|
|
![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||
|
Best Blu-ray Movie Deals
|
Best Blu-ray Movie Deals, See All the Deals » |
Top deals |
New deals
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
![]() €39.99 16 hrs ago
| ![]() €12.10 4 hrs ago
| ![]() €17.14 6 hrs ago
| ![]() €14.99 | ![]() €15.00 | ![]() €29.99 | ![]() €24.99 | ![]() €9.99 | ![]() €14.87 | ![]() €15.00 | ![]() €49.99 | ![]() €19.99 |
![]() |
#1 | |
Blu-ray reviewer
|
![]()
Lola Blu-ray PRE-ORDER
![]() NEWS https://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=9449 Quote:
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
#5 | |
Blu-ray reviewer
|
![]()
RDA:
Our disc is in transit somewhere, but it is coming later because it is bundled with Polanski's Tess. As I mentioned above, we will have a full review. I am attaching the official press sheet from Arte that confirms that the English subs from the DVD have been ported: http://download.pro.arte.tv/uploads/...-COMPLET-3.pdf And here's some additional info on the restoration. I assume you are fluent in French (there is some English text as well): http://www.fondation-groupama-gan.co...OLA_DP_V19.pdf From Mathieu*: Quote:
![]() Pro-B **Please see and support Mathieu's fantastic debut, one of the year's best films ![]() ![]() Last edited by pro-bassoonist; 11-28-2012 at 09:51 AM. |
|
![]() |
![]() |
#7 | |
Active Member
Jul 2009
|
![]() Quote:
![]() for "La Baie des Anges", is it a with or do you have an info that this is the next blu-ray planned by Cine Tamaris/Arte ? I was expecting Les Parapluies de Cherbourg (after all it is already available in Japan on Blu-Ray).. I've been looking forward for your review of Lola, but a few screenshots have been posted here and if this tends to be accurate captures of the Blu-Ray (and not a TV HD broadcast (which I'm afraid it's not the case - apparently it's the Blu-Ray) it's...well.... ![]() ![]() ![]() http://criterionforum.org/forum/view...412713#p412713 that's one of my XMas present... to be found under the XMas tree... hope your review will don't confirm this... if this is the case, well December 21 already happened... I don't know - if this turns out to be true - what happens in France... restoration documentation are always talking about potential; looks promising (there's even some short documentary of the restoration even before the blu-ray release- those about Lola can be found on youtube), and I don't know if someone is unleashed with the DNR joystick or sit on it and ruin the blu-ray in its last stage of production, but it's sad... Last edited by RupertPupkin; 11-29-2012 at 06:40 AM. Reason: adding link - and being sorry for my English (but I'm French, and for being from this Blu-Ray DNR country...) |
|
![]() |
![]() |
#8 | |
Blu-ray reviewer
|
![]() Quote:
Get the disc, see the film/presentation, offer an opinion if you wish. The disc may very well turn out to be disappointing, but the right thing to do is actually have the product in your hands before criticizing someone else's work - because most certainly there are real people behind these restorations, transfers, etc. Anyway, Rupert, our disc is in transit, and as soon as it arrives I will post our review. I love this film, though a little less than Bay of Angels. Mathieu did the grading, so I hope that it is at least a decent release. ![]() I don't have a date for Bay of Angels yet. Pro-B p.s. Do you need region coding info on Americano? I could check my disc and update the profile. |
|
![]() |
![]() |
#9 | |
Active Member
Jul 2009
|
![]() Quote:
generally I try to find full resolution captures before ordering a blu-ray (especially in France), because recently I've been scalded to say the least. Before, it was much more a matter of excitation to see the first captures than the fear of a "hit or miss Blu-Ray". If some captures are really frightening (alert DNR!) I prefer to cancel my order (if some blu-ray test reviews, later, tends to temper the picture quality impressions or to invalidate the first captures, then it'll be time to re-order it). Had this Blu-Ray be not a XMas present, I would have canceled my pre-order. And your right about the resolution of the capture and I can not judge a blu-ray I haven't seen. That's why I wrote "if it turns out to be true"... I'm just very worried about these captures and was expecting some feedbacks from people who would already have bought it who could tell me that "no there is still grain, it's not another DNR disaster". I put my trust on Arte videos. And my love goes to Cine Tamaris. "Les Demoiselles de Rochefort" has great picture quality and there is absolutely nothing to complain about DNR on this blu-ray. So I was totally confident about "Lola"... Please undertand my ![]() I'm really looking forward for your review now ![]() (so far, no captures have been posted on some Blu-Ray French sites or forums...) it's kind of funny (well, not so...) that we have to wait for people like you to order from "outside" a blu-ray in France to get a proper review. I put my trust (and my money (because blu-ray in France are expensive) in a site like blu-ray.com Fortunately blu-ray.com was there to warn me about a disappointing transfer of "Bande à Part" (gasp) About Mathieu Demy's blu-ray.... it's listed as region A. Perhaps you could confirm if this is the case or not ? Last edited by RupertPupkin; 11-29-2012 at 07:23 AM. |
|
![]() |
![]() |
#10 |
Blu-ray reviewer
|
![]()
I most definitely understand, Rupert, and I agree with you.
