HP: Order of Phoenix review on Audio?

[sphdle1]

I checked out the review on HP: OOTP & it seems to get a rave review on both audio and video, but I am wondering why they only scored the audio a 4.5, when it has a full PCM track on it, and they had nothing but positive things to say about it...?

I can understand maybe the video because of the VC-1 track, but even still they say it's better than '300' and have nothing but good to say about it, and still only give it a 4.5

Does anyone know if the HDUD version has a PCM track & what score(s) is it getting in comparison to Blu?

[cking2729]

If I'm not mistaken HDD gave it 5 Star audio. No offense to anyone here of course, but I put their reviews before all else because they are almost always spot on. I am a pretty big fan of Peter Bracke. They said it was nothing short of an amazing audio track.

From what I've seen the Blu gets PCM and Standard 5.1, as well as audio in about every language imaginable. DuD version gets their TrueHD and a few other lousy options. No PCM for them or anything mindblowing.

HDD appears to be down this morning, but here is the link for when the site is up and running again
http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/1121...hephoenix.html