One more receiver question. Re: HDMI and receivers

[ZackL]

Ok. So ive learned a ton so far but ive got one more question. If I understand correctly, some HDMI receivers are able to transmit Lossless true HD audio, and some are not, even though they have HDMI ports, and just pass them through the same as an optical would? Is this correct or am I off my rocker and all HDMI receivers can make HD audio? If I am correct, when looking for my new receiver, what should I be looking for?

[crackinhedz]

the problem is that some Receivers do not process HDMI Audio, even though they have an HDMI input. These are called "passthrough" systems.

More often than not, passthrough systems are not clearly labeled as such making it difficult for new buyers to distinguish between the two.

The only real way to spot a passthrough system is to read the item description. It should say it is "passthrough" (but most do not outright say) or will say "an additional audio cable is required". But like I said, many do not describe this correctly, and only when the buyer gets home and tries it out does he/she realize its not what they were hoping for.

My own personal rule of thumb (and its not always correct), is if the system is under ~$300 or comes in a HTIB package, it is normally a passthrough. Of course there are exceptions to the rule, but more often than not it is a good rule of thumb.

But, the best way to tell if you're getting a good HDMI receiver is to come onto the forums and ask other members who have experience with any particular receiver.

Before you buy, always ask!

...could save you a headache or two.

[ZackL]

Originally Posted by crackinhedz

the problem is that some Receivers do not process HDMI Audio, even though they have an HDMI input. These are called "passthrough" systems.

More often than not, passthrough systems are not clearly labeled as such making it difficult for new buyers to distinguish between the two.

The only real way to spot a passthrough system is to read the item description. It should say it is "passthrough" (but most do not outright say) or will say "an additional audio cable is required". But like I said, many do not describe this correctly, and only when the buyer gets home and tries it out does he/she realize its not what they were hoping for.

My own personal rule of thumb (and its not always correct), is if the system is under $300 or comes in a HTIB package, it is normally a passthrough. Of course there are exceptions to the rule, but more often than not it is correct.

But, the best way to tell if you're getting a good HDMI receiver is to come onto the forums and ask other members who have experience with any particular receiver.

Before you buy, always ask!

Alright awesome. Thanks very much. Im currently looking into the new Onkyo 606. Looking to upgrade the TV and hopefully by the time that's done it will be available for me here in Canada. ( At triple the cost, of course!)

[crackinhedz]

the 606 is 7.1 PCM and can also decode Dolby TrueHD/Dts-HD MA.

That would be a good choice.

[ZackL]

Originally Posted by crackinhedz

the 606 is 7.1 PCM and can also decode Dolby TrueHD/Dts-HD MA.

That would be a good choice.

That's great. One more Q... I know this isn't the speaker forum, but I will be living in an apartment for the next few years and am looking at Paradigms or Klipsch. I know these are quality but they are a little pricey. Do you think they may be overkill since there won't be many occasions to really crank it? If you don't think so, I won't be skimping but if you do, what would you suggest as a more economical choice?

[crackinhedz]

well, speakers play a great role in audio reproduction...probably one of the more important investments. Go big if you can, who knows one day you maye have a big house? ...until then just keep the volume low.

...go with what you can afford.

[ZackL]

Originally Posted by crackinhedz

well, speakers play a great role in audio reproduction...probably one of the more important investments. Go big if you can, who knows one day you maye have a big house? ...until then just keep the volume low.

...go with what you can afford.

Luckily im in college and don't have to pay for it myself. Looks like I'll be getting quality. Thanks for all the help crackinhedz.