Still not convinced

[Doctorossi]

Originally Posted by bruceames.

Is it still inappropriate if the filmmaker approved it?

No, but it would be nice if the disc would include the original theatrical version of the movie, as well.

The other difficulty is in finding out whether or not the HDR grade is filmmaker approved. Outside of the movies that had theatrical HDR grades, I'm only aware of three UHD releases that I know for certain have filmmaker-approved HDR grades (Exodus, The Martian and Sicario). And there's one upcoming one that I know for sure isn't filmmaker approved (Lawrence of Arabia). So far, there's no provenance or explanation provided on the disc packaging, so we're on our own trying to figure out whether or not the filmmakers have been consulted on the re-grade.