funny HD-DVD Stuff...and how stupid is J6P

[AustinSTI]

I find this scary and funny at the same time. I've been reading the 3 star and 1 star reviews of the HD-DVD of Planet earth on Amazon.com. They can be found here:

http://www.amazon.com/review/product...y=addThreeStar

http://www.amazon.com/review/product...rBy=addOneStar

Some of my favorite quotes

Unfortunatley, when I received the 4 DVD's they did not work. Major disappontment since they were a gift. The person I sent Planet Earth invited people over to view the cd's .... no luck. Plus, it ended a nice planned evening.

When I first got my hd-dvd player, this was one of the hd-dvd's I received. i was pretty impressed by the quality compared to it's dvd pq, but was not totally impressed. my brother picked this up though for his ps3 blu-ray player and kept going on on how clear the picture was, so i told him it was good but not that good. so i go over to his place and was AMAZED on how much clearer the picture was. keep in mind that we both have the same tv's on the same settings.

all in all, this is a great show...but when it comes to quality seeing is believing, and seeing it on blu-ray made me regret buying it in hd-dvd format.

we purchased two sets of this dvd, one for a gift the other for ourselves. the gift was perfect! its a great dvd! when ours arrived we were so excited! unfortunately, it would not load, not one of the dvds worked. so we are in the process of getting it returned. we love the dvd though, and are anxiously awaiting the new one!

I was unable to view the series because the DVD would not play in my state of the art HD DVD player or my brand new state of the art computer's DVD drive. Amazon was kind to send me a replacement CD, but the outcome was the same (I even tried to play the DVD at my office).

I don't know whether to laugh or cry at the stupidity of people...