Isn't it a purist argument in both cases? I know people like HDGoofnut who only buy films shot in 3D on 3D blu tend to say that's because of purism and wanting to see movies how they were shot and intended to be seen, etc. Same with people not looking to get UHDs based on HDR, which they often see as revisionist.
Not saying these are my opinions, just examining those who say these things. 3D gives me a headache and doesn't excite me so you can shoot a 3D movie in 3D all day long and tell me that's the intended experience but I'm still watching it in 2D.
|