2013 - Three Surprises, Three Disappointments

[remake]

Surprises
The Call (I found the first hour incredibly suspenseful)

Warm Bodies (the trailers looked good, but ended up loving the film much more than I thought. Ended up seeing it 4x in theatres)

You're Next (first half hour is a little slow, but once it got going, it blew my mind more than once. I was rooting for the protagonist so hard)

Disappointments
The Conjuring (after the brilliant first half of Insidious, and being a fan of James Wan, I had high expectations for this. I was disappointed because all the good stuff was revealed in the trailers so I sat in the theatre knowing every single thing that would happen. It's very well acted though)

Star Trek Into Darkness

Insidious: Chapter 2 (I don't recall one memorable scare. I liked when a certain character went psycho though)