Prometheus Review Thread (Spoilers)

[Foggy]

Originally Posted by Barbossa

No he didn't - the '17 minutes cut' was from an interview a few months ago, and that was referring to another of his films.

However, in a recent interview with Theron and Fassbender, they mentioned that they thought 27 minutes had been cut.

27 minutes could easily fix this film to a great quality, or just botch it up more

[mwynn]

Originally Posted by groove93

[Show spoiler]Honest question, what's the difference between Milburn and Kane? Why isn't anyone upset that Kane stuck his head inside an egg, but we're all butt hurt about Milburn wanting to play with the "Cobra"? Did we know that something was going t jump out and attack Kane, no. Did know the Cobra was going to attack Milburn, be honest, no!!

[Show spoiler]The big difference besides the fact that the egg was an unknown element and the snake was not. Is that Kane was exploring and just a few minutes earlier Milburn was looking for the exit. And a few seconds before that he was trying to avoid a possible life form in the other direction. Why would a person who clearly was afraid touch or attempt to make friends with anything in there?

[Foggy]

Originally Posted by mwynn

[Show spoiler]The big difference besides the fact that the egg was an unknown element and the snake was not. Is that Kane was exploring and just a few minutes earlier Milburn was looking for the exit. And a few seconds before that he was trying to avoid a possible life form in the other direction. Why would a person who clearly was afraid touch or attempt to make friends with anything in there?

Not only that,

[Show spoiler]but the snake gave a warning hiss to tell him to get lost

[Taipan]

I enjoyed this film a lot. I'll be buying it on release day.

4/5

[mwynn]

Originally Posted by Foggy

27 minutes could easily fix this film to a great quality, or just botch it up more

A reorder of scenes could fix a few continuity issues in the third act. Yet there are a few scenes that should have been filmed again. That hair blowing in the helmet thing was awful.

[fgomike]

How did Shaw

[Show spoiler]come to the conclusion that the canisters leaking the black fluid were weapons?

The more I think about certain scenes, the more I feel I missed.

Like

[Show spoiler]Did the Captain nail Vickers?

[raygendreau]

Originally Posted by fgomike

I'm surprised that Scott didn't use Russell Crowe as Weyland. Seems to be in most of his movies now anyway.

I'm lost - Who/What is

[Show spoiler]the Sacriface Engineer?

[Show spoiler]The Sacrifice Engineer appears at the beginning of the movie. He infuses the water with the DNA from his disintigrating body thereby starting evolution on Earth. So, in essence, the Engineers create humanity. The question is, was that his intent. Or was the planned evolution incomplete or the result flawed when Prometheus seeks out mankind's creators.

Originally Posted by avecha

[Show spoiler] I saw it as Weyland was top priority and now that he was up and mobile their orders/priorities changed and Shaw was the least of their worries.

Yes. But keep in mind,

[Show spoiler]there were two agendas. The Mission to find the Engineers of humanity and Weyland's hidden agenda to wrest the secret of immortality from the 'gods'. David and Vicker's to a lesser extent, were tasked with finding that secret of immortality for Weyland. In the beginning, Weyland was kept in stasis inside the luxury escape module that was also Vicker's quarters. When the 2000 year old bodies of the Engineer's were found, David thought they had all died, so in an attempt to find a solution he infected Holloway which led to the 'impregnation' of Shaw. The plan was to bring the creature back to Earth ,thinking that they might answer the immortality question by investigating the creature.

After Weyland told David to "try harder", David discovered the hidden entrance to the pilot's compartment on the juggernaut where he found the last remaining Engineer in stasis. He returned to revive Weyland to bring him to the Engineer. Shaw and the creature were no longer important to the mission of discovering immortality at that point. That's why they ignored her.

Weyland had been kept in stasis as long as possible, given that he was near death. He would have been kept in stasis if David had not found the last Engineer.

[dyne]

Something has been bugging me.

[Show spoiler]All the other engineers died. But the flute pilot went into stasis. Why? Why didn't he just pilot the ship to Earth? David brought up all the plans. He seemed perfectly capable after they woke him up and he started slaughtering people and launched the ship. Should we make such a stretch that they were all up and walking around, the virus broke out and he was the only one in the right spot to enact a lock down and put himself into stasis waiting out the virus, with the end agenda being what? That he'd hope the humans would show up and do exactly what they did? That's a bit of an enormous stretch. If that wasn't the plan then how did he end up in stasis?

