Make Mine Music and Melody Time Blu-rays from Disney Movie Club

[Block-Busted]

So did anything happen to Make Mine Music yet?

[Class316]

Originally Posted by Block-Busted

So did anything happen to Make Mine Music yet?

Yes but not by Disney.

[Block-Busted]

Originally Posted by Class316

Yes but not by Disney.

There's an uncut version? Where is it?

[Block-Busted]

Oh, and it looks like aside from the first segment not being available, the film doesn't seem to be missing a scene or frame.

[Mayboy128]

Originally Posted by Block-Busted

Oh, and it looks like aside from the first segment not being available, the film doesn't seem to be missing a scene or frame.

DMC’s version, or Jack Sparrow’s?

[gwfb5]

Originally Posted by Block-Busted

Oh, and it looks like aside from the first segment not being available, the film doesn't seem to be missing a scene or frame.

Not sure if you're being sarcastic, but just in case, the official BD has some censorship in the All the Cats Join In segment.

[Show spoiler]

Nowhere near as egregious as removing an entire segment, but still worth mentioning.

[WonkaBedknobs83]

Disney proper (as opposed to Touchstone, Hollywood Pictures, Fox, or Miramax) is actually more prudish now than they were under Walt or his son-in-law. How is that possible?

[Block-Busted]

Originally Posted by gwfb5

Not sure if you're being sarcastic, but just in case, the official BD has some censorship in the All the Cats Join In segment.

[Show spoiler]

Nowhere near as egregious as removing an entire segment, but still worth mentioning.

That's kind of what I meant. At least we won't have a jarring cut in that segment.

[Block-Busted]

Originally Posted by WonkaBedknobs83

Disney proper (as opposed to Touchstone, Hollywood Pictures, Fox, or Miramax) is actually more prudish now than they were under Walt or his son-in-law. How is that possible?

Well, standards of what kids are allowed to see in films and TV series have changed over the years.

[Mayboy128]

Originally Posted by Block-Busted

Well, standards of what kids are allowed to see in films and TV series have changed over the years.

But how many parents are buying Make Mine Music exclusively from the Disney Movie Club for their kids without knowing something about the film already? None I know. The parents I personally know barely seem to use physical media at all, and they try to make due with what they find appropriate on streaming services and YouTube.
Even if there were some, if Disney really wanted to appeal to both them and film fans (I really think the latter would make up the bulk of sales for the old package films), they could easily have a “family-friendly” version and the uncut version on the same disc with seamless branching. Which gets me back to the same question I’ve had time and time again: Who is the DMC for? It seems outdated for normies and too basic, corporatized, sanitized, and low-effort for film fans.

[Class316]

C'mon now, nothing wrong with this bit of nudity. So what if kids see it?

I should add, there's nudity in the Pastoral Symphony of Fantasia, and that was never cut.

[gwfb5]

Originally Posted by Class316

C'mon now, nothing wrong with this bit of nudity. So what if kids see it?

I should add, there's nudity in the Pastoral Symphony of Fantasia, and that was never cut.

Don't forget all the nudity in the Night on Bald Mountain segment, which has thankfully never been censored on any release. (AFAIK)




How is this shot in particular less risqué than the split second of side-boob in MMM?


Censorship is bullsh*t!

[WaverBoy]

So glad I have the uncut version of MMM.

[Eucube92]

Can someone who has the uncut version of Make Mine Music, in decent quality, contact me privately?

[Class316]

I agree with the above. Baffling why that frame of MMM is censored yet Fantasia has all the boobs. And nothing wrong with boobs either way. Nudity is God made. Clothes are man made.

Censorship is evil. Studios subscribe to that evil. Be it MMM, Fantasia, or otherwise. Hence why people turn to other ways. By the way for those who haven't look at this post I made in a Fantasia thread: https://forum.blu-ray.com/showpost.p...postcount=2594

[Dan_Shane]

I suspect the censoring happened because the girl is supposed to be a minor, so I wouldn't call the removal "baffling." I do consider it unnecessary, but I get the logic.