FOX's "American Idol" (Season 16)

[WyldeMan45]

Originally Posted by CZAR

I stopped reading after that line as that is just ludacris! She sounds nuthin like a man. U might wanna get those ears tuned up lol. Got Em!!

I happen to find women with raspy voices quit sexy, at least they don't sound like 7 year olds. Sophia Bush, Scarlett Johannson have very raspy voices. Haley's is just intense though! I've never thought a raspy voiced woman sounded like a man. I believe he's think of 70 year old women who have smoked their entire lives, now they sound like men, that's not rasp, that's throat cancer. Fragile's profile interests tell us he loves the voices of little girls, there is no way he will like Haley cause she's all woman.

[Diesel]

Originally Posted by CZAR

Finally u admitted it haha. Got Em!!

Crap...stupid typo

Actually even Lee & Crystal is a better finale then a Scotty & Lauren finale haha. Got Em!!

Now your pushing it

I will say this...I'd rather suffer through Haley singing than to hear Crystal ever again.

Yes sir. Haley blows Lauren out of the water and its not even close. Me and Diesel had a similar argument last year where he liked this girl names Katie who was young with a younger sounding voice while I liked Siobhan who was more mature and had pipes and had soul. I guess it depends on who u liked. By the way Siobhan made it further than Katie to lol. Got Em!!

Siobhan

This thread wouldn't be any fun if you and I agreed

Originally Posted by WyldeMan45

I happen to find women with raspy voices quit sexy, at least they don't sound like 7 year olds. Sophia Bush, Scarlett Johannson have very raspy voices. Haley's is just intense though! I've never thought a raspy voiced woman sounded like a man. I believe he's think of 70 year old women who have smoked their entire lives, now they sound like men, that's not rasp, that's throat cancer. Fragile's profile interests tell us he loves the voices of little girls, there is no way he will like Haley cause she's all woman.

I'm with you 100% on Sophia Bush and Scarlett Johannson

...but I wouldn't want to hear either of them sing

[Uniquely]

Originally Posted by WyldeMan45

I happen to find women with raspy voices quit sexy, at least they don't sound like 7 year olds. Sophia Bush, Scarlett Johannson have very raspy voices. Haley's is just intense though! I've never thought a raspy voiced woman sounded like a man. I believe he's think of 70 year old women who have smoked their entire lives, now they sound like men, that's not rasp, that's throat cancer. Fragile's profile interests tell us he loves the voices of little girls, there is no way he will like Haley cause she's all woman.

Joss Stone... raspy teenager. Once you've made it past puberty and the voice is through changing... age has very little to do with vocal quality other than any damage that may have been done over time.

[Dustin44]

Originally Posted by czar

haley killed it period all three rounds and should easily advance to the finals. I think it should be her and lauren in the finale but as we all know scotty will advance of course. I just hope haley beats out lauren for the other spot. She is simply marvelous. She sings the toughest songs and takes the most risks and she kills it everytime out. Got em!!

+1,ooo,ooo

[TLeeTx2012]

Totally missed last night's show. It's on the DVR though.

[WyldeMan45]

Originally Posted by robinandtami

Joss Stone... raspy teenager. Once you've made it past puberty and the voice is through changing... age has very little to do with vocal quality other than any damage that may have been done over time.

It didn't mean to sound like I was comparing age with rasp, I know Haley has obviously had that voice for some time, and Sophia and Scarlett had the rasp as teenagers to. I just meant that I tend to prefer women with raspy voices cause to me they actually sound like adults, versus the ones that even as adults have the voices of little girls.

[TheForce8686]

It is kind of sad. We did not watch the show at all. This was the first season me and my wife ever watched but we lost interest when James was eliminated and with the Bball game and some other shows on we didn't care to watch the show at all.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by WyldeMan45

I happen to find women with raspy voices quit sexy, at least they don't sound like 7 year olds. Sophia Bush, Scarlett Johannson have very raspy voices. Haley's is just intense though! I've never thought a raspy voiced woman sounded like a man. I believe he's think of 70 year old women who have smoked their entire lives, now they sound like men, that's not rasp, that's throat cancer. Fragile's profile interests tell us he loves the voices of little girls, there is no way he will like Haley cause she's all woman.

Haha tru dat. Got Em!!

Originally Posted by Diesel

Crap...stupid typo






Now your pushing it

I will say this...I'd rather suffer through Haley singing than to hear Crystal ever again.




Siobhan

This thread wouldn't be any fun if you and I agreed





I'm with you 100% on Sophia Bush and Scarlett Johannson

...but I wouldn't want to hear either of them sing

Haha yea man us and music dont get along lol. Got Em!!

