FOX's "American Idol" (Season 16)

[Diesel]

Originally Posted by CZAR

^^I only meant being biased when judging Katie! I think because u like her u judge her on a easier scale. Hey we all do it sometimes so its ok but just pointing it out. As for Siobhan I will actually give u that as she may be what u call a polarizing singer as her style may not work for others, but cmon man Crystal is the truth and I dont how u dont see the greatness in her. She is ready and Katie doesnt compare to her in my eyes. But hey well see who is right and what else takes place! For the guys I think we pretty much agree there for the most part! Got Em!!

Nah, I'm not judging her easier because I like her. I guess I could see how you would think that though since you think she's just alright but I put her at the top of my list for last night. But like I said before, she's not my favorite
Lee is


Yea, Siobhan's stuff just aint for me man. I guess you and Meek just fall on the other side of the line.


Crystal has a good voice and I usually think she does good (but she has never blown me away or made me think she was great), I just don't like that Janis style of music, I hate the way she sounded last night since that's the kinda stuff she sang.


As for seeing who's right, I don't think either of us can be wrong since we both think the girl who's voice we like more is really good. I say we both win since we get to listen to a couple good singers


I was thinking about it last night, and I've decided that I think Mike is the best (before I was thinking either Lee or Mike) RIGHT NOW. Lee just needs to keep getting better and he could take it from Mike imo. But he's got some work to do, where Mike could go out there and make a great R&B record right now probably just like the judges and you said Crystal could do. But I love Lee's 'rocker' style, gravel voice.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by Diesel

Nah, I'm not judging her easier because I like her. I guess I could see how you would think that though since you think she's just alright but I put her at the top of my list for last night. But like I said before, she's not my favorite
Lee is


Yea, Siobhan's stuff just aint for me man. I guess you and Meek just fall on the other side of the line.


Crystal has a good voice and I usually think she does good (but she has never blown me away or made me think she was great), I just don't like that Janis style of music, I hate the way she sounded last night since that's the kinda stuff she sang.


As for seeing who's right, I don't think either of us can be wrong since we both think the girl who's voice we like more is really good. I say we both win since we get to listen to a couple good singers


I was thinking about it last night, and I've decided that I think Mike is the best (before I was thinking either Lee or Mike) RIGHT NOW. Lee just needs to keep getting better and he could take it from Mike imo. But he's got some work to do, where Mike could go out there and make a great R&B record right now probably just like the judges and you said Crystal could do.

Yea a couple of them are actually ready to record in my opinion. So who do u predict will be in the bottom 3? I think u already said Paige was goin home but what other 2 will be on the hot seat with her? Got Em!!

[Diesel]

I think Tim and Andrew will be with her. I think they are the next three to leave imo unless the remaining two step it up big time.

Maybe Didi, I liked her but the judges didn't so maybe she might be in trouble.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by Diesel

I think Tim and Andrew will be with her. I think they are the next three to leave imo unless the remaining two step it up big time.

Maybe Didi, I liked her but the judges didn't so maybe she might be in trouble.

Yea man I like Didi the more and more I see her. I still think her first performance in the top 24 was better than the original song "The Way I Am" but the judges didnt care for it. I liked it a lot. There was only 1 performance of hers I didnt like and that was because of poor song choice which was when she sang "Lean On Me" bad song choice. Other than that I think she has been either good or great! She aint goin nowhere tonight! Got Em!!

[Diesel]

In the early going I didn't care for her, she was one of the ones I thought sucked.

But last week (I think it was last week) she was pretty good and this week she was pretty decent. She won't win, but at least she doesn't flat out suck like I originally thought

[Diesel]

at Ryan:

Katie you are in the bottom three.

Katie your safe.


Come on man, he's usually more suspenseful than that! I guess he knew there was no point in playing it up since we all knew she wasn't going anywhere this week.

He also left Lee and Casey hanging.




Did you guys read Crystal's lips when he said Katie was in the bottom three?
"Oh s***"


The voters nailed the bottom two and the elimination.

[Meeklo]

Well....that was the easiest to call. We really didn't need to watch the whole hour for that result.

It was funny seeing Crystal say "Oh sh*t" to Katie leaving.

[Diesel]

Miley Cyrus sounded horrible...

[Moefiz]

Originally Posted by Diesel

Miley Cyrus sounded horrible...

Dude..you ain't kidding, I had to change the channel while she was singing with the wife permission of course...the thing is Paige sounded much better tonight that last night...

[Diesel]

Originally Posted by Moefiz

Dude..you ain't kidding, I had to change the channel while she was singing with the wife permission of course...the thing is Paige sounded much better tonight that last night...

I have heard her a few times lately and thought she sounded much better (but still not that good) than she used to sound when she was younger.

But when she "sung" (if that's what it was supposed to be) tonight
Wow....




BTW, where is CZAR? Shouldn't he be busting my chops right about now because of Katie being in the bottom 3?

[browndk26]

Originally Posted by Diesel

Miley Cyrus sounded horrible...

Thats what my 12 year old daughter said.

[Moefiz]

I also think its just a matter of time for Big Mike, seem like he is doing the same thing week after week..

Right now..Krystal and Shioban is leading the pack.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by Moefiz

Dude..you ain't kidding, I had to change the channel while she was singing with the wife permission of course...the thing is Paige sounded much better tonight that last night...

Man I am kinda pissed at Simon and the judges. How can they decide they werent gonna save Paige before she even did the save performance like Lacey did last week? So her singing afterwards was pointless. The funny thing is she sounded great and couldve been a possible save with that performance! That was hella messed up in my opinion! Although she gave a bad performance lastnight she is much better than Tim & Andrew alone and I could throw in a few others. Oh well Ill get over it. Got Em!!

