Movie(s) in Your "Top 5 Of All Time" That Will Make Most Scratch Their Heads

[Trav606]

Father of the Bride is one of my tops. It just takes me to my happy place. Not sure if it would be in the top 5. It's been years since I tried to make a definitive list.

[codysame]

The Town is my favourite movie of all time.

[movielib]

Nashville. Possibly my #1 film of all time.

Not that many people don't recognize it as great but I think few people would see it in their top five or even top 50.

[marmup]

Originally Posted by rorschach72

The only headscratchers in my top 5 would be Excalibur and Brainstorm. I do know a lot of guys who like Excalibur, but I doubt it's in very many top 5 lists.

I don't know if it is in my top 5, but I love Excalibur.

[ChristmasFnatic]

So my main post was edited. The word retard was removed cuz someone complained it shouldnt be used... I was just referencing the movie I was pertaining to- "Step Brothers", in which that word was used 3x. Some people are just too sensitive. lol

[A Sith Lord?]

Originally Posted by Kevin Holly

Glad to hear it.


I considered The Devil's Rejects to be the greatest film of all time for a few years after seeing it. Offhand, I would probably still consider it the best horror film released between 2003 and 2007.

I consider it probably my favorite horror film of all time if not Top 3. It's still top 5 in any genre for me most of the time. I may have to rethink my top 5 but it still is top 10 absolutely.

[The Debts]

To those who haven't seen the Director's Cut, the appearance of Kingdom of Heaven could raise an eyebrow or two. Jurassic Park too.

[Mahatma]

To live and die in LA?

[PipesDonatello]

Originally Posted by Mahatma

To live and die in LA?

Nothing crazy about that, it sits at #5 for me. Real Genius is #3.

[Kevin Holly]

Originally Posted by Mahatma

To live and die in LA?

Friedkin's Masterpiece.

[nightwolf2369]

Originally Posted by The Debts

To those who haven't seen the Director's Cut, the appearance of Kingdom of Heaven could raise an eyebrow or two. Jurassic Park too.

JP is definitely one of my top 5 favorite films so I completely understand.

[Jacob Anderson]

I don't think these are that crazy or that big of head scratchers, but i don't think many others have these in their Top 5; Anchorman, Kick-Ass & The Hangover are all probably in my personal Top 5.

[LegacyCosts]

Bringing out the dead and buffalo 66. Don't see those in too many top lists ever

[AaronJ]

Originally Posted by The Debts

To those who haven't seen the Director's Cut, the appearance of Kingdom of Heaven could raise an eyebrow or two. Jurassic Park too.

I'm not sure that there's any film where the Director's Cut makes as huge of a difference as it does with Kingdom of Heaven. They are almost like two completely different movies.

[Michael1989]

Superbad

And not so much a headscratcher on this one but also Training Day just because I never see people mentioning it

[Packerfan75]

I know it's well liked but I don't see it much in top 5's and certainly not #1 but it's mine. It's not a classic when put next to others in that category but I love it and never get sick of it. It's just a complete picture for me that has everything I want and nothing I don't. The pacing and performances are just perfect for a movie like this. I can watch it any time no matter what mood I'm in and it's definitely one of the most quotable movies ever.
Now all I need is a complete remaster since the picture on the current disc is the only thing holding it back.

[Cremildo]

I don't think there's any title in my top 5 that will make people scratch their heads. My taste in movies is fairly conventional, I'm afraid.

In my overall top 50, though, I'm sure many will be aghast to find the likes of Femme Fatale, Redacted, and Bitter Moon.

[BladeRunner2007]

Originally Posted by Pizzamorg

I guess Mad Max for one, I think it's far better than Fury Road or The Road Warrior but I seem to be in a very small minority in that regard.

I'd also rank Night of The Creeps as probably THE best film in the horror genre when it comes to referential, homage based comedy but the film doesn't seem to be nearly as appreciated as more obvious titles in that category.

I'm with you on Mad Max.

[TheSpruceMoose]

Fantasia, and people scratch their heads with that choice not because its a bad film but it pops out considering my other 4 top films are usually, Terminator 2, Akira, Halloween, and Hara-Kiri.

[DR Herbert West]

Phantasm