Game of Thrones: The Complete Fourth Season (BD with Digital Copy)

[explorer6]

Originally Posted by Aragorn the Elfstone

[Show spoiler]Theon's betrayal was Season 2. His torture happened in Season 3.

Aghhhhhh okay, as i said i'm completely mixed up then. Sometimes when i binge watch stuff i get so lost in the story i can remember all of the story and stuff but when it comes to an exact time line i can't recall where it's placed exactly. I don't know if that's just something with me or an effect of binge watching.

Alright, well...

[Show spoiler]Greyjoy's house sigil and everything being around that time makes a lot more sense so just erase everything i said in the last few pages about Greyjoy involving season 3 ha ha and move it over to season 2. My bad.

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by explorer6

Well, I mainly and basically support Tyrell because of goddess Natalie Dormer aka Margaery Tyrell.

Certainly can't argue with that logic.

[Gold Ranger]

Originally Posted by tj5921

I wouldn't have said anything but the same poster criticized me for not using the spoiler tag on something that clearly wasn't a spoiler. Then they post an obvious spoiler without using said tag. It's just hypocritical.

Originally Posted by explorer6

Oh, then i'm totally mixed up lol.

I could've sworn that

[Show spoiler]the whole Rob battle campaign and red wedding was season 3 wasn't it? And wasn't that when Theon betrayed Rob and then was captured by that torturer? If so i felt that was the Greyjoy's strongest representation whenever these events occurred. Theon betraying Rob and embracing his Greyjoy roots was sort of the moment of Greyjoy for me.

I watched season 1-3 in a binge watching marathon and so it all sort of bleeds together for me. It's difficult to remember what was exactly season 2, etc... as it was all kind of 1 big season.



I see, well if that's the case it all makes a lot more sense.

No, You posted about Deaths that are YET TO HAPPEN and that DO NOT OCCUR in the books!
You spoiled stuff that some of us don't know about and don't WANT to know about.

[rickah88]

Originally Posted by Aragorn the Elfstone

[Show spoiler]Theon's betrayal was Season 2. His torture happened in Season 3.

[Show spoiler]Please don't remind my about that! I cringe every time I think about it!

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by Gold Ranger

No, You posted about Deaths that are YET TO HAPPEN and that DO NOT OCCUR in the books!
You spoiled stuff that some of us don't know about and don't WANT to know about.

I posted a GRRM quote. Which deaths did he reveal? None.

You revealed the death of a specific character.

Only you posted a spoiler.

[Gold Ranger]

Originally Posted by tj5921

I posted a GRRM quote. Which deaths did he reveal? None.

You revealed the death of a specific character.

Only you posted a spoiler.

Mine was from FIVE years ago!
Yours is about multiple upcoming ones, just because it isn't specific, doesn't mean it ISN'T a spoiler!

[croooow]

Originally Posted by tj5921

I posted a GRRM quote. Which deaths did he reveal? None.

You revealed the death of a specific character.

Only you posted a spoiler.

That is the mature way to handle it...

Originally Posted by tj5921

I posted a GRRM quote. You said the quote was a spoiler for those who read the books. When did I put words in your mouth?

Bottom line - his quote wasn't a spoiler.

Bottom line is, those who read the books don't know what is about to happen in season 5 since we don't know what has been changed. You spoiled that by giving us a clue without simply using spoiler tags (something that I was called selfish and lazy for, despite not revealing any spoilers past or future)

It was not a major spoiler, it was hardly a spoiler but that is not the point

Originally Posted by rickah88

Nope. I'd just be wasting my time.

Spoilers are a courtesy thing, either you get it or you don't.
Clearly you don't.

I am very sure you are the one who does not get it (and that is why you are shrugging your virtual shoulders: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrug)

I have not spoiled anything and I use spoiler tags even when talking about plot points that some in this thread may not know. Thank you very much

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by Gold Ranger

Mine was from FIVE years ago!
Yours is about multiple upcoming ones, just because it isn't specific, doesn't mean it ISN'T a spoiler!

You really think GRRM would spoil GoT? As I said earlier he'd be incompetent if he did.

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

That is the mature way to handle it...

If by mature you mean saying the truth then you're correct.

