Can I get a disc replaced years after purchase?

[TheBluRayBandito]

I bought the Godfather set some years back. I watched the movies, but never got to the bonus disc. Finally decided to pop it in and it never went to the main screen. I would just get a loading screen and then go black. Tried it on my PS with the same results, except it froze the console.

I looked at the disc and saw that it has an imprint "smudge." Can I get a replacement if I contact the distributor? or am I SOL? No receipt, if it matters.