Should longer movies be given 1 disk for movies and 1 for extras

[Sith]

Originally Posted by Banned User

Nothing worse than getting a BluRay and it having less extras then the DVD version you already own. Plus it would be nice to have extras in 1080p

Then again I think studios when rereleasing a SE edition should offer a 2 or 3 disc case with just the extras so prior owners can buy it and just put their movies in it. In most cases I won't double dip, but I'd be willing to buy the above granted it wasn't outrageously priced.

I think most people care more about the quality of the movie itself and if they
have to sacrifice some extra's it's the price you pay for a top notch blu.

I'd rather have pq/aq be as good as possible like Avatar, then have the compress it to much to add extras.

[dcowboy7]

Yep.

[Banned User]

Originally Posted by Sith

I think most people care more about the quality of the movie itself and if they
have to sacrifice some extra's it's the price you pay for a top notch blu.

I'd rather have pq/aq be as good as possible like Avatar, then have the compress it to much to add extras.

Your missing the point of this thread. We are discussing wanting one disc for the movie and one disc for the special features. If the thread has said 'are you willing to sacrifice special features for a better PQ/AQ?' I would agree wholeheartedly.
Of course I'd much rather have the better PQ, but I really do not see why we can't have both a great PQ/AQ and Special features in 1080p and not 480p.

[FlipperWasIrish]

Originally Posted by Banned User

Of course I'd much rather have the better PQ, but I really do not see why we can't have both a great PQ/AQ and Special features in 1080p and not 480p.

Why? It's clear as day to me. Because the economics do not support what you desire vs the masses desire of under $20.00 Blu-rays.

[Bluyoda]

Originally Posted by Banned User

Nothing worse than getting a BluRay and it having less extras then the DVD version you already own. Plus it would be nice to have extras in 1080p

Then again I think studios when rereleasing a SE edition should offer a 2 or 3 disc case with just the extras so prior owners can buy it and just put their movies in it. In most cases I won't double dip, but I'd be willing to buy the above granted it wasn't outrageously priced.

Originally Posted by ChuckT43

In my view as long as the films picture and audio quality is top notch, if possible include the extras on the same disc. This way when I watch the movie I have the extras right there. However if it means fewer extras or lower quality video then a second disc should be added. What bothers me is when they release theatrical or extended cuts only on a BD. I'm pretty sure with most movies both would fit (X-Files, AVP come to mind).

Originally Posted by Flea77

I would say as a general rule, yes. I would rather have maximum PQ and AQ and have the features on another disc. Now if you can run max PQ & AQ plus the special features on one BD50, then fine.

Allan

Yes to all that!