Lord of the Rings Trilogy (Theatrical Versions) - April 6, 2010

[AVfile]

I think I was too late. The clerks at Wal-mart found it listed in the computer at $12 (this was the day after Black Friday) and said they have stock but could not find it either in the second store I tried.

I'm still looking for a source for the TE trilogy. I don't want the Canadian version on inetvideo.com

[5UP4]

Originally Posted by thisisragtime

if someone could add this to the database, i would appreciate it very much! Bought it today.

+1

[hpDeskjet600C]

Originally Posted by 5UP4

+1

Looks like someone has added it
https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/The-L...Blu-ray/60836/

[5UP4]

Originally Posted by thisisragtime

Looks like someone has added it
https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/The-L...Blu-ray/60836/

thanks!

[lostinga]

Wal-mart in Lawrenceville, GA (Collins Hill location) has the 9 dollar set. Picked one up yesterday.

[Pull and Twist]

I was lucky enough to get a order in when Walmart had this set for $9 and I just received it in the mail today. Although I have yet to watch it, it does come with 3 blu-rays, each containing a single movie... plus 3 dvd's, 1 for each film containing special features. According to the box, it's over 7 hours of special features. As I own the extended edition as well with its treasure trove of special features, i figure these will probably be repeats. Regardless, it's a much better set then I had expected. Case is not bad either... 6 disc blue blu-ray case that slips inside a foiled cardboard housing that then slides into a 3d movie style slipcover.

[AVfile]

Sounds like they sent you the full up box set! I wish I could get one for anywhere near this price.

[goeagles5039]

I got the 3 bluray/3dvd one in the mail too for $9. And it has $5 Hobbit movie cash. Supposedly these special features are different from the extended edition set.

[Pull and Twist]

Originally Posted by goeagles5039

I got the 3 bluray/3dvd one in the mail too for $9. And it has $5 Hobbit movie cash. Supposedly these special features are different from the extended edition set.

I think they may be... the insert says they include the National Geographic specials on the movies, which the extended edition do not have, but are available for streaming on Netflix. When I get some time i'll have to look through them and compare.

[MifuneFan]

The theatrical and extended editions do have different special features, with no overlap as far I know.

[goeagles5039]

Are the National Geographic specials for each movie good?

[Rizor]

Originally Posted by goeagles5039

Are the National Geographic specials for each movie good?

I liked the one for the first movie. Haven't seen the others.

[Grand Bob]

Originally Posted by goeagles5039

Are the National Geographic specials for each movie good?

Originally Posted by Rizor

I liked the one for the first movie. Haven't seen the others.

The only National Geographic special I am aware of was aired about the same time "Fellowship" was released. It had a few scenes from the movie along with some background on Tolkien and the book that I felt was uneven. For example, more time was spent discussing the Kalevala (a myth that influenced Tolkien) than other things that would have better suited the hour available for the special. However, it is still worth watching.

[PatrynXX]

rented FOTR and yet again another blu ray with a mastering defect. Encountering more and more of these from netfix. no probs from blockbuster online but 99 % of the bad BD's all netflix. like is netflix using a cheap material or something... get to the layer change and poof. frozen. not that there is a layer change but whenever it gets to that area it locks up. No matter what drive I've got it on. Hitachi or Panasonic.. Didn't really wanna buy them now I know why I won't buy them. master sucks.

[mzupeman]

Originally Posted by PatrynXX

rented FOTR and yet again another blu ray with a mastering defect. Encountering more and more of these from netfix. no probs from blockbuster online but 99 % of the bad BD's all netflix. like is netflix using a cheap material or something... get to the layer change and poof. frozen. not that there is a layer change but whenever it gets to that area it locks up. No matter what drive I've got it on. Hitachi or Panasonic.. Didn't really wanna buy them now I know why I won't buy them. master sucks.

I don't think you know what you're talking about. What does the master have to do with anything?

Perhaps it's renting second hand Blu-ray discs that causes issues, because people clearly don't take adequate care of this stuff.

[kesando]

Are the recent Steelbook versions worth it for $9.99-$14.99?

[The Fallen Deity]

What special features were exclusive to this set because I just bought a slimmed down 3 disc set of the Theatrical Cuts without the extras discs as I thought all the extras were carried over to the Extended Editions?

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

[insomniac013]

Originally Posted by The Fallen Deity

What special features were exclusive to this set because I just bought a slimmed down 3 disc set of the Theatrical Cuts without the extras discs as I thought all the extras were carried over to the Extended Editions?

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

[Show spoiler]

Fans pining for the hours and hours of special features originally included on New Line's sprawling Platinum Series Special Edition DVDs will have to wait for the inevitable Blu-ray release of Peter Jackson's extended cuts to get their much deserved supplemental fill. The three theatrical cuts arrive with a more meager selection of features that barely scratch the surface of the trilogy's massive production and the filmmakers' tireless efforts. Moreover, the majority of the content on hand is spread across three DVD discs and presented in lowly standard definition (the lone exception being the various videogame and theatrical trailers found on each film's Blu-ray disc, all of which are encoded in HD). Ultimately, diehards and completists who share an optimistic view of Warner's Big Picture may be satisfied with the studio's initial volley of bonus materials, but most everyone else will be sorely disappointed, whether considering overall quality or quantity.

