Alien Plot-holes

[J-Syxx]

Originally Posted by s2mikey

Ya know - you're right, its all there in the COMIC book. Comics have NOTHING to with anything so Im glad you guys have the time and inclination to read the comics. All the cool pictures. Great. Way to put on a display of your immense intelligence and IQ. Im impressed. Maybe you can find a popup book for Alien 3 too and refer to that from now on.

The egg-laying with NO sac is "canon"? From what? Some dorky comic book? Noone cares about comic books and they have nothing to do with blu-ray discs.

Its a plot hole - the entire world except for 2-3 people here know that to be a fact so keep spewing the "Im smart and you're not" BS. Its entertaining if not somewhat sad. Oh wait - It was Bishops next door neighbors best friends brother that planted the egg. My bad. See - I thought about it. I feel smarter now.

Even if we take away the GAPING plot hole, the movie still sucks and is considered a disaster of epic proportions by 99% of the population. Even most of the people involved in making the film know its a mess. Glad thats settled.

It's not a plot hole, and anyone who thinks it is one is slow and doesn't understand what a plot hole is.

The entire premise was built upon the fact tha an egg or eggs got aboard the Sullaco, more than likely via the queen. They just chose to not show it on screen to keep it more mysterious. Do you understand that, genius? A big part of the plot of the first part of this movie is about whether or not an Alien actually made it onto Fury 161. Showing a lot of the Alien on screen before that, and spelling it all out for the audience, works against that theme. Please read that several times so it soaks in a bit.

Again, a plot hole is something accidental. You may as well be calling Ripley being lost in space for 50 years a plot hole becuase it doesn't sound plausible or the eggs in the diralect being a plot hole because how they got there isn't explained. Stop being rediculous. Just because you don't like the movie, doesn't mean you get to redefine words or accuse David Fincher or being an idiot.

Yes, eggs were placed on the Sulacco in Alien 3 canon. Notice how you don't see the ****ing queen untill she pops out and slices Bishop in half. If we saw the queen the whole damn time, you would have a point, but you don't at all. The fact that Alien biology was added onto with Alien 3 also doesn't prove your point or else the queen herself would be a "plot hole."

And Alien 3 really isn't that unpopular anymore. The extended cut has made people realize it actually has some merit.