Rate the collection of the poster above you

[miTfan3]

Originally Posted by Seamus McFly

Fixed, lol.
10/10 for yours. One of the best collections I've seen.

9/10. Great smaller collection.

[SilentDawn]

Originally Posted by miTfan3

9/10. Great smaller collection.

Love your avatar, There Will Be Blood is in my top 5 of all time!

You have a ton of must-own titles, very impressive.

9/10

[KrugerIndustrial]

Originally Posted by SilentxStatik24

Love your avatar, There Will Be Blood is in my top 5 of all time!

You have a ton of must-own titles, very impressive.

9/10

Some nice classics, and those Criterion's are gems. Nice collection that can only get better.

8/10

[tama]

Originally Posted by KrugerIndustrial

Some nice classics, and those Criterion's are gems. Nice collection that can only get better.

8/10

10 Great collection there.

[CoolRanch]

Originally Posted by tama

10 Great collection there.

10/10, Amazing collection, with impressive number of Criterions!

[starman15317]

Originally Posted by CoolRanch

10/10, Amazing collection, with impressive number of Criterions!

7/10 not bad at all

[zeze]

Originally Posted by starman15317

7/10 not bad at all

It seems we have similar tastes. I own many titles that you have (65 titles I think), and you have ones that I still need to get. 8.5/10. Good start

[Le samouraï13]

Originally Posted by zeze

It seems we have similar tastes. I own many titles that you have (65 titles I think), and you have ones that I still need to get. 8.5/10. Good start

We don't have much in common but it's a nice collection ...8/10

[Cabby]

Originally Posted by Le samouraï13

We don't have much in common but it's a nice collection ...8/10

10/10. Amazing collection. The criterions and limited edition sets you have are incredible. I'm jealous!

[SilentDawn]

Originally Posted by Cabby

10/10. Amazing collection. The criterions and limited edition sets you have are incredible. I'm jealous!

Fantastic collection full of awesome titles!

10/10

[CoolRanch]

Originally Posted by SilentxStatik24

Fantastic collection full of awesome titles!

10/10

10/10, Perfect start!

[WillHunting]

Originally Posted by coolranch

10/10, perfect start!

8/10

[miTfan3]

Originally Posted by WillHunting

8/10

9/10. Nice boxes and steels.

[mjbethancourt]

Originally Posted by miTfan3

9/10. Nice boxes and steels.

Finally, I catch a chance to rate a collection that won't make me feel "mean" about judging honestly.

You don't have a ton of the same titles I do, but you do have most of my favorites. Of your roughly 180 titles that I don't have, most are titles on my shopping lists; you only have a few that I wouldn't touch with a ten-foot pole. You have some music BDs, which is cool. (I still don't have any yet.)
Looking at all of your titles, I am guessing that you started collecting BDs pretty early (not quite '2006' early, more like "holiday 2007" early, or perhaps sometime in 2008).

Your collection size is right on the border of where I separate a "modest" collection (roughly 140-270 titles) from a "medium" collection, (270-600 titles). As a Modest collection, it would be an easy 10/10, but as a Medium collection, there's too much missing to get a full 10/10, instead I have to give you a borderline-low 9/10.

That's a nice collection.

[Hellraiserfan]

Originally Posted by mjbethancourt

Finally, I catch a chance to rate a collection that won't make me feel "mean" about judging honestly.

You don't have a ton of the same titles I do, but you do have most of my favorites. Of your roughly 180 titles that I don't have, most are titles on my shopping lists; you only have a few that I wouldn't touch with a ten-foot pole. You have some music BDs, which is cool. (I still don't have any yet.)
Looking at all of your titles, I am guessing that you started collecting BDs pretty early (not quite '2006' early, more like "holiday 2007" early, or perhaps sometime in 2008).

Your collection size is right on the border of where I separate a "modest" collection (roughly 140-270 titles) from a "medium" collection, (270-600 titles). As a Modest collection, it would be an easy 10/10, but as a Medium collection, there's too much missing to get a full 10/10, instead I have to give you a borderline-low 9/10.

That's a nice collection.

8/10

Nice mix of new and old films and quite a lot of good foreign films in there as well.

[SilentDawn]

Originally Posted by Hellraiserfan

8/10

Nice mix of new and old films and quite a lot of good foreign films in there as well.

A varied and well thought out collection.

8.5/10

[El_Jay]

Originally Posted by SilentxStatik24

A varied and well thought out collection.

8.5/10

Good selection of Disney and stuff like Baraka in the beginning here.

Some questionable quality-control in the comedy section (Benchwarmers, Cats & Dogs).

Pretty strong in the action for a collection this size.

Very strong Criterion section.

Very good quality control through the Horror/Sci-fi section.

Quite strong all the way through the Thriller/Drama section.

It's a good collection for this size. I'm guessing you're in the middle of backlisting a lot of stuff from a large DVD collection.

8.5/10

[Deckard757]

Originally Posted by El_Jay

Good selection of Disney and stuff like Baraka in the beginning here.

Some questionable quality-control in the comedy section (Benchwarmers, Cats & Dogs).

Pretty strong in the action for a collection this size.

Very strong Criterion section.

Very good quality control through the Horror/Sci-fi section.

Quite strong all the way through the Thriller/Drama section.

It's a good collection for this size. I'm guessing you're in the middle of backlisting a lot of stuff from a large DVD collection.

8.5/10

9.5/10

A ton of my favorites.

Sweetass collection

[Phil92]

Originally Posted by Deckard757

9.5/10

A ton of my favorites.

Sweetass collection

8/10. Good stuff. Like it, like it.

[zeze]

Originally Posted by Phil92

8/10. Good stuff. Like it, like it.

Pretty heavy on newer titles, but I like your horror titles (but how can you not own Halloween ). 6.5/10