Jurassic Park Trilogy 4K Steelbook (US)

[Bobafett345]

Originally Posted by PoLskA

i'm not asking for any proof... because i know TLW has one cut on physical media...

Originally Posted by PoLskA

please show me proof where there is an alternative cut of The Lost World...

It's not even like there's a long chain of discussion where you might have forgot you asked for proof. You changed your story in the space of a single reply.

Originally Posted by PoLskA

secondly, i have the previous 4K disc ripped... and guess what? no super secret cut on the disc...

And if we were discussing the previous disc, that might mean something.

When you rip the one we're currently discussing and come back with whether or not the "modifed" message is there, then that will mean something.

Originally Posted by jess1581

What bothered me was that despite numerous attempts to burst your bubble, you insisted on a silly notion that you presumed instead of coming to the more sensible conclusion that it was an authoring error. Being obtuse is not a quality to have in any discussion, especially one that should never have been anyway.

Maybe lead with something more substantive like "it's an authoring error" next time instead of trolling, insults, and a position based on assumptions for most of the discussion.

That would have been sensible.

But even in your reply you can't have a sensible discussion and keep to the same tired insults and trolling you started with.

If it's an authoring error, the issue would seem to be that the disc skips playing the "modified from original version" message it was encoded with.

[PoLskA]

Originally Posted by Bobafett345

It's not even like there's a long chain of discussion where you might have forgot you asked for proof. You changed your story in the space of a single reply.

i was asking for your proof that there was an alternative cut...

Originally Posted by Bobafett345

And if we were discussing the previous disc, that might mean something.

When you rip the one we're currently discussing and come back with whether or not the "modifed" message is there, then that will mean something.

do you really think the studio would secretly add an alternative cut on the new 4K disc? you really are beyond reason...

[Bobafett345]

Originally Posted by PoLskA

i was asking for your proof that there was an alternative cut...

Like, the "modified" message.

Strange how you'll do almost anything (including using other versions as your "proof") rather than rip this version and see if the "modified" message is there.

Originally Posted by PoLskA

do you really think the studio would secretly add an alternative cut on the new 4K disc? you really are beyond reason...

So secret they literally had a "modified" message?

People beyond reason resort to insults and trolling instead of backing up their arguments with facts.

Feel free to rip this version and come back with the results.

[PoLskA]

Originally Posted by Bobafett345

Like, the "modified" message.

Strange how you'll do almost anything (including using other versions as your "proof") rather than rip this version and see if the "modified" message is there.

did you rip the disc to get the message? that is not your proof as you took someone else's picture as proof...

provide me your concrete proof... oh wait, there is none...

[Bobafett345]

Originally Posted by PoLskA

did you rip the disc to get the message? that is not your proof as you took someone else's picture as proof...

provide me your concrete proof... oh wait, there is none...

"I don't like the source, therefore I can ignore it."

That's not how proof, evidence, etc works.

Feel free to provide something that casts anything that would show d3nt0n as an unreliable witness in this.

Other than aspersions you and others have made during the course of this discussion. "Nuh uh," insults and the like don't cut it. Handwaving a source you don't like just because is the kind of bad faith arguments made by you three during the course of this discussion. Either back up your accusations of d3nt0n being an unreliable source, or apologize for the slander.

Like I said above: if one or more of you had ripped this and posted the results "modified" message, I'd question whether you'd be honest about it but the fact that you have convinced yourselves it's not there, posted evidence to the contrary...and your only rebuttal is trolling and insults.