Amazon Editors' Picks 2008 for Blu-ray

[assydingo]

Originally Posted by John72953

I bought Gattaca based on the reviews it got and I almost fell asleep.

Saw I Am Legend at the theatre and was disappointed as well. I wish Will Smith would do something else and expand his creative horizons. All his movies are the same.

I know it wasn't on the list, but I bought Blade Runner as well. Without a doubt the biggest waste of money on Blu-ray for me yet!

Just an opinion guys, no need to go ape on me for my dislikes!

To be fair, I Am Legend's alternative ending makes the movie 20x better.

[cflames89]

Originally Posted by assydingo

To be fair, I Am Legend's alternative ending makes the movie 20x better.

Finally, someone else that appreciates the alt ending as much as I do.

[metsfan1545d]

bad list imo

[GORT]

Like any list some good and some bad

[assydingo]

Originally Posted by cflames89

Finally, someone else that appreciates the alt ending as much as I do.

Most I've shown it to agree.

One said the second the other ending is more dramatic because Will dies. I see his point. It also makes 99% of the movie before it not make sense.

[Copywriter]

I'm sorry, but this "top 50 of 2008" thing is nothing more than a shopping list of many of the BLUs that came out in 2008.

There's no real picking here. Show me a Top 10 or possibly 20.

Why not just say, "Here's our top BLUs for 2008" and list every single one.

Boo.

[Original-6ix]

geez when rambo cant crack the top 50 you know the list is a rib.

[Mystique]

I guess, they like those movies.

[Ice2Dragon]

Wow heroes season 2.

Really??