Game of Thrones: The Complete Fourth Season (BD with Digital Copy)

[Gold Ranger]

Originally Posted by Aragorn the Elfstone

This is not a Season 4 Discussion thread. It's a thread about the Blu-ray release. It is entirely reasonable to suppose that people who have not seen the show, but are interested in it, will pop into this thread.

Then why are there pages and pages and pages of posts about what happens in the show here, along with many many other threads in this section?

[Thomas Irwin]

Originally Posted by croooow

That is very fair. I have no problem using the spoiler tags, but really don't get how people get so upset when they are not used.

If you all notice, I did not bring up any of the spoilers in question. I come here for the talk about the blu-ray sets (specially the Best Buy sigils covers)

And I do respect that. Thank you.

[croooow]

Originally Posted by tj5921

Now you're reaching. I'm sorry but saying the show is going to start deviating from the books and discussing the number of seasons remaining isn't a spoiler.

I never said the deviation (which is unavoidable in any adaption between different media, books to TV in this case) or number of seasons was a spoiler. Deaths in future seasons is what I am talking about. Please don't put words in my mouth.

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

I never said the deviation (which is unavoidable in any adaption between different media, books to TV in this case) or number of seasons was a spoiler. Deaths in future seasons is what I am talking about. Please don't put words in my mouth.

The deviation and number of seasons are what his two quotes are about. Saying there will be more deaths isn't a spoiler, it's expected. It's as much of a spoiler as if he said it would snow in Winterfell.

[Doughoef]

I need to make a dedicated shelf for the Pops! but here is my collection as it stands today. I may chase down the Greyjoy cover for S2. I also have some of the beers and special glasses Ommegang has released.

image.jpg.

[croooow]

Originally Posted by tj5921

The deviation and number of seasons are what his two quotes are about. Saying there will be more deaths isn't a spoiler, it's expected. It's as much of a spoiler as if he said it would snow in Winterfell.

You posted

“People are going to die

[Show spoiler]who don’t die in the books, so even the book readers will be unhappy

,"

which would be a spoiler for those who read the books (like me) but have not seen season 5 and beyond (like all of us)

You guys are so worried about people who have not watched any of the show and read 90+ pages into a season 4 thread (Bluray focused but still about season 4) but don't care about people who have read the books and understand that the show is its own thing?

Also, the original complaint about your post was not the content in you link to another site, it was your text on this site

[myptosis1]

Originally Posted by Doughoef

I need to make a dedicated shelf for the Pops! but here is my collection as it stands today. I may chase down the Greyjoy cover for S2. I also have some of the beers and special glasses Ommegang has released.

Attachment 109148.

No, you need to make a dedicated shelf for Game of Thrones Overall, including the POPs.

[Doughoef]

Originally Posted by myptosis1

No, you need to make a dedicated shelf for Game of Thrones Overall, including the POPs.

Good idea!! Maybe I'll just clear out the shelf below for the Pops!

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

You said which would be a spoiler for those who read the books (like me) but have not seen season 5 and beyond (like all of us)

You guys are so worried about people who have not watched any of the show and read 90+ pages into a season 4 thread (Bluray focused but still about season 4) but don't care about people who have read the books and understand that the show is its own thing?

Also, the original complaint about your post was not the content in you link to another site, it was your text on this site

I didn't say that, GRRM did - I quoted him.

This forum is for the show not the books. And those aren't book spoilers. If it said who what where when why or how then yes but saying more will die doesn't spoil anything.

[croooow]

Originally Posted by tj5921

I didn't say that, GRRM did - I quoted him.

This forum is for the show not the books. And those aren't book spoilers. If it said who what where when why or how then yes but saying more will die doesn't spoil anything.

I fixed my post

Originally Posted by Gold Ranger

What is one now-dead character that you miss in the show?
I'd have to go with

[Show spoiler]Eddard Stark

Just realized I never answered this but thought of someone as soon as I read it:

[Show spoiler]Oberyn Martell. Probably my favorite new character ("new" meaning not in the first season

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

I fixed my post

So you think GRRM spoiled the books? Lol ok.

[explorer6]

Originally Posted by tj5921

Greyjoy was only available for S2.

And it's odd you would want Greyjoy but also Tyrell. Lady Olenna even says how their flower sigil and words are boring.

Oh, didn't realize it was only for S2... alright, then i guess i'd have to switch the Lannister and Greyjoy around but that does complicate things a bit because

[Show spoiler]if i remember correctly i don't think the Greyjoy's had much of a presence until S3 and so it doesn't make much sense why it wouldn't be included there. If i was following the series while buying the house sigil slips i could see passing on the Greyjoy's in season 2 because there wasn't representation yet but if just going by which sigil you like more it's no contest.

