Rate the collection of the poster above you

[Yojimbo68]

Originally Posted by Habsfan77

9/10 Solid collection

Amazing collection! We dig a lot of the same films.

10/10

[vertigo12314]

Originally Posted by Yojimbo68

Amazing collection! We dig a lot of the same films.

10/10

9/10 Good collection. I would only remove some of the clunkers and movies that won't get a second viewing but otherwise lots of great stuff. I really want The Killer

[HD Goofnut]

Originally Posted by vertigo12314

9/10 Good collection. I would only remove some of the clunkers and movies that won't get a second viewing but otherwise lots of great stuff. I really want The Killer

Short on comedy and animation, but is otherwise well put together. 8.5/10.

[formula72]

Solid 10/10, nice HD Goofnut

[Blu Jedi Master]

Originally Posted by formula72

Solid 10/10, nice HD Goofnut

10/10 I would like to see your 3D, Box Sets and Collectors Editions in their own category to better appreciate them.

[HD 335]

Originally Posted by Blu Jedi Master

10/10 I would like to see your 3D, Box Sets and Collectors Editions in their own category to better appreciate them.

Nice colletion! 8.1/10

[wickerjay]

Originally Posted by HD 335

Nice colletion! 8.1/10

OMG, I get to rate you, Andrew.

0/10

hehe

EDIT: BTW, what's with the .1 in your rating of that other guy's collection?

EDIT 2.0: After giving your collection an extensive look, I'll give it a 9.16473/10.

[HD 335]

Originally Posted by wickerjay

OMG, I get to rate you, Andrew.

0/10

hehe

EDIT: BTW, what's with the .1 in your rating of that other guy's collection?

EDIT 2.0: After giving your collection an extensive look, I'll give it a 9.16473/10.

Amazing, your sensitivity to reviewing collections is even more keen than mine. You get a rock solid 9.5/10

[m_burlock]

Originally Posted by hd 335

amazing, your sensitivity to reviewing collections is even more keen than mine. You get a rock solid 9.5/10

10/10.

[thecynical_drummer]

Originally Posted by m_burlock

10/10.

10/10 Really nice collection.

[jautor]

Originally Posted by thecynical_drummer

10/10 Really nice collection.

10/10 for quite an extensive and fine collection. +1 for the Criterions, -2 for too much "bad" horror, but +1 for Better Off Dead. So still a 10!

[Adcatalano]

Originally Posted by jautor

10/10 for quite an extensive and fine collection. +1 for the Criterions, -2 for too much "bad" horror, but +1 for Better Off Dead. So still a 10!

I like that your collection feels very complete. you know what you like and you have probably made really good purchases. your collection is really great... for you.. for me, I just don't care for a lot of the movies. we seem to like the same genres but just in different ways. objectively, 10/10. subjectively, 5/10 (you lose extra points for having two copies of one bad movie..braveheart )

[toddly6666]

Originally Posted by Adcatalano

I like that your collection feels very complete. you know what you like and you have probably made really good purchases. your collection is really great... for you.. for me, I just don't care for a lot of the movies. we seem to like the same genres but just in different ways. objectively, 10/10. subjectively, 5/10 (you lose extra points for having two copies of one bad movie..braveheart )

A very respectable mix of action, classics, and horror! Nice job, keep it up!

9 out of 10 stars!

[jautor]

Originally Posted by Adcatalano

I like that your collection feels very complete. you know what you like and you have probably made really good purchases. your collection is really great... for you.. for me, I just don't care for a lot of the movies. we seem to like the same genres but just in different ways. objectively, 10/10. subjectively, 5/10 (you lose extra points for having two copies of one bad movie..braveheart )

Fixed! That 2nd copy was a typo... One, at the Black Friday $10 sale, is certainly enough Braveheart!

D'oh, and now I screwed up the thread. Ok, fixed:

Originally Posted by toddly6666

A very respectable mix of action, classics, and horror! Nice job, keep it up!

9 out of 10 stars!

10 / 10 - There's a lot in there that I'd like in my collection, especially the Ghibli films not in US release yet...

[m_burlock]

Originally Posted by jautor

fixed! That 2nd copy was a typo... One, at the black friday $10 sale, is certainly enough braveheart!

d'oh, and now i screwed up the thread. Ok, fixed:



10 / 10 - there's a lot in there that i'd like in my collection, especially the ghibli films not in us release yet...

10/10.

[MovieMan31]

Originally Posted by jautor

Fixed! That 2nd copy was a typo... One, at the Black Friday $10 sale, is certainly enough Braveheart!

D'oh, and now I screwed up the thread. Ok, fixed:



10 / 10 - There's a lot in there that I'd like in my collection, especially the Ghibli films not in US release yet...

Pretty great collection with lots of stuff I like...

9/10

[Walts Ghost]

Originally Posted by MovieMan31

Pretty great collection with lots of stuff I like...

9/10

8/10

[Blu Jedi Master]

Originally Posted by Walts Ghost

8/10

10/10 Awesome browse through.

[Wally Q]

Originally Posted by Blu Jedi Master

10/10 Awesome browse through.

Respectable 8/10. Enjoyable collection. It's been a while since I took part the thread so should be interesting to see how this goes.

[LuFeng]

10/10 Wally....loved browsing your collection...and saw many i still need to add to mine!

Originally Posted by Wally Q

Respectable 8/10. Enjoyable collection. It's been a while since I took part the thread so should be interesting to see how this goes.