one!!

[dolphinc]

I say, go ahead and Push that Jumper. Moron should not be on that building anyway.

[iori]

Push is way better than jumper.

[ScarredLungs]

Originally Posted by JHM

Push is way better than jumper.

Indeed, I concur. Push was a blind buy and I really enjoyed it. I thought it was way better then Jumper.

[inzanee]

Didn't really like either, but if i had to choose i'd say push.

[langn08]

I am going to go with Jumper

[AcePunK]

Originally Posted by langn08

I am going to go with Jumper

+1

[Jtodd]

Originally Posted by Ricshoe

Hmmmmmm....

dog turd vs. goose crap - which one would you rather step in?

Neither thats why that wasnt the question,if you dont like either dont bash the topic by showing how funny you really arent!

[My_Two_Cents]

Originally Posted by Jtodd

Neither thats why that wasnt the question,if you dont like either dont bash the topic by showing how funny you really arent!

Take a pill and lighten-up a bit, dude.

You asked a question, and did not specify you only wanted responses with which you argreed. So, to make my response a little more clear for the comedy-challenged, I'd have to vote 'neither' as they were both terrible movies. In my humble opinion, of course.