Any reason not to get 4K?

[Penton-Man]

Originally Posted by Auditor55

You have to be kidding me!! Please produce that Independent professional lab testing that have proven Dr. Soneira wrong. Also, please produce their resume that would qualify them to attack his analysis.

His findings are consistent with the overwhelming expert view on this subject. He's not some lone quack on this subject, Please!! His resume speaks for its self. The only people that would try to attack him are some subjectivist home theater enthusiast, that reject true, correct, scientific and factual evidence.

See the links toward the bottom of this post –
https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread...ic#post9902392

which relate the results (presented at more than one international conference by spokespersons for the EBU ( https://ch.linkedin.com/pub/hans-hoffmann-phd/5/a68/75b ) , Eurovision, etc.) presenting the materials, methods and results of the independent professional lab testing as well as my included link to the easier-to-read consumer testing by HDTVtest which prove wrong the assertion by Dr. Soneira, as quoted by you, that “a regular human isn't going to see a difference."

I kind of find that sort of hyperbole amusing coming from a physicist who, unlike most video engineers, actually realizes that humans commonly can resolve better than one arc minute (30 cycles/degree)… http://www.wired.com/2010/06/iphone-4-retina-2/ which, by the way, is the basis of the graph you posted by Carlton Bale and which you also accept and continuously promote as gospel.

Real world advice…. don’t blindly follow personalities based on professional credentials or past reputation believing therefore that whatever spouts out of their mouths is guaranteed to be accurate