Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[Shin sam]

Originally Posted by MasterSandman

I haven't been able to read through the entire thread but anyone else missing the subtitles when Anakin is talking to Sebulba in Episode I? Other scenes too.

Yep, I've noticed that too. There are a few missing or altered alien translation subtitles. More changes = pain in the ass.

[Shaft Windu]

As you can clearly see here Obi Wan only get's trapped by the ramp and not hurt by it. I rest my case!

[s2mikey]

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

As you can clearly see here Obi Wan only get's trapped by the ramp and not hurt by it. I rest my case!

Nice. The haters will just find the next thing though

[nathan_393]

Originally Posted by Shin sam

Yep, I've noticed that too. There are a few missing or altered alien translation subtitles. More changes = pain in the ass.

I'm not missing any subtitles. Perhaps you need to update the firmware on your player.

[Kryptonic]

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

As you can clearly see here Obi Wan only get's trapped by the ramp and not hurt by it. I rest my case!

[Colonel Kurtz]

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

As you can clearly see here Obi Wan only get's trapped by the ramp and not hurt by it. I rest my case!

And as you can clearly see here the horizontal part of the ramp digs right into Obi-Wan's hipbone. Hard enough to push him over the ground a foot or two..

[P@t_Mtl]

I am so disapointed, I was expecting this thread to have surpass the Criterion thread by this morning

[nathan_393]

^ As you can see there, some of the visual effects in these films are not all that good.

That always looked terrible on DVD and it still looks terrible on Blu. Bleh.

[chip75]

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

[Show spoiler]

As you can clearly see here Obi Wan only get's trapped by the ramp and not hurt by it. I rest my case!

What the hell happened to Obi's head when Dooku throws him though? It's completely squashed! I still think Obi-Wan wasn't walking away from the gantry thingy pushing him along the floor, he would have been badly injured.

PDVD_090.jpg

PDVD_092.jpg

[Monolithium]

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

By the way: If the explanation for TESB holds up (they were sending out probe droids through THE WHOLE GALAXY) then you'd also have to except the SAME explanation in TPM: Darth Maul searched inhabited planets in the vicinity of Naboo and found them on Tatooine with the help of his search-droids. What's the big deal!

Probe droids were sent out to search for the Rebels. One landed on Hoth, took pictures of the shield generator, then sent the info to the Empire. It holds up because you see it happen.

Darth Maul traces the Queen to Tatooine somehow. We know this because of dialogue between him and The Emperor.

[Kryptonic]

It looks like it just kind of scoots his hip and pushes him back. Obviously, its going to hurt and he might hobble for a bit, but it's not life threatening.

[Shaft Windu]

Originally Posted by Colonel Kurtz

And as you can clearly see here the horizontal part of the ramp digs right into Obi-Wan's hipbone. Hard enough to push him over the ground a foot or two..

That's because it has to be absolutely clear to the audience that he is stuck. Because of the shape of the ramp it is also clear though that it couldn't break his legs...

[Colonel Kurtz]

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

Because of the shape of the ramp it is also clear though that it couldn't break his legs...

It doesn't need to break his legs when it crushes his hip bone. You can see how it digs into his hip. With that kind of weight the lack of a few centimeters of spare room is enough to do serious damage. That the ramp was missing these few centimeters is pretty clear as well, otherwise the ramp wouldn't have had enough grip to push him. Don't try to explain away a clear mistake. It's fine to roll with it, suspension of disbelief and everything, but denying it when it's ther for everybody to see doesn't help.

[Shaft Windu]

Originally Posted by Colonel Kurtz

It doesn't need to break his legs when it crushes his hip bone. You can see how it digs into his hip. With that kind of weight the lack of a few centimeters of spare room is enough to do serious damage. That the ramp was missing these few centimeters is pretty clear as well, otherwise the ramp wouldn't have had enough grip to push him. Don't try to explain away a clear mistake. It's fine to roll with it, suspension of disbelief and everything, but denying it when it's ther for everybody to see doesn't help.

Right back at you!

[doctorsteve]

I'm waiting for the Super-Deluxe Full-Tilt Mostest Completest Ever Set... which will include every single version ever filmed, released, re-released, updated, Special Edition or 3-D'd. Only then can George have another DIME!

[Colonel Kurtz]

Originally Posted by doctorsteve

I'm waiting for the Super-Deluxe Full-Tilt Mostest Completest Ever Set... which will include every single version ever filmed, released, re-released, updated, Special Edition or 3-D'd. Only then can George have another DIME!

So, never then.

[Shin sam]

Originally Posted by nathan_393

I'm not missing any subtitles. Perhaps you need to update the firmware on your player.

Do you have the subtitle for the Gran ( the three eyed alien ) in Episode 2 then? When he say's " The debate is over we need that clone army now" then? I'm playing on PS3 and a Panasonic PD 1500.

[El_Jay]

Originally Posted by Valaquen

Darth Maul finds them within days. The Empire have been chasing the rebels for, perhaps, months-years, and only find them due to an itchy blaster finger. I don't think anybody went into the PT looking for holes; they simply fell through 'em.

Nor did I watch it with "anger" simply because I noticed these plot holes.

[nathan_393]

Originally Posted by Shin sam

Do you have the subtitle for the Gran ( the three eyed alien ) in Episode 2 then? When he say's " The debate is over we need that clone army now" then? I'm playing on PS3 and a Panasonic PD 1500.

I have a PS3 as well. I'd have to check when I'm home later today.

[El_Jay]

Originally Posted by Kryptonic

It looks like it just kind of scoots his hip and pushes him back. Obviously, its going to hurt and he might hobble for a bit, but it's not life threatening.

What does that thing look like it weighs?

I'm beginning to think you guys have no concept of physics.

"Oh, it's just a metal sidewalk, it can't weigh but 3 or 4 tons... yeah I mean as long as it only hits you in the hip and sort of scoots you a couple feet, you'll be walkin' away from that, yes sirree..."

Please allow something that weighs several hundred pounds at the very least to fall and "rest gently" on your legs, merely "scooting you a couple feet" and tell me how that turns out for ya.