[rickah88]

Originally Posted by croooow

I am very sure you are the one who does not get it (and that is why you are shrugging your virtual shoulders)

I have not spoiled anything and I use spoiler tags even when talking about plot points that some in this thread may not know. Thank you very much

I'm shrugging my "virtual" shoulders because you've spent the last 3 pages trying to defend why one doesn't need to use spoilers.
This implies you don't get it.

I don't need to hold the door open for people behind me.
I do it as a courtesy to them.

[croooow]

Originally Posted by rickah88

I'm shrugging my "virtual" shoulders because you've spent the last 3 pages trying to defend why one doesn't need to use spoilers.
This implies you don't get it.

I don't need to hold the door open for people behind me.
I do it as a courtesy to them.

You are wasting time...

Originally Posted by explorer6

In fairness, i think people are being a little too hard on the person. Something well known all the way from season 1... should people always use spoilers, probably just for consideration to others but something well known back from season 1 in a season 4 thread is hardly the spoiler of spoilers. If someone hasn't seen season 1 yet they probably should know better then be in a season 4 thread.

Thank you

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

Bottom line is, those who read the books don't know what is about to happen in season 5 since we don't know what has been changed. You spoiled that by giving us a clue without simply using spoiler tags (something that I was called selfish and lazy for, despite not revealing any spoilers past or future)

It was not a major spoiler, it was hardly a spoiler but that is not the point

And you still don't know what's going to happen in S5 - because GRRM didn't spoil anything.

Also I don't think you even realize how bad you're contradicting yourself. Defending someone who actually did post a legitimate spoiler, and then coming at me for posting a GRRM quote that isn't a spoiler.

[rickah88]

Originally Posted by croooow

You are wasting time...

I already said that in my previous post.

[croooow]

Originally Posted by tj5921

You really think GRRM would spoil GoT? As I said earlier he'd be incompetent if he did.

It is subjective. Some people think even a trailer or a poster is a spoiler, they try to avoid ANY information before they can see the whole thing for themselves, for others they only consider major plot points to be spoilers. I don't think his quote is a spoiler but some would. Why can't you be considerate of those people?

[myptosis1]

[Show spoiler]Nothing

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

It is subjective. Some people think even a trailer or a poster is a spoiler, they try to avoid ANY information before they can see the whole thing for themselves, for others they only consider major plot points to be spoilers. I don't think his quote is a spoiler but some would. Why can't you be considerate of those people?

At least you finally admit what I posted wasn't a spoiler, despite saying it was for the past four pages. I'm done posting about this it's gotten ridiculous and I need to get back to marathoning.

[croooow]

Originally Posted by tj5921

Also I don't think you even realize how bad you're contradicting yourself. Defending someone who actually did post a legitimate spoiler, and then coming at me for posting a GRRM quote that isn't a spoiler.

Of course I understand how that may look, but the difference is context. This is being said in a thread about season 4. If this was a season 6 or 7 thread, I would be on your side.

And again, just because you (and I) don't think something is really a spoiler, does not mean it is not one. Just use spoiler tags! It's easy!

Originally Posted by rickah88

I already said that in my previous post.

Still waisting time, and shrugging one's shoulder means "I don't know"

Originally Posted by tj5921

At least you finally admit what I posted wasn't a spoiler, despite saying it was for the past four pages. I'm done posting about this it's gotten ridiculous and I need to get back to marathoning.

I said I don't think it is a spoiler but some may, be considerate of those people.

[rickah88]

Originally Posted by croooow

Still waisting time, and shrugging one's shoulder means "I don't know"

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

I said I don't think it is a spoiler but some may, be considerate of those people.

Before you said you thought it was a spoiler and now you admit you don't think it's a spoiler.

Either way I'm glad you finally realized it.

[croooow]

Originally Posted by rickah88

Originally Posted by tj5921

Before you said you thought it was a spoiler and now you admit you don't think it's a spoiler.

Either way I'm glad you finally realized it.

What happened to "I'm done posting"?

And what I think was not the point (plus I did not say I thought it was a spoiler, I asked "How is that a non-spoiler?" and still say it should have been in spoiler tags. Not exactly "admitting it is not a spoiler")