Unfortunately, I could not get an early screener for this release, and I was a bit sick so fell behind on some reviews. But as I mentioned earlier, we will have a review. What I wanted to convey to you is that I don't like this recent practice/trend where people 'authoritatively' dismiss someone else's work without having even looked at the disc. It is not right. That's all. As far as Lola is concerned, all of the info on the restoration is in the press sheet I posted above. It is also in French ![]() I personally was very happy with Arte's Les demoiselles de Rochefort. ![]() As you know well, it is also a CineTamaris project. ![]() We will have to wait and see. Pro-B p.s. Americano is tested only for Region-A. B and C are untested. Hold on a minute, please. I will update it now. p.s. I just tested Americano. It is indeed Region-A "locked". Last edited by pro-bassoonist; 11-29-2012 at 07:51 AM. |
![]() |
![]() |
#11 |
Active Member
Jul 2009
|
![]()
some real captures of the Blu-Ray have been just posted on dvdclassik French forum, thanks to Geoffrey Firmin
![]() it's difficult to judge a Blu-Ray just from the captures, but whereas it's obviously HD there's clearly a lack of grain. Last edited by RupertPupkin; 11-29-2012 at 10:04 AM. |
![]() |
![]() |
#13 |
Blu-ray Baron
|
![]()
I wonder about this everyday - a country that loves cinema and has great video releases, but when it comes to finding accurate video information from French websites, it's like France becomes a third-world country. Unless there are some great French websites that we don't know about?
|
![]() |
![]() |
#14 | |
Active Member
Jul 2009
|
![]() Quote:
![]() I don't know in .fr and I'm still looking for a place which would focuse on the French Blu-Ray (French movies; or movies which are exclusive in France (you'll find more info in the blu-ray.forum section) releases... you can check : http://www.dvdfr.com dvdclassik French forum has now a capture section with some "real screenshots" I don't trust that much the reviews on Ecran Large, but they did post some early captures of the last Gaumont "Bande à Part" / "La Chinoise"; but blu-ray.com was faster... http://www.devildead.com is a great French site when you like SF / horror / fantastic movies... I highly recommend this site. I use to visit it since 10 years or something like that... Dorian Gray forum is a great place ton find some captures of some various DVD/Blu-Ray to see the difference (cropping, color) between each different releases... (from Argento to Melville's Le Cercle Rouge / Le Samourai, to John Carpenter...) But if you are looking for a site with captures + review; and which will test a blu-ray when it came out (so you can decide if you will order or not a title), I haven't find such a site in France so far... And I'm not talking about pre-test (such as dvdbeaver or blu-ray.com) which allow you to cancel your pre-order, I haven't find such site in France. I'll take 2 examples : when Mk2 releases the Kielowski "3 colors" box set + La Vie de Véronique, the first captures were posted on : forums.highdefdigest.com this is there where I was warned about the 1080i encoding. "Bande à Part" (Gaumont) : first review and first captures on blu-ray.com... (and I looked every day with google on several French web site...) judging the captures and my tolerance about DNR I was able to cancel my pre-orer (thanks again to blu-ray.com) Blu-Ray are expensive in many countries, and this is the case in France; so this kind of "alert" (1080i, excessive DNR, disappointing release, etc...) is a good thing to save your money; for a better release... of course you'll find in France a pre-release review of Prometheus or The Dark Knight Rises... but when it's French movies; or some more "arty" release such as "Moonrise Kingdome"; it was too late when I bought my French Blu-Ray (StudioCanal) to realize that the US Blu-Ray, altough respecting the 16mm photography, has better bitrate, and more HD details. (I bought the US version, so I've been able to compare both releases - I have a full HD projector - the US version have more details, better "3D" feeling (I mean depth, like in the theatrical release, with the backgrounds, landscapes, etc...) it's even impossible to trust some site like ecran-large about the 1080p24 encoding. You read it's 1080p24, and it turns out that it is 1080i even if in all other countries it has been released in 1080p24 (Stephen Frears's Tamara Drewe for instance is in 1080i) Last edited by RupertPupkin; 12-02-2012 at 06:48 AM. |
