Official BD forum PQ tier thread

[redlikefire02]

Discription:

Tier 0 would be reference material and have no artifacs with a pure and clean picture

5/5 = Tier 0
4.5/5 = Tier 1
4/5 = Tier 1
3.0-4.0 = Tier 2
2.0-3.0 = Tier 3
1.0-2.0 = Tier 4


Tier 0

i, robot
cars
Ratatoullie
Speed Racer
POTC 1
POTC 2
POTC 3
Shoot Em' Up
Crank
Corpse Bride
Spiderman 3
No Country For Old Men
Kill Bill Volume 1



Tier 1

Kill Bill Volume 2
Transformers
Casino Royale
Planet Earth: The Complete Collection
Troy
300 (grain is intentional)
Apocolypto
Spiderman 1
Spiderman 2
Shooter
I Am Legend
The Simpsons
Blade Runner
Doomsday
Deja Vu
Enchanted
Black Hawk Down
Batman Begins
The Messengers
Shutter
Sunshine
Hellboy
Happy Feet
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
The Exorcism of Emily Rose
The Patriot
The Eye
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
Fantastic Four: ROSS
The Rock
Rambo
Mr and Mrs Smith
The Ant Bully
National Treasure 2
Underworld (Unrated)
The Fifth Element (Remastered)
The Polar Express
Remember the Titans
Semi-Pro
Appleseed Ex Machina
Kingdom of Heaven
The Prestige
Flyboys
The Brave One
Pan's Labyrinth
Bikini Destinations - Triple Fantasy Video
National Treasure
The Bank Job
21



Tier 2


Tier 3
National Lampoons: Van Wilder

Tier 4
The Fifth Element (origional)
The Punisher




Pretty much borrowed this idea from AVS but we really need one and im sick of going over there and its been months upon months since an update. i would appreciate everyones help and im ALWAYS online here to update. this would also reduce the number of new and useless threads by noobs asking what are the best to buy. i started the thread with the ones i know are unanimus. notice the RED is the bad

[JasonR]

Nomination for tier 0

Kill Bill Volume 1 & 2
No Country For Old Men

[redlikefire02]

i want everyone to remember that EVERYTHING cant be in 0 only the BEST of the BEST!!

[Alan Gordon]

Originally Posted by redlikefire02

i want everyone to remember that EVERYTHING cant be in 0 only the BEST of the BEST!!

I don't go for "Tier" lists, so I'd rather Blu-ray.com stay away from them myself, but if one were to be made, there is NO WAY "Troy" would be in "Tier 1". "Tier 3" at best.

~Alan

[BluLuzzo]

I would agree with POTC being in tier 0... as well as Bee Movie...

Tier 1 - Nightmare before Christmas, The Shining

Teir 3-4 300

[redlikefire02]

Originally Posted by Alan Gordon

I don't go for "Tier" lists, so I'd rather Blu-ray.com stay away from them myself, but if one were to be made, there is NO WAY "Troy" would be in "Tier 1". "Tier 3" at best.

~Alan

well its here now, this isnt a dictatorship. lol. either you can participate and we take your opinion seriously and put it to good use or dont come to the thread. its simple.

and have you seen the detail in troy with the armour and water as well as fight scenes its definately tier 1

[Judgmentday2007]

for tier 0 you got to have Caino Royale in there
but for tier 1 I would like to nominate flight of the pheonix that looked so awsome

[Blu Titan]

Originally Posted by Judgmentday2007

for tier 0 you got to have Caino Royale in there
but for tier 1 I would like to nominate flight of the pheonix that looked so awsome

Casino Royale is Tier 0, or whatever tier corresponds to the highest PQ.

[BStecke]

Originally Posted by BluLuzzo

Teir 3-4 300

This is one of many reasons why tier threads don't work.

[MarekM]

Originally Posted by BStecke

This is one of many reasons why tier threads don't work.

+1

Marek

[Clark Kent]

I think the idea of a tier thread for PQ here is a good idea. There is also a list over at HDD for reference.

[GORT]

The problem with this and any other thread like it is that its based on someones opinion and post #5 in here about 300 is proof they dont work

[redlikefire02]

Originally Posted by Clark Kent

I think the idea of a tier thread for PQ here is a good idea. There is also a list over at HDD for reference.

thanks kent lol id rather have one at this site bc i know i can trust people here vs. others. tier threads DO work and ive based many of my purchases on them AND the words of others. and id rather have one here then none at all.

[Teabaggins]

where would you put the NEW version of the Fifth Element? I love the movie and am thinking about buying it

[Marine Mike]

Originally Posted by Teabaggins

where would you put the NEW version of the Fifth Element? I love the movie and am thinking about buying it

I personally would put it in the Tier 0 as I find it to be definate Reference Material in the Video and Audio department.

[Teabaggins]

awesome, thanks. that sounds great

[mikejet]

Transformers isn't Tier 0?

I know The Fall is Tier 0.

[Barbie-Shrimp]

Where's 2001?

[stockstar1138]

my corrections:

Tier 0 should not be about a pure, clean picture, it should be about accuratly representing the director's intent for how the movie should look.

POTC 1 should be taken out of Tier 0 and placed in Tier 1
No Country for Old Men should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 0
Transforemers should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 0
Planet Earth should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 2 or possibly 3
300 should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 2
Troy should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 2
Batman Begins should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 3
Blade Runner should be take out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 0

Additions:
2001: A Space Odyssey should be placed in Tier 1
The Shining should be placed in Tier 1
Close Encounters of the Third Kind should be placed in Tier 0
A Few Good Men should be added to Tier 1
Cloverfield should be added to Tier 0
Ice Age 2: The Meltdown should be added to Tier 1
The Departed should be added to Tier 2
Finding Neverland should be added to Tier 4
Van Wilder should be added to Tier 4
The Untoucables should be added to Tier 1
Full Metal Jacket should be added to Tier 2
Surf's Up should be added to Tier 0

[mikejet]

Originally Posted by stockstar1138

my corrections:

Tier 0 should not be about a pure, clean picture, it should be about accuratly representing the director's intent for how the movie should look.

POTC 1 should be taken out of Tier 0 and placed in Tier 1
No Country for Old Men should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 0
Transforemers should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 0
Planet Earth should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 2 or possibly 3
300 should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 2
Troy should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 2
Batman Begins should be taken out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 3
Blade Runner should be take out of Tier 1 and placed in Tier 0

Additions:
2001: A Space Odyssey should be placed in Tier 1
The Shining should be placed in Tier 1
Close Encounters of the Third Kind should be placed in Tier 0
A Few Good Men should be added to Tier 1
Cloverfield should be added to Tier 0
Ice Age 2: The Meltdown should be added to Tier 1
The Departed should be added to Tier 2
Finding Neverland should be added to Tier 4
Van Wilder should be added to Tier 4
The Untoucables should be added to Tier 1
Full Metal Jacket should be added to Tier 2
Surf's Up should be added to Tier 0

My understanding is that 300 is shown exactly the way the director intended.