The Fellowship of the Ring earns a relatively small, often redundant suite of promotional features. "Welcome to Middle-earth" (SD, 17 minutes) is a rather dull, clip-laden Houghton Mifflin In-Store Special that provides a talking-head overview of the first film, Peter Jackson's infectious passion and involvement, the contributions of several artists, WETA's design work and special effects, the script, and more. "Quest for the Ring" (SD, 21 minutes) is a flashier (albeit more annoying) Fox television special that focuses more attention on the actual production, but its stilted narrator spends most of his time recapping plot points, introducing characters, and rattling off basic details covered elsewhere. And what of "A Passage to Middle-earth" (SD, 42 minutes)? More of the same, this time via a Sci-Fi Channel special. Thankfully, things change momentarily with a collection of fifteen "LordoftheRings.net Featurettes" (SD, 39 minutes), many of which are far more extensive and informative (at least when taken as a whole) and tackle everything from the film's locations to its elaborate sets, its actors to their performances, and Tolkien's languages to Howard Shore's score. Rounding out the package is a behind-the-scenes, Jackson-hosted preview of the then-upcoming release of The Two Towers (SD, 11 minutes), an Enya music video (SD, 4 minutes), three rousing theatrical trailers (HD, 7 minutes), six TV spots (SD, 3 minutes), two videogame trailers (HD, 2 minutes), a "Trilogy Supertrailer" (HD, 7 minutes), and a terribly dated Extended DVD preview (SD, 3 minutes).

The Two Towers serves up a similar assortment of supplements. "On the Set" (SD, 14 minutes) is a Starz Encore special that skips stones across the production, touching on various reactions to the first film, the continuation of the story, its new characters, and an early look at the conflicts and themes that propel the sequel along. "Return to Middle- earth" (SD, 43 minutes), a WB-aired television special, follows suit but, even at three- quarters of an hour), brings little of note to the proceedings other than more film clips, more narration, and more promotional interviews. It's fairly decent, mind you, but I'm sure it was far more exciting to watch before the second film arrived in theaters. Another batch of eight "LordoftheRings.net Featurettes" (SD, 34 minutes) improves matters once again, candidly (albeit briefly) dissecting Towers' creatures, sound design, weapons, armor, and more. A short film from actor Sean Astin, "The Long and Short of It" (SD, 7 minutes), provides a nice, mildly endearing distraction from the main behind-the-scenes material, and even earns its own "Making Of" special (SD, 8 minutes). From there, an engaging sneak peek at The Return of the King (SD, 13 minutes), an Emiliana Torrini music video (SD, 4 minutes), two theatrical trailers (HD, 5 minutes), two videogame trailers (HD, 2 minutes), a "Trilogy Supertrailer" (HD, 7 minutes), sixteen TV spots (SD, 8 minutes), and an Extended DVD preview (SD, 5 minutes) wrap up the second film.

The Return of the King doesn't change course. "The Quest Fulfilled" (SD, 23 minutes) is a solid EPK that traces the arc of the trilogy, its characters, and Jackson's Oscar- winning adaptation and production. "A Filmmaker's Journey" (SD, 29 minutes) is an In a World-narrated special that covers the breadth of the films, their actors' performances, Jackson's obstacles and achievements, and a number of topics that, as abundant as the information might be, becomes incredibly repetitive. And where exactly does Hollywood find these narrators? Sheesh. Ah well, at least "The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" (SD, 46 minutes) strikes a different, more refreshing pose. Hosted by John Rhys-Davies, this National Geographic tie-in digs into the historical cultures, figures, and events that helped shaped Tolkien's lore, his heroes and their battles, and Jackson's breathtaking vision. Honestly, it's the most interesting television special included in the set. Six "LordoftheRings.net Featurettes" (SD, 22 minutes) offer some respite as well, delving into key aspects of the key cities, battlefields, combatants, and special effects employed in Return of the King. Finally, two theatrical trailers (HD, 6 minutes), two videogame trailers (HD, 2 minutes), a "Trilogy Supertrailer" (HD, 7 minutes), fourteen TV spots (SD, 7 minutes), and an Extended DVD preview (SD, 7 minutes) top things off.

Basically everything from the original 2-disc DVD releases.

[The Fallen Deity]

Originally Posted by insomniac013

Basically everything from the original 2-disc DVD releases.

I see, thanks for the info. I'm not too fussed about getting the movie only set, it was dirt cheap so I thought what the hell. The special features on the Extended Edition box set look better anyway, I can always watch the other extras on YouTube or something. I haven't seen the Theatrical Cuts in years so it should be a treat to see them again. It'll be weird after watching the Extended Editions so many times.

The films are classics though regardless of which versions you watch.

[moviebuff75]

I can't watch the first movie on blu. The dnr and the white line that appears on the right side of the frame (more frequently as the movie progresses) ruin it for me...especially after seeing the improved Extended Edition. I would like to own the theatrical versions in better editions.