V for Vendetta review!?

[i JACK o]

https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/V-for...ay-Review/744/

i respect the rating of the film but if you read the final words, it seems like the reviewer is only stating posotives about the film, as if he gave it a 5, when it is quite the contrary

[Clark Kent]

Nine different reviews for "V for Vendetta" on Blu-ray:

http://www.hddb.net/reviews/v-for-ve...217414-blu-ray

The graphic novel was much, much better and more sophisticated in tone.

[i JACK o]

Originally Posted by Clark Kent

Nine different reviews for "V for Vendetta" on Blu-ray:

http://www.hddb.net/reviews/v-for-ve...217414-blu-ray

The graphic novel was much, much better and more sophisticated in tone.

i wasnt looking for reviews you might wanna re read the initial post

[donaldheil]

Originally Posted by i JACK o

https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/V-for...ay-Review/744/

i respect the rating of the film but if you read the final words, it seems like the reviewer is only stating posotives about the film, as if he gave it a 5, when it is quite the contrary

Yeah, you're right. It's kinda weird.

I think the movie and the whole BD deserve THOSE words, not THAT rating. Anyway, it looks like you agree with the rating...

Since his review is SO positive, it makes me wonder what it will take for the reviewer to grant a 4.5 or 5 qualification to a BD.

By the way, I think blu-ray.com should allow us to review the reviewer, maybe in a section of short opinions below the whole thing.

[i JACK o]

Originally Posted by donaldheil

Yeah, you're right. It's kinda weird.

I think the movie and the whole BD deserve THOSE words, not THAT rating. Anyway, it looks like you agree with the rating...

Since his review is SO positive, it makes me wonder what it will take for the reviewer to grant a 4.5 or 5 qualification to a BD.

By the way, I think blu-ray.com should allow us to review the reviewer, maybe in a section of short opinions below the whole thing.

agreed on all counts id say the movie deserves a 4 though it kept me entertained for the entire runtime

[Batman1980]

It wouldn't make my top 5, that's a jumbled mess but it would probably make my top 10 all time comic book films list. Featuring excellent writing, stand-out performances and well choreographed fights, one of my top 100 movies of all-time for sure.

[Lt. Aldo Raine]

yea its like a different reviewer wrote the conclusion for him
after reading that conclusion i thought it would've had higher scores all around

[KilloWertz]

It is an odd review given the closing and the score, but in the end, it doesn't matter to me. I'm more than happy to have it in my collection.

[Adrock]

Originally Posted by killowertz

I'm more than happy to have it in my collection.

+1.