Your thoughts/reviews on 3:10 to Yuma

[Grisle]

He didn't risk getting hung because he'd already escaped from the prison twice so he knew he could do it again. I don't understand why he did what he did either or why the bullets at the end couldn't find their way to Bale, but I love this movie and I don't think the end hurts it at all.

[Grisle]

You may want to contain a spoiler warning too just in case people get upset.

[mdm1699]

Originally Posted by haynsey

for a start bale would have been shot to shit, crowe shot all of his people who came to help him? then risked getting hung WTF!!

Check the movies thread for more. Watch it again. It wasn't a risk. He escaped from that prison twice. Pay attention to his first sketch, what he did with it and why. When he used his gun(Hand of God) and why. His fixation with the cross on the handle before he killed the gang...justice/injustice. Good movies ask you to revisit them and relive them.

[Giyomu]

Originally Posted by Grisle

You may want to contain a spoiler warning too just in case people get upset.

thank you...

[Quad]

There is a thread about the ending a few pages back. It may help answer your questions. I loved it, not the cookie cutter ending we see all too often.

[haynsey]

well it would be a risk i mean if were going to be really logical about it dont you think they would have changed the prison layout after 2 escapes, especially as its him who escaped? his lloyalty if he had any would be too his gang!??

[Beta Man]

The PQ quality is very good the first half of the film is very good but the ending makes so sense at all

Your post makes "so sense at all"

I think the movie was A "Roger Moore" on a scale of Sean Connery to Pierce Bronson. Or a "Superman II" on a scale of Superman to Superman Returns.

[Grisle]

It almost seemed like Wade was planning to escape from the train not even the prison so he wouldn't be risking anything.

[haynsey]

i would add a spoiler if i knew how, sorry! but i thought the title would be obvious enough

[JasonR]

The PQ quality is very good the first half of the film is very good but the ending makes so sense at all and ruins the film it sucks

[haynsey]

Originally Posted by Grisle

It was just a typo Beta...anyway to me it almost seemed like Wade was planning to escape from the train not even the prison so he wouldn't be risking anything.

ok now that starts to make sense, as in he wants to make a clean break of it and help bale in the process??

[Beta Man]

just giving you a little ribbing... no offense intended or implied.....

I thought the ending could have been better however..... and honestly, there were a lot of parts in the movie that could have been a little better....

gotta make the bad-guys more ruthless in my opinion.... look at Hang em' High, etc.

[JayAuritt]

Originally Posted by haynsey

The PQ quality is very good the first half of the film is very good but the ending makes so sense at all and ruins the film it sucks because the acting and everything else is great but i just dont get the ending for a start Bale would have been shot to shit!

Did you ever consider becoming a professional film critic? I think you have a future in that - I've never read a more concise, intelligent and thoughtful review of a film.

[mdm1699]

Originally Posted by haynsey

well it would be a risk i mean if were going to be really logical about it dont you think they would have changed the prison layout after 2 escapes, especially as its him who escaped? his lloyalty if he had any would be too his gang!??

What is the point of watching a movie if everything is obvious. https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=34491s? Ever since the Clint Eastwood westerns, I have been begging for these. Did you watch Tombstone(Kilmer version)?

[haynsey]

Originally Posted by JayAuritt

Did you ever consider becoming a professional film critic? I think you have a future in that - I've never read a more concise, intelligent and thoughtful review of a film.

i asked for people to offer opinion and to explain to me in the event i missed something or didn't understand, i never said that i was right thats why theres a question mark in the threads title, try reading next time mate

[haynsey]

Originally Posted by mdm1699

What is the point of watching a movie if everything is obvious. https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=34491s? Ever since the Clint Eastwood westerns, I have been begging for these. Did you watch Tombstone(Kilmer version)?

not obvious but logical i think there was a plot oversight apparently


"The ending is from the original.

In the original movie Dan saves Wade's life during their voyage to the town. Wade feels indebted to Dan for saving his life, hence the ending."

which makes all the difference but was not included in this version, why?

[Grisle]

Originally Posted by haynsey

ok now that starts to make sense, as in he wants to make a clean break of it and help bale in the process??

Yeah that's what I think...He wanted to start over on his own. In all honesty Wade's character is a bit confusing because he's supposed to be a lunatic, but he actually seems to be a decent person at times and a ruthless killer at others. I think the ending is a little weak...I'll give you that, but the freaking movie is freaking awesome!!! Just wanted to give a little dramatic effect...off to bed now!

[mdm1699]

Originally Posted by haynsey

not obvious but logical i think there was a plot oversight apparently


"The ending is from the original.

In the original movie Dan saves Wade's life during their voyage to the town. Wade feels indebted to Dan for saving his life, hence the ending."

which makes all the difference but was not included in this version, why?

You could look at this as a different interpretation when compared to the original. You could look at it as the same, but less obvious. Did you get the impression that Wade cried when his mother failed to show or at any other time in his life?

[owa]

I thought the movie was really good and I liked the ending. Here are 4 other threads discussing the movie (and ending):

https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=32655

https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=30741

https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=33822

https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=34491

[haynsey]

Originally Posted by mdm1699

You could look at this as a different interpretation when compared to the original. You could look at it as the same, but less obvious. Did you get the impression that Wade cried when his mother failed to show or at any other time in his life?

yeah i know what u mean and thanks for replying too, i thought that he might not want bales kids growing up the way he did or something