Well, i mainly and basically support Tyrell because of goddess Natalie Dormer aka Margaery Tyrell. Yeah, the house sigil isn't the most amazing one ever but there's nothing boring about her and she gets my unwavering support always. And i don't think the Martel one is anything to rave about really, even if Natalie Dormer wasn't in House Tyrell it would be fairly even between them imo.

What is one now-dead character that you miss in the show?

[Show spoiler]The redhead outside the wall whose name i'm forgetting at the moment. I wish she didn't die, i liked her. "You know nothing Jon Snow."

[croooow]

Originally Posted by tj5921

So you think GRRM spoiled the books? Lol ok.

Again, I did not say that. Don't put words in my mouth. You know I am talking about season 5 of the show he is a major part of...

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by croooow

Again, I did not say that. Don't put words in my mouth. You know I am talking about season 5 of the show he is a major part of...

I posted a GRRM quote. You said the quote was a spoiler for those who read the books. When did I put words in your mouth?

Bottom line - his quote wasn't a spoiler.

[rickah88]

Originally Posted by croooow

Care to explain it to me then?

Nope. I'd just be wasting my time.

Spoilers are a courtesy thing, either you get it or you don't.
Clearly you don't.

[ck19]

Originally Posted by explorer6

Oh, didn't realize it was only for S2... alright, then i guess i'd have to switch the Lannister and Greyjoy around but that does complicate things a bit because

[Show spoiler]if i remember correctly i don't think the Greyjoy's had much of a presence until S3 and so it doesn't make much sense why it wouldn't be included there. If i was following the series while buying the house sigil slips i could see passing on the Greyjoy's in season 2 because there wasn't representation yet but if just going by which sigil you like more it's no contest.

Well, i mainly and basically support Tyrell because of goddess Natalie Dormer aka Margaery Tyrell. Yeah, the house sigil isn't the most amazing one ever but there's nothing boring about her and she gets my unwavering support always. And i don't think the Martel one is anything to rave about really, even if Natalie Dormer wasn't in House Tyrell it would be fairly even between them imo.

[Show spoiler]The redhead outside the wall whose name i'm forgetting at the moment. I wish she didn't die, i liked her. "You know nothing Jon Snow."

Besides theon the greyjoy had one scene in season 3. Greyjoy were prominently in season 2.

[explorer6]

In fairness, i think people are being a little too hard on the person. Something well known all the way from season 1... should people always use spoilers, probably just for consideration to others but something well known back from season 1 in a season 4 thread is hardly the spoiler of spoilers. If someone hasn't seen season 1 yet they probably should know better then be in a season 4 thread.

[tj5921]

Originally Posted by explorer6

In fairness, i think people are being a little too hard on the person. Something well known all the way from season 1... should people always use spoilers, probably just for consideration to others but something well known back from season 1 in a season 4 thread is hardly the spoiler of spoilers. If someone hasn't seen season 1 yet they probably should know better then be in a season 4 thread.

I wouldn't have said anything but the same poster criticized me for not using the spoiler tag on something that clearly wasn't a spoiler. Then they post an obvious spoiler without using said tag. It's just hypocritical.

[explorer6]

Originally Posted by ck19

Besides theon the greyjoy had one scene in season 3. Greyjoy were prominently in season 2.

Oh, then i'm totally mixed up lol.

I could've sworn that

[Show spoiler]the whole Rob battle campaign and red wedding was season 3 wasn't it? And wasn't that when Theon betrayed Rob and then was captured by that torturer? If so i felt that was the Greyjoy's strongest representation whenever these events occurred. Theon betraying Rob and embracing his Greyjoy roots was sort of the moment of Greyjoy for me.

I watched season 1-3 in a binge watching marathon and so it all sort of bleeds together for me. It's difficult to remember what was exactly season 2, etc... as it was all kind of 1 big season.

I wouldn't have said anything but the same poster criticized me for not using the spoiler tag on something that clearly wasn't a spoiler. Then they post an obvious spoiler without using said tag. It's just hypocritical.

I see, well if that's the case it all makes a lot more sense.

[Aragorn the Elfstone]

Originally Posted by explorer6

Oh, then i'm totally mixed up lol.

I could've sworn that

[Show spoiler]the whole Rob battle campaign and red wedding was season 3 wasn't it? And wasn't that when Theon betrayed Rob and then was captured by that torturer? If so i felt that was the Greyjoy's strongest representation whenever these events occurred. Theon betraying Rob and embracing his Greyjoy roots was sort of the moment of Greyjoy for me.

I watched season 1-3 in a binge watching marathon and so it all sort of bleeds together for me. It's difficult to remember what was exactly season 2, etc... as it was all kind of 1 big season.

[Show spoiler]Theon's betrayal was Season 2. His torture happened in Season 3.