Originally Posted by Dustin44

+1,ooo,ooo

Right on. Got Em!!

Originally Posted by TheForce8686

It is kind of sad. We did not watch the show at all. This was the first season me and my wife ever watched but we lost interest when James was eliminated and with the Bball game and some other shows on we didn't care to watch the show at all.

Your loss as u are missing one of the greatest Idol contestants of all time in Haley Reinhart! Got Em!!

[WyldeMan45]

Originally Posted by CZAR

Your loss as u are missing one of the greatest Idol contestants of all time in Haley Reinhart! Got Em!!

“Rhiannon” is my all-time favorite Fleetwood song, and Haley just slayed it! I am a huge Zepplin fan and her cover of “What Is and What Should Never Be” even if she fell, she sure bounced back quick and kept going, while her dad laid down some impressive guitar work. I was even surprised by how great she covered Morissette’s “You Oughta Know” which I didn't recognize by name but knew by the chorus Haley had a great tune to work with. I loved the slight yodel as she finished out the final "You's". It wasn't her best performance by far, but she still did a great job.

[seeweda]

Haley should win it. Her vocals last night weren't as good as they were the 2 previous weeks but the degree of difficulty on the 3 songs she sung were are tougher than Lauren or Scotty's with the exception of Lauren singing Wild One. (Though Lauren sounded like she was out of breath through the whole song.)

Scotty will probably win it though it really doesn't matter he will sell tons of albums either way.

My only concern with Haley is just not sure I see her selling a ton of albums. She almost needs to disappear for a few years reinvent herself a bit and come back as some kind of cross between Lady Gaga and Joan Jett.

[SpaceDog]

I told myself I'd stop watching when Pia went. I did stop watching when James went. I didn't want to watch the only remaining worthwhile contestant get the piñata treatment again.
A Scotty/Lauren finale will be pretty lame. The only way I'll be tuning in to the results is if they've got James/Pia paired with somebody great (thus, they'd better leak that).
Nuts of Wonder grew up within spitting distance of where I live, but I've never been rooting for him.

[WyldeMan45]

Originally Posted by SpaceDog

I told myself I'd stop watching when Pia went. I did stop watching when James went. I didn't want to watch the only remaining worthwhile contestant get the piñata treatment again.

Surprisingly they all responded nearly completely positive on Haley's three performances last night, but of course you know Fat Butt couldn't be completely positive to her, she just had to get her little digs in every chance she could.

[Diesel]

She's FINALLY out of there!


Judging by her face she made, she didn't think there was any chance she was going home.

[Chloenator]

Originally Posted by Diesel

She's FINALLY out of there!


Judging by her face she made, she didn't think there was any chance she was going home.

It's going to be an EXCELLENT finale!

[anomynous]

of course the best of the three would be going home


Not that any of them are good

[Diesel]

Originally Posted by Fragile Line

It's going to be an EXCELLENT finale!

I'd say a pretty good finale...excellent for me if it were Lauren vs Pia


Carrie Underwood vs Bo Bice is probably going to still be the best finale imo.

[Chloenator]

Originally Posted by Diesel

I'd say a pretty good finale...excellent for me if it were Lauren vs Pia


Carrie Underwood vs Bo Bice is probably going to still be the best finale imo.

Yeah, that is true. I'm still bummed that Pia got booted so quick. She was hands down the best singer on the show this season! It's America's fault for not voting. Too many people just assumed that she was safe.

That finale with Carrie and Bo was phenominal! Carrie is amazing and I had so much respect for Bo! He seemed like such a nice guy.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by WyldeMan45

“Rhiannon” is my all-time favorite Fleetwood song, and Haley just slayed it! I am a huge Zepplin fan and her cover of “What Is and What Should Never Be” even if she fell, she sure bounced back quick and kept going, while her dad laid down some impressive guitar work. I was even surprised by how great she covered Morissette’s “You Oughta Know” which I didn't recognize by name but knew by the chorus Haley had a great tune to work with. I loved the slight yodel as she finished out the final "You's". It wasn't her best performance by far, but she still did a great job.

Yea I cant wait to get an album from her. It sucks that she is going home but then again the best usually dont win anyway. The finale is gonna be boring and wack but Ill watch just because. I told everyone that Scotty was gonna win along long time ago. i just felt it. Got Em!!

[WyldeMan45]

Standing by every statement I've made up til now, Haley is gone and so am I. Never to return to the sham that is Idol.

[doctorD]

Yeah, this is a popularity contest and it looks like Haley didn't have enough support. She was definitely the best singer of the 3...and as before the best don't always make it to the end. I would say that Lauren should win but somehow I'm sure Scotty will win the whole thing. I'm done too with this show.