[Debbie Downer]

Originally Posted by mwynn

Yet there are a few scenes that should have been filmed again. That hair blowing in the helmet thing was awful.

Ridiculous nitpicking. Try to enjoy the film next time.

And I don't even know why Foggy gave this a 4. That's a pretty solid rating for a film you seem to keep criticizing. Don't let the Internet influence you in a bad way.

[Kaiju]

Originally Posted by groove93

[Show spoiler]Honest question, what's the difference between Milburn and Kane? Why isn't anyone upset that Kane stuck his head inside an egg, but we're all butt hurt about Milburn wanting to play with the "Cobra"? Did we know that something was going t jump out and attack Kane, no. Did know the Cobra was going to attack Milburn, be honest, no!!

Good point. People just like to complain though, unfortunately.

[mwynn]

Originally Posted by Debbie Downer

Ridiculous nitpicking. Try to enjoy the film next time.

Sorry my post has upset you so much. Next time? Why would I want to see this mess again?

[mwynn]

Originally Posted by TheMan

Good point. People just like to complain though, unfortunately.

No people like to get their moneys worth, and not feel like they have been ripped off. Everyone here has had a complaint about a movie.

[MyBlu-rayBrotherEd]

Originally Posted by TheMan

Good point. People just like to complain though, unfortunately.

Yep

[groove93]

Originally Posted by TheMan

Good point. People just like to complain though, unfortunately.

I agree. In my years of watching Alien, especially with someone watching it for the first time, I always anticipate the reaction to when Kane gets attacked by the Facehugger, and it's always the same two reactions, "Don't put your head in there.....ohhh shhhhiiii....", or, "Why is he kneeling down, sheeeiiiiiiittt if that was me......". No different than

[Show spoiler]Milburn sticking his hand out to the Cobra

[mwynn]

Originally Posted by fgomike

How did Shaw

[Show spoiler]come to the conclusion that the canisters leaking the black fluid were weapons?

The more I think about certain scenes, the more I feel I missed.

Bad writing.

[Stridulent]

Originally Posted by dyne

Something has been bugging me.

[Show spoiler]All the other engineers died. But the flute pilot went into stasis. Why? Why didn't he just pilot the ship to Earth? David brought up all the plans. He seemed perfectly capable after they woke him up and he started slaughtering people and launched the ship. Should we make such a stretch that they were all up and walking around, the virus broke out and he was the only one in the right spot to enact a lock down and put himself into stasis waiting out the virus, with the end agenda being what? That he'd hope the humans would show up and do exactly what they did? That's a bit of an enormous stretch. If that wasn't the plan then how did he end up in stasis?

As much as I don't really like defending this film after all the plot holes and mindlessness that it contained, I can still see the engineer being in crisis making sense. They were preparing for launch. He could have got into crisis for the trip and the rest of the crew got wiped out while he was sleeping.

[groove93]

Originally Posted by mwynn

Bad writing.

[Show spoiler]I thought that was Janek's conclusion.

[Debbie Downer]

Originally Posted by mwynn

Sorry my post has upset you so much. Next time? Why would I want to see this mess again?

Thanks. I may not be able to sleep tonight.

And why would you see this again? Well depends. Not saying this is in the same league as Blade Runner, but there are even people today who don't like it much initially, until they see it once or twice more. Maybe you honestly did not like Prometheus and have valid reasons. Maybe you are an upset Alien fan that is disapointed it wasnt the film you expected. Maybe you saw it wanting to dislike it and were on the lookout for things to criticize. There are many reasons. I think after time has settled, the hype is gone, and your in a different time in your life, you may think differently about it if you watch it again. It happens all the time. For me it was The Thin Red Line.

[InCali]

Originally Posted by Evra

To answer your question:

[Show spoiler]
-Questionable language
-A scene depicting incineration of a human being
-Three/four scenes involving aliens crawling in and out of mouths
-Exploding chest
-A lady performing C-section on herself (very intense sequence)

I can see why it was rated R, but I think of it more along the lines of PG-13 (or PG-15 if they had that rating). I have to say that the last scene you mention was one of those "whoa" scenes. Overall, the movie was very intense, but not something I would have a problem with my 15 or 16 year old seeing. In fact, my son saw it last night (just walked on in with no problem) with some of his friends.

[Grumpz]

Originally Posted by MykeHavoc

I'm certainly curious as to what your question and answer was.

I was a bit intoxicated and missed the fact that there was evidence of

[Show spoiler]chest buster wounds found on the pile of engineers, so I didn't know what they were running from.