Quirke (Gabriel Byrne) -- Another UK series released in Germany and not the UK

[McCrutchy]

Originally Posted by Buzz201

Your original comment about Sony was incredibly vague, I incorrectly assumed you meant licensing films rather than technology.

Whether it breaks the bank or not is irrelevant, BBC Worldwide's job is to be ruthlessly commercial, they exist purely to make money not friends or fans. If they cannot justify the extra expense with a lot more sales (or because the percentage of blu-ray sales is enough to justify the time/expense), they won't and arguably can't do it.

There's a difference between arguing against a blu-ray release and understanding why one hasn't happened.

And you have just as much idea why one has not happened as I do. You and I can only hypothesize. I do find it interesting though, that only with Blu-ray releases, do people, even on an enthusiast forum, come out with all sorts of justifications for not releasing on Blu-ray.

Again, this isn't limited to one program, we are seeing it happen more and more. BBC programs are showing up in the US, Japan, and particularly, in Germany, yet they continue to neglect to release these programs in the UK.

Yes, the UK Blu-ray market is much smaller than those other countries, but that's the home base for most of these productions, and the natural thought is that the most sales for a UK program will come from the UK.

I'm not asking the BBC to be my friend, and I'm not blind to the fact that Blu-ray releases are more expensive to produce. But I think this is far more about ignorance of the market than anything else. It's preposterous, for example, to think that Luther would not have sold on Blu-ray. The BBC missed a prime opportunity to put out a Series 1-3 box set last year, at arguably the height of Idris Elba's popularity. I've also never understood why the Top Gear series are not released, either.

It's gotten to the point, even in the UK, where other, often smaller labels are picking up the slack where they can, surely where co-productions mean that other labels are responsible for DVD and Blu-ray releases of BBC TV material. Look at the releases of Mrs. Brown's Boys from Universal UK (admittedly a large company, but also with the widest variety of UK Blu-ray releases), or the BBC TV releases from Acorn (Broadchurch, The Fall) or Spirit Entertainment (Father Brown). If Blu-ray releases are viable on a smaller scale for these UK companies, then the BBC should be capable of more at home. They don't even release the French series they air from Canal (Spiral), while Canal's similar French crime series Braquo gets UK Blu-ray releases from Arrow, who are still a much smaller company than the BBC, and who manage dozens of UK Blu-ray releases of films as well.

The current mantra from the BBC would seem to be: If it's nature, or it's effects-driven, or if it's Sherlock, release it on Blu-ray. Otherwise, don't bother.

Again, as you say, BBC Worldwide is not exactly a minor player in the entertainment industry, and knowing that, do we really think a few more UK Blu-ray releases per year are going to hurt their bottom line? Doubtful.

Yet I'm sure, thanks to their efforts, that most people, and even most retailers, believe that when a TV series come out, it is coming out on DVD only. I'm sure that, living in the UK, you notice the shop shelves, and I'm sure most dual-format BBC TV releases are stocked on DVD only. But I'm also sure, if you ask any employee in these shops about a Blu-ray version, they will probably have no idea if one exists or not, or even if they ever carry it.

This exact scenario happens all the time in American shops, where employees will express surprise when I tell them that a title was indeed released on Blu-ray.

[Buzz201]

Originally Posted by McCrutchy

It's gotten to the point, even in the UK, where other, often smaller labels are picking up the slack where they can, surely where co-productions mean that other labels are responsible for DVD and Blu-ray releases of BBC TV material. Look at the releases of Mrs. Brown's Boys from Universal UK (admittedly a large company, but also with the widest variety of UK Blu-ray releases), or the BBC TV releases from Acorn (Broadchurch, The Fall) or Spirit Entertainment (Father Brown). If Blu-ray releases are viable on a smaller scale for these UK companies, then the BBC should be capable of more at home. They don't even release the French series they air from Canal (Spiral), while Canal's similar French crime series Braquo gets UK Blu-ray releases from Arrow, who are still a much smaller company than the BBC, and who manage dozens of UK Blu-ray releases of films as well.

The current mantra from the BBC would seem to be: If it's nature, or it's effects-driven, or if it's Sherlock, release it on Blu-ray. Otherwise, don't bother.

Some of those examples are unfair, Arrow charge a lot for their blu-ray releases, and they only come down in price during clearances, if BBCW charged those kinds of prices shit would hit the fan and the papers would accuse them of blatant profiteering for content people "have already paid for", where as BBCW's price points are more reasonable.

