Rate the collection of the poster above you

[Laservampire]

Originally Posted by Jimmy Bro

Hahaha thanks:P How'd you know I go to JB though?

Just a guess, seeing as we own most of the same stuff that's always in the JB 2 for $20/$30 bins

That and JB is pretty much the only non-online store to buy Blu-rays here!

[koover]

Originally Posted by Laservampire

Just a guess, seeing as we own most of the same stuff that's always in the JB 2 for $20/$30 bins

That and JB is pretty much the only non-online store to buy Blu-rays here!

8/10

Long wordy spoiler if interested

[Show spoiler]Maybe it's me, but man there's a lot of different ways to rate a collection from this group. Collections under 300 titles REALLY get rated where large ones like mine, or anyone over 500, gets a rating based off the size because hardly anyone wants to sift through that many titles. I also find it interesting how people rate, based off their tastes versus the person thats collection is getting rated. Or when someone has an obscure collection (many foreign or films no one ever heard of, they are rated poorly. I like to rate on that persons own tastes AND versus what I like. If a guy has 200 titles, 100 of them are foreign and the others are like mine, that's a high rate because they like what I like and they stand pat on buying what THEY like. Kudos to that person. None of this means anything but I still find it interesting Did you actually read this? If so, what's your take on how you rate?

[jwblu]

Originally Posted by koover

8/10

Long wordy spoiler if interested

[Show spoiler]Maybe it's me, but man there's a lot of different ways to rate a collection from this group. Collections under 300 titles REALLY get rated where large ones like mine, or anyone over 500, gets a rating based off the size because hardly anyone wants to sift through that many titles. I also find it interesting how people rate, based off their tastes versus the person thats collection is getting rated. Or when someone has an obscure collection (many foreign or films no one ever heard of, they are rated poorly. I like to rate on that persons own tastes AND versus what I like. If a guy has 200 titles, 100 of them are foreign and the others are like mine, that's a high rate because they like what I like and they stand pat on buying what THEY like. Kudos to that person. None of this means anything but I still find it interesting Did you actually read this? If so, what's your take on how you rate?

10/10 - Nice selection of 3D films.

[Walts Ghost]

Originally Posted by Cat III

Tremendous size. Too many to look at every page. You do have every genre covered and every time period too. Like all collections this size there are those I wish I had, and ones I would never have. Curiously no imports.8/10

Thanks for the honest assessment Wally Q.

Well, I do have imports. The fact you didn't look at everything on every page made you not notice that. I don't have many, mind you, but I do have quite a few from the UK.

Originally Posted by jwblu

10/10 - Nice selection of 3D films.

8/10

[koover]

Originally Posted by Walts Ghost

Well, I do have imports. The fact you didn't look at everything on every page made you not notice that. I don't have many, mind you, but I do have quite a few from the UK.



8/10

See my spoiler above. Exactly

10/10 Walt

[Leslie Dame]

Originally Posted by koover

See my spoiler above. Exactly

10/10 Walt

10/10

I've seen and possibly rated your collection before. Either way, always enjoy looking through your list. Bonus points for the It's true-Somewhat category

[jwblu]

Originally Posted by Leslie Dame

10/10

I've seen and possibly rated your collection before. Either way, always enjoy looking through your list. Bonus points for the It's true-Somewhat category

10/10- I like how you have your films placed in there categories. Good work.

[StoogeFan1118]

Originally Posted by jwblu

10/10- I like how you have your films placed in there categories. Good work.

8.5/10 nice collection

[Le samouraï13]

Originally Posted by StoogeFan1118

8.5/10 nice collection

8/10 good collection.

[j128v897]

Originally Posted by Le samouraï13

8/10 good collection.

9/10

Great taste in films and a wide diversity.

[ScarredLungs]

Originally Posted by j128v897

9/10

Great taste in films and a wide diversity.

7/10.

You have some movies that I am not a fan of. Even though your collection is small, you do have a good start. Keep up the collecting!

