Rumor: Peter Jackson To Direct New Middle Earth Film, Linking The Hobbit To Rings?

[My_Two_Cents]

Originally Posted by Wolverine1980

I could see this happening AS LONG AS THERE ARE ENOUGH TOLKIEN NOTES. I love Jackson but I love Tolkien more and I don't want Tolkien's name ruined by a director making a movie with material that just isn't there.

Agree. If the story is not there (in notes, etc from Tolkien), then it should not be attempted. We'd be looking at what, The Hobbit Ring-Keeper and the Search for Gollum (and for more $$)? I'll pass.

Originally Posted by Penitus

Am I the only person who hated 3D?

No. I've yet to see a 3D film yet that wasn't so dumbed-down by the obligatory object flying out of the screen.

[Sith]

Originally Posted by Ricshoe

Agree. If the story is not there (in notes, etc from Tolkien), then it should not be attempted. We'd be looking at what, The Hobbit Ring-Keeper and the Search for Gollum (and for more $$)? I'll pass.


No. I've yet to see a 3D film yet that wasn't so dumbed-down by the obligatory object flying out of the screen.

Totally agree on the first point....And agree on your point about 3D films, with
the exception of UP...