Stargate: SG-1 Vs SGA Vs SGU

[Cinemave]

Stargate SG-1. Ten glorious seasons of gate-jumping goodness.

[Elandyll]

Sorry... I know that (apparently most) SG-1 fans depised SG-U, but it was such a breath of fresh air that I still mourn it.
With such a great start in 2 short seasons, who knows what levels of greatness the show would have reached when at maturity (generally around season 4 for most series)?
I guess at least we still get to enjoy the great Robert Carlyle in OuaT...

[DasManiac]

Loved SGU, liked SG-1, hated Atlantis. SGU was a rare show that challenged its audience to think and did not deserve the hate it got from people. It wasn't remotely similar to Battlestar Galactica and was a one of kind show. SG-1 was a pretty good show though it really only got great in its final few seasons. The go a'uld arc lasted for a few too many seasons and there were too many filler episodes like Buffy. That said though the show drastically improved with Seasons Nine and Ten. Atlantis had a lot of potential but wasted it with its lousy first three seasons. Too much reliance on the SG-1 formula rather than trying something different SGU.

[lazystoner]

I enjoyed all of them, but SGU the most. It was fresh and exciting. So much potential to surpass the other shows, but was squandered with its cancellation.

[MarcelS1]

Love them all. In the past SG-1 was my favorite but over the last few years this has changed for me to Atlantis.

[AeroK]

Atlantis

[Mr. Forest]

1. Stargate: SG-1 (1997-2007) - 5/5
2. Stargate: Atlantis (2004-2009) - 4.5/5
3. Stargate: Universe (2009-2011) - 4/5

[Captain Flint]

SG-1 is my favorite show of all time. I've seen bits and pieces of Atlantis and didn't really like it, but that was a long time ago. I'll be watching that show from beginning to end very soon. Universe sucked for me really bad. I only ever watched the pilot and that was seriously underwhelming.

[JeffTheMovieGuy]

SG-1 is my favorite and I actually miss those characters. Atlantis was an interesting venture into a different part of the galaxy which was not bad. SGU had potential if they were only given more time and space to stretch out before SciFi shat the bed.

It's a shame we will never see a conclusion to SGU with Elias controlling the ship.

[bonifac81]

SG-1
SGA
SGU

I just wish SG1 came out on BD. I'd probably faint from the excitement though. .

[i007spectre]

My SG1 Garrison and Offworld cosplay should tell you which is my favorite. But I love all of them.

[Geza83]

SG-1
SGA
SGU

I just rewatched SGA, now I'm onto SG-1, actually I'm already in the middle of season 3. Still a great show.

[Gamma_Winstead]

Might have to do a re-watch as well. It's been years since I've seen the shows. I miss them. Really wish we'd have gotten some new (good) content since U went off the air. Heck, I'd take a small mini-series.

[jedidaniel]

Stargate: SG-1

[mikezilla2]

SG1 easily

[LexInHD]

I ended up liking SGA after watching the series when it hit Blu-Ray - I didn't watch it when it was airing because I was into other shows at the time - and I loved SGU when it was on. I have sort of warmed up to SG-1 via streaming, but it's not something I greatly enjoy watching, though the later seasons are solid and on par with SGA in my opinion.