[StoogeFan1118]

Originally Posted by cvm

7/10.

You have some movies that I am not a fan of. Even though your collection is small, you do have a good start. Keep up the collecting!

10/10 nice collection

[j128v897]

Originally Posted by cvm

7/10.

You have some movies that I am not a fan of. Even though your collection is small, you do have a good start. Keep up the collecting!

Thanks! Just started and hoping to catch up with everyone else!

[The Space Jockey]

Originally Posted by j128v897

Thanks! Just started and hoping to catch up with everyone else!

Saving Private Ryan.

[Wally Q]

Originally Posted by the space jockey

saving private ryan.

8/10 sj!

[thejokerha13]

Originally Posted by Wally Q

8/10 sj!

9/10 awesome collection went to get paths of glory and sold out at best buy

[OneWayFilms]

Originally Posted by thejokerha13

9/10 awesome collection went to get paths of glory and sold out at best buy

Great range of films. It would be nice to see them seperated into the catagories that Bluray.com offers. It would make your collection appear more orderly. Othyerwise, great collection.

8/10

[Cat III]

Originally Posted by koover

Maybe it's me, but man there's a lot of different ways to rate a collection from this group. Collections under 300 titles REALLY get rated where large ones like mine, or anyone over 500, gets a rating based off the size because hardly anyone wants to sift through that many titles. I also find it interesting how people rate, based off their tastes versus the person thats collection is getting rated. Or when someone has an obscure collection (many foreign or films no one ever heard of, they are rated poorly. I like to rate on that persons own tastes AND versus what I like. If a guy has 200 titles, 100 of them are foreign and the others are like mine, that's a high rate because they like what I like and they stand pat on buying what THEY like. Kudos to that person. None of this means anything but I still find it interesting Did you actually read this? If so, what's your take on how you rate?

I don't really see how a collection can be judged objectively. It seems hard to judge based on the tastes of the collector, since I only really know my own tastes. I assume people like the movies they own, so most collections would rank high in that regard anyway. If anyone's followed my rating system it basically takes into account overall size, imports, diversity (of genre and year produced), limited or collectors editions, complete sets (owning all Pixar movies or every Michael Bay film or whatever, and how many of the films I like or want to see. It's really just a game when you get down to it. Nothing more than a bit of fun, and an excuse to show off our collections.

Originally Posted by Walts Ghost

Well, I do have imports. The fact you didn't look at everything on every page made you not notice that. I don't have many, mind you, but I do have quite a few from the UK.

Sorry for the oversight. Part of the reason I don't look through the entire collection when it's so big is if I do, then there's a good chance someone else will have posted a rating by the time I'm through.

Originally Posted by OneWayFilms

Great range of films. It would be nice to see them seperated into the catagories that Bluray.com offers. It would make your collection appear more orderly. Othyerwise, great collection.

8/10

Sorry, too tired for much detail. Good Pixar collection, and the Christian/Religious category is not one I often see on here.

6.5/10

[The Space Jockey]

Originally Posted by Cat III

I don't really see how a collection can be judged objectively. It seems hard to judge based on the tastes of the collector, since I only really know my own tastes. I assume people like the movies they own, so most collections would rank high in that regard anyway. If anyone's followed my rating system it basically takes into account overall size, imports, diversity (of genre and year produced), limited or collectors editions, complete sets (owning all Pixar movies or every Michael Bay film or whatever, and how many of the films I like or want to see. It's really just a game when you get down to it. Nothing more than a bit of fun, and an excuse to show off our collections.



Sorry for the oversight. Part of the reason I don't look through the entire collection when it's so big is if I do, then there's a good chance someone else will have posted a rating by the time I'm through.



Sorry, too tired for much detail. Good Pixar collection, and the Christian/Religious category is not one I often see on here.

6.5/10

You got Troll 2 too! 8.5/10.

[KrugerIndustrial]

Originally Posted by The Space Jockey

You got Troll 2 too! 8.5/10.

6.5/10. Sorry.