Acorn only released Broadchurch several months after the DVD release, as demand had been proven, much to the annoyance of some on this forum, despite the fact the series was a sleeper hit, and by the time Acorn realised this it was probably too late to do anything...

One would also note, Sherlock, Mrs. Brown's Boys and Broadchurch all achieve very high ratings for their respective networks, The Fall got high ratings for it's respective networks. Quirke did alright, similar viewership figures to The Fall, but as a miniseries perhaps alright wasn't good enough...

[McCrutchy]

Originally Posted by Buzz201

Some of those examples are unfair, Arrow charge a lot for their blu-ray releases, and they only come down in price during clearances, if BBCW charged those kinds of prices shit would hit the fan and the papers would accuse them of blatant profiteering for content people "have already paid for", where as BBCW's price points are more reasonable.

Acorn only released Broadchurch several months after the DVD release, as demand had been proven, much to the annoyance of some on this forum, despite the fact the series was a sleeper hit, and by the time Acorn realised this it was probably too late to do anything...

One would also note, Sherlock, Mrs. Brown's Boys and Broadchurch all achieve very high ratings for their respective networks, The Fall got high ratings for it's respective networks. Quirke did alright, similar viewership figures to The Fall, but as a miniseries perhaps alright wasn't good enough...

I wouldn't say it's unfair necessarily. BBC releases often seem to approach £20 or more initially, which is usually right around what Arrow charge for a similar amount of programming. The difference is that Arrow's releases stay expensive for much longer, and BBC releases tend to drop significantly in price and stay inexpensive afterwards. That's about what one would expect when comparing releases from small labels, with those from one of the nation's largest.

The Broadchurch release is rather telling, though. I remember how many people were upset, because they had bought the DVD assuming there would be no Blu-ray. After all, Acorn releases popular series like the seventh series of Foyle's War on DVD-only in the UK.

And matters of ratings don't explain why a series like Luther or Happy Valley go unreleased on Blu-ray, and why a series like Top Gear only gets specials released (though perhaps there is an unrelated reason for that). In general, it seems like most adult-oriented content (not that Top Gear is adult-oriented) is skipped over, because the BBC must think that Blu-ray is only for hip, young series, like In the Flesh.

[Buzz201]

Originally Posted by McCrutchy

I wouldn't say it's unfair necessarily. BBC releases often seem to approach £20 or more initially, which is usually right around what Arrow charge for a similar amount of programming. The difference is that Arrow's releases stay expensive for much longer, and BBC releases tend to drop significantly in price and stay inexpensive afterwards. That's about what one would expect when comparing releases from small labels, with those from one of the nation's largest.

The Broadchurch release is rather telling, though. I remember how many people were upset, because they had bought the DVD assuming there would be no Blu-ray. After all, Acorn releases popular series like the seventh series of Foyle's War on DVD-only in the UK.

And matters of ratings don't explain why a series like Luther or Happy Valley go unreleased on Blu-ray, and why a series like Top Gear only gets specials released (though perhaps there is an unrelated reason for that). In general, it seems like most adult-oriented content (not that Top Gear is adult-oriented) is skipped over, because the BBC must think that Blu-ray is only for hip, young series, like In the Flesh.

The first series of In The Flesh was excellent, I have the second banked up ready to watch. And it's an 18 rated BAFTA winning show, so perhaps more "adult orientated" than you think...

And the BBC have released the original House of Cards Trilogy on blu-ray, I'm not even sure that was "hip and young" in it's day, never mind now...

[McCrutchy]

The back cover is now up at Amazon.de:

Note that the German release will include English audio and English subtitles.

[Funktion]

If this release is indeed uncut, I will be picking it up.

And in other news, another BBC Show, Merlin, is getting a big boxset in the US with all seasons included. So far, no release in the UK was announced, so it seems it will be one more Blu-Ray release that won't make to its country of origin (so many examples: Hours: Series Two was released on BD in the US, unlike the UK; ...).

[Erasmus Craven]

Please be aware that Polyband releases, although offering English audio and subs, usually have German onscreen text (i.e. Sherlock: all onscreen text like phone messages or Sherlock's derivations/conclusions/thoughts will be in German only). I've not seen this particular show and thus don't know how much of an issue it would be in this case - just a heads up for Polyband releases in general.