"Reset" Blu-ray menu - LOST Season 5

[Alpha]

So I've basically been trying to find a way to do this for a few days now with no luck. On the LOST Season 5 set, there's a bonus disc (Disc 5). When you first insert the disc, you get this menu:

http://img683.imageshack.us/img683/4899/82463043.jpg

Now if you go to Bonus Features, you'll arrive at this menu:

http://img705.imageshack.us/img705/5336/80052135.jpg

If you try to select any of those options, the menu effect kicks in. You hear a bomb go off, and the menu turns to this:

http://img683.imageshack.us/img683/7968/76491027.jpg

This is where it stays. How (assuming there's a way) do I get back to the original menu(s)? I make sure my players don't save my progress on movies (never liked that ability), SeasonPlay is off, and to my knowledge, there's absolutely nothing else that can interfere. I did this menu effect on my first player thinking that the change is probably saved on the disc, but then I popped it into my second player and the original menus were there without any effect, so obviously nothing is saved on the disc. If it's on the player, where can I find (and possibly delete) what's being saved? I would assume resetting my players to their factory settings might work, but I don't want to go through that process. Besides that option, is there any other way? I've tried ejecting the disc while it's playing, I've tried powering off the player while it's playing...everything.

I figured I'd turn here for help (somewhat of a lurker of this board). Any help is appreciated!