Star Trek: TNG - Best of Both Worlds April 30 Pre-order

[blonde_devil]

Originally Posted by Josep5349

I've never been a fan of the feauture length edit. When watched as one piece I find it suffers from poor pacing, which is natural as it's made up of two episodes structured and paced as such. Watched as feature length we get a good steady build up, an amazing intense mid section, the pace then slows right down for a good 20 minutes and the end climax never quite reaches the intensity of the mid section. I love watching them individually, but as a movie I find it a bit frustrating.

personally i thought it worked alright as a feature. maybe it isn't structed the best as a feature but it still is good to watch. Think of The Dark Knight - you spend 90 minutes watching until they catch The Joker, then it slows down a little before it picks up again. Granted, Best of Both Worlds does slow down a little more but a lot of movies work this same way.

i am excited about this. this is how i saw it as a kid for the first time so i am jacked to be seeing it that way again. and we will have the individual episodes to watch as well so everyone is happy. but i think this is a good way to attract people to Trek who might not have seen it otherwise. The sampler was good as it was cheap and had a few episodes that were pretty good (and one that wash okay) but this is a better way. Show one of the best episodes ever made and let people see TNG in full power. good thing for me is that I am going to be in the States when this comes out so i might be able to pick it up there and save a few dollars(not to mention having a decent cover instead of that English/French thing we get in Canada).

[Josep5349]

Originally Posted by blonde_devil

personally i thought it worked alright as a feature. maybe it isn't structed the best as a feature but it still is good to watch. Think of The Dark Knight - you spend 90 minutes watching until they catch The Joker, then it slows down a little before it picks up again. Granted, Best of Both Worlds does slow down a little more but a lot of movies work this same way.

Even to this day I still find TDK relentless and emotionally draining, the momentary change of pace is actually welcome. In TBOBW "movie" things come to a halt immediately after a highly intense edge of your seat moment, and I just find it loses its momentum.

[nametag]

Originally Posted by Josep5349

Even to this day I still find TDK relentless and emotionally draining, the momentary change of pace is actually welcome. In TBOBW "movie" things come to a halt immediately after a highly intense edge of your seat moment, and I just find it loses its momentum.

TDK is just a bloated and badly structured movie, unfair comparison

I agree that I don't think much is added by watching it as one long episode, I like to see them in two parts as originally made. But I still might get this for the features... and because it'd be nice not to wait months to see part 2 when season 4 comes out.

[mport5150]

I always thought that this should have been released as a movie. I agree that it is far better than most of the ST:TNG movies...

[blonde_devil]

it's one of the results of making part 1 and part 2 several months apart. i think had they written both parts at once, it would have flowed a little better but it wasn't to be. meh, it will still be cool to see this. now if it was only playing in an theatre somewhere - doublebill with First Contact would be even better.

[obriensg1]

I don't want to wait for the conclusion, partly because I've been meaning to show this episode to a friend of mine who is mostly a Trek virgin (I've only managed to show him 'Trek 09', 'Wrath/Khan', 'Search/Spock', and 'Tribbles'.) I explained there is a two parter of TNG that will better prepare him for the villains of one of the movies as I work him through the series. He seemed down with that. My goal is to have him through BOBW and the rest of the films by May. He's starting to lose interest again so this could be tough.

Oh, forgot. Yeah, I too wonder how that will edit together in the middle. As has been said before, that conclusion is chill inducing. To not have the overly dramatic pause and smash to black might not be the same.

[Jar Jar Stinks]

It would be nice if they included both a 4:3 and a 16:9 version of this on the disc.