EA's Skate or Tony Hawk's Proving Ground

[Therickus]

I realize that this will cater to a small audience, but its worth the question. I have now played through both demos, and I am actually thinking of going with Skate. It is different. I mean, how many times can they redo Tony Hawk, adding very little other than graphics. I think it might even be worse than what you can say about Madden, because at least they update players. I find the controls for Skate to be....interesting....but after playing it for about 10 mins I became used to them. What do you guys think?