Still not convinced

[Geoff D]

Originally Posted by ray0414

Seems to be conflicting reports on avs about the orange/red flare in mad max. Some are saying it's red on their hdr tv and others say orange. Some are saying that if some do see red, that means that the ones seeing orange probably have a P3 color out of whack.

I think that's a given at this stage of proceedings: https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread...y#post11967571

And for that I won't blame HDR/UHD itself, but on the lack of available calibration assets. The software is out there, the meters are out there, but the test patterns themselves are MIA. Heck, just a set of primary/secondary colour slides mastered in 2020 colour space (or with P3 mapped out to 2020) would be a huge step in the right direction. [edit] And that would even help someone like me with a SDR 709 set, because I could play the colour saturation slides and then measure how accurately the 2020 to 709 transform is being done.