Sylvester Stallone v. Arnold Schwarzenegger

[Wolverine626]

Originally Posted by Beefbowl

I pick arnold. He has that charisma that makes his movies more enjoyable. True Lies was great.

I love the horse chase scene in True Lies. Tom Arnold's reaction to Arnie saying that his horse is getting tired was priceless

[Agent Bond]

Arnold is the bigger star, but Sly is the better actor.

[Wolverine626]

I got to go with Arnold. I like Sly's Action movies too, but I grew up on Arnie films moreso than Sly. I think the only Sly films that I saw growing up were Tango&Cash, Demolition Man, and Judge Dredd. That I know of, anyway.

[THALL434]

Sly is the better of the two in terms of acting, writing, directing, but Arnold has more memorable roles to me. Arnold has the better one-liners too, and in action movies it's all about the muscles and one-liners.

[L.J.]

Really like both of them a lot. Sly to me is the better, because of Rocky, Over the Top, and Rambo. Arnold also has some of my favorites Conan, Terminator, and Predator. Really enjoyed both of them in Escape Plan.

[Randall Flagg]

I like Arnold better.

[Elvis]

Stallone only because a few of his films: Rocky and First Blood are better than anything Arnold ever did.

[qb2333]

Arnold better action and comedy. Stallone better drama and acting. Both big stars

[St3ph4n]

Arnold

[Ill_Be_Back]

Arnold has always been more likable than Stallone in my opinion of course. Stallone may have Rocky, Rambo, Cobra and Demolition man but Schwarzenegger has the Conan series, The Terminator series, Total Recall, True Lies and Predator. Schwarzenegger is the better action hero overall though both are action legends in their own way.

[Elvis]

Originally Posted by Ill_Be_Back

Arnold has always been more likable than Stallone in my opinion of course. Stallone may have Rocky, Rambo, Cobra and Demolition man but Schwarzenegger has the Conan series, The Terminator series, Total Recall, True Lies and Predator. Schwarzenegger is the better action hero overall though both are action legends in their own way.

Neither one are great actors by any stretch.

[onyxbfly]

Originally Posted by Elvis

Neither one are great actors by any stretch.

Amen bro Amen indeed!

[tob]

Stallone he is a better actor and give us a cinema icon in Rocky.

[Spirit Zero]

Arnie has made far better films by a good country mile.

[Bickle76]

I feel like the nerd in The Running Man that can't decide on a stalker.

I choose Arnold Stallone.

[Samus Aran]

Stallone is a much better actor but Schwarzenegger has on-screen charisma in spades. Stallone's ego was also hurting his career at the same time Schwarzenegger was flourishing by collaborating with other talent.

[David LFC]

Went with Stallone he gave us John Rambo!!!

[AeroK]

For me I would say that my favorite is:

Stallone in the 80s
Arnold in the early-mid 90s

[The Special Dog]

Rocky & Rambo

Stallone for me

[BladeRunner2007]

Always preferred Sly. Nothing has changed since, so I am going with Stallone.