Originally Posted by Diesel

BTW, where is CZAR? Shouldn't he be busting my chops right about now because of Katie being in the bottom 3?

Haha yes sir u knew I was comin! Remember I am on the west coast so I dont get to watch the show until 8pm or 9pm pacific time. I was shocked that she went and not Andrew but then I was tellin my girl that I kinda glad she made the bottom 3 so I could talk some trash to this guy who claims she is better than Crystal & Siobhan! My girl was like "hell naw she isnt better than those 2" haha but u got lucky and she is still here. But I am tellin u her time is comin, but not until Tim & Andrew are gone! Haha! Got Em!!

[Meeklo]

Originally Posted by CZAR

Man I am kinda pissed at Simon and the judges. How can they decide they werent gonna save Paige before she even did the save performance like Lacey did last week? So her singing afterwards was pointless. The funny thing is she sounded great and couldve been a possible save with that performance! That was hella messed up in my opinion! Although she gave a bad performance lastnight she is much better than Tim & Andrew alone and I could throw in a few others. Oh well Ill get over it. Got Em!!

They did that a couple of times last season. The judges know when someone has got it and when it's painfully obvious that they need more work. I'm actually more surprised that they waiting until after Lacey sung to tell her no. Paige deserved to go....she should have gone a couple of weeks ago.

I'd actually say at this point we could get rid of all the women except Siobhan and Crystal....those 2 should be duking it out at the end.

[Steelmaker]

Originally Posted by Meeklo

They did that a couple of times last season. The judges know when someone has got it and when it's painfully obvious that they need more work. I'm actually more surprised that they waiting until after Lacey sung to tell her no. Paige deserved to go....she should have gone a couple of weeks ago.

I'd actually say at this point we could get rid of all the competitors except Siobhan and Crystal....those 2 should be duking it out at the end.

FYP!


Seriously thuough, I don't even think Siobhan is in Crystal's league. Yes she has that scream at the end, but beyond that she lacks Crystal's soul and Crystal knows who she is. I think Siobhan is still trying to figure herself out.

[CYMBOL]

Originally Posted by Steelmaker

FYP!


Seriously thuough, I don't even think Siobhan is in Crystal's league. Yes she has that scream at the end, but beyond that she lacks Crystal's soul and Crystal knows who she is. I think Siobhan is still trying to figure herself out.

I think Siobhan is an artist, through and through. Crystal got soul (and glad she's losing the attitude - seriously, she was looking annoyed to be there in the beginning).

Very different singers, but both are fantastic.

Crystal definitely knows what kind of artist she is - I think Siobhan is a bit more of a cameleon.

Should be fun to watch as they both progress.

[Diesel]

Originally Posted by CZAR

Haha yes sir u knew I was comin! Remember I am on the west coast so I dont get to watch the show until 8pm or 9pm pacific time. I was shocked that she went and not Andrew but then I was tellin my girl that I kinda glad she made the bottom 3 so I could talk some trash to this guy who claims she is better than Crystal & Siobhan! My girl was like "hell naw she isnt better than those 2" haha but u got lucky and she is still here. But I am tellin u her time is comin, but not until Tim & Andrew are gone! Haha! Got Em!!

That's hilarious man



Unless something changes in the next few weeks I think it'll be:

Tim
Andrew
Didi
Aaaron
Casey
Katie
Siobhan (though she could leave a week or two earlier possibly, it depends just how big that split with the people who like/hate her is)


Once you get to the top 3 (who I think will be Big Mike, Lee and Crystal), all bets are off, I don't know which of them would go first.

I personally think it would be an 'upset' if one of those three didn't make it to the last two weeks of the show.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by Meeklo

They did that a couple of times last season. The judges know when someone has got it and when it's painfully obvious that they need more work. I'm actually more surprised that they waiting until after Lacey sung to tell her no. Paige deserved to go....she should have gone a couple of weeks ago.

I'd actually say at this point we could get rid of all the women except Siobhan and Crystal....those 2 should be duking it out at the end.

U could be possibly right about Crystal and Siobhan! I still think that was messed up how they did Paige. Paige was much better than Lacey and they let her atleast sing before giving the bad news. Oh well. Got Em!!

Originally Posted by Steelmaker

FYP!


Seriously thuough, I don't even think Siobhan is in Crystal's league. Yes she has that scream at the end, but beyond that she lacks Crystal's soul and Crystal knows who she is. I think Siobhan is still trying to figure herself out.

I think Siobhan knows exactly who she is. She is a great artist who is very versatile and has crazy range! Got Em!!

Originally Posted by Diesel

That's hilarious man



Unless something changes in the next few weeks I think it'll be:

Tim
Andrew
Didi
Aaaron
Casey
Katie
Siobhan (though she could leave a week or two earlier possibly, it depends just how big that split with the people who like/hate her is)


Once you get to the top 3 (who I think will be Big Mike, Lee and Crystal), all bets are off, I don't know which of them would go first.

I personally think it would be an 'upset' if one of those three didn't make it to the last two weeks of the show.

Haha u like that one huh? Yea she had me laughin with that to as it is true however! Also man I dont think there is a split of people about Siobhan. Yes Simon says that but we dont know that by the votes. I think she probably is right at the top with the votes each week so until proven otherwise I think most like her. I think its just u! Nice try though. haha! Katie will be gone way before Casey & Aaron mane. Got Em!!

[Diesel]

Maybe, maybe not


Of course, I don't vote for the show so I won't complain if she does


As long as my man Lee makes it to the last couple weeks

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by Diesel

Maybe, maybe not


Of course, I don't vote for the show so I won't complain if she does


As long as my man Lee makes it to the last couple weeks

Aint no maybe to it! Haha! Naw well see what happens. The tour should be cool. Got Em!!