|
![]() |
![]() |
#15 | |
Blu-ray Baron
|
![]() Quote:
French Blu-rays aren't that expensive - I really can't believe that there isn't one person in France with a blu-ray review website/blog that isn't reviewing French films released on Blu-ray. Tres bizarre! ![]() |
|
![]() |
![]() |
#19 |
Active Member
Jul 2009
|
![]()
I watched it yesterday and was very pleased with the transfer...
Sometimes screenshots (those posted on dvdclassik) which frightened don't translate what the film will look like in motion (after all this is a movie); albeit, of course, you can spot excessive DNR on a screenshot. I'm glad that I didn't cancel my order. Well, I didn't need to read to booklet (and/or see the restoration bonus; I did after) to be pleased with the picture quality - I don't like to read how much difficulty they had for the restoration, I like to enjoy the movie first without knowning all these details and well the transfert looks "real" and sometimes great. In a nutshell, I enjoyed the movie (I already saw it on TV, VHS, DVD, etc...) without thinking what the hell they have done with the picture, etc... I don't notice excessive DNR (altough there has been "digital manipulation" that's sure, there is a slight grain. (I've been uncomfortable to see the "door" example footage in the restoration bonus; but I wouldn't have noticed it if I hadn't see this documentary) It doesn't seem to betray the work of Raoul Coutard. What I've seen is close to my memory and the last vision of the movie : that's just that it looks better; it's high def, there is real depth, so it's really film-like, sometimes some shots are magnificiant (really this particular white and black which I've always associated to this movie) ![]() In a nutshell, I was in a familiar world, Lola's world; but I've never seen this movie with such quality. The French scope format is excellent; it reminds me the Shoot The Piano Player... now I understand that Mathieu Demy was pleased with the transfer. We'll discover in the booklet that the original negative has burnt in 1970. So it's a bit of miracle here. Would have the blu-ray more HD details if the original was still there? I don't know... So it won't be a 4.5/5 or 5/5 like on Les Demoiselles de Rochefort; but certainly not a 1/5... Really I was afraid of a Gaumont syndrome, but here I'm very pleased.... What I don't understand is why Raoul Coutard (which is said to have been here for the first step of the restoration process) wasn't there for the digital restoration at Technicolor, L.A. Perhaps he is very ill ? ![]() I don't understand, because - IMHO - he was behind the camera. When you see his recent interview footage about his memory about "Week end", he says that he didn't see the movie since its theatrical release (1967) but he remembers everything. oh, and in the blu-ray there is a Arte/Ciné Tamaris catalog and it seems that "Donkey Skin"/Peau d'Âne will be the next 2013 Blu-Ray title... another delicious Catherine Deneuve on Blu-Ray ![]() ![]() well, I'm waiting for your review; and please a lot of screenshots of Lola ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#20 |
Blu-ray reviewer
|
![]()
Hello Rupert,
Merry Christmas to you and your entire family. I was not active for 4 days as I fell very sick (flu complications). I am getting back to normal now but everything will be moving slower for some days, perhaps another week. I will respond to your PMs tomorrow. The review is also coming up. Merry Christmas to everyone in France. Pro-B |
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
|
|