Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[Space2099]

Both these scenes are in the Star Wars Bluray rips, which you can find online.



I guess I'm not buying Star Wars on Blu-ray then.

[madlost1]

Originally Posted by madlost1

I can handle the no's but please for the love of everything that is star wars tell me the Obi/Sand people audio was not actually changed because if so it's the most retarded thing I have ever heard.

Anyone?

Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk

[EddieLarkin]

Originally Posted by Breather

You invalidated anything else you said when you ventured into hyperbole and outlandish comparisons. You're kind of going off the rails here this morning. First, the earlier post about Lucas' death and now comparing the guy to Nazis/Hitler. Over movies. You might want to read up on the fuhrer and his evil buddies before you use them as some sort of comparison. You'll likely find it's not a valid one...

Well as I already explained I was comparing the attempt to delete the UOT from history to book burning, not the actual actions of the Nazis. I put Nazi in there because they are the most recognisible book burners. Simple as that, and not hyperbole in my opinion.

[Mavrick]

Originally Posted by marlon dingle

That "Nooo" sound clip sounds fake. It doesn't fit in at all with the scene and it sounds like someone has take the "Nooooo" from Revenge of the Sith, shortened it and edited it in.

I would stick money on it, that it's fake.

Three NEW HD rips appear online at the same time all with new alterations such as the rocks in Star Wars and the fixed arm of the Wampa in ESB (that has actually been used as an example of one of the actual fixes for the BD by the way) and the new Jabba's palace opening shot in Jedi.

Why would someone add the Dragon Cry and the "No!" to them? They are there in the rips along with the changes that WILL be on the BDs. And I'm pretty sure the discs have gone gold by now so ther's no going back. It will be in the films come Sep 12th/16th.

At least you guys will get confirmation a week before the US release considering it will be available in the UK first.

[Jumpman]

madlost,

It's been changed. The audio is correct.

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by marlon dingle

That "Nooo" sound clip sounds fake. It doesn't fit in at all with the scene and it sounds like someone has take the "Nooooo" from Revenge of the Sith, shortened it and edited it in.

I would stick money on it, that it's fake.

No it's real. It's from a guy who known's a guy, who as a website, who as this cousin, who know this guy at a restaurant, who know this waitress, who serve breakfast every morning to the brother of the janitor at Lucasfilm

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by jyenor

You don't seem to get what the issue is. Lucasfilm PROMISED they'd fix the sabers. They PROMISED they'd fix the garbage mattes.

It's one thing to have bad effect shots but it's another to put out a huge press event and press release point blank saying they'd fix them then releasing a product where they left them almost entirely unfixed. Lucasfilm lied to the fanbase. Period.

Easy to fix, do not buy it!

[jyenor]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

Easy to fix, do not buy it!

You don't think it is at all wrong that Lucasfilm literally point blank LIED to everyone by promising to fix the sabers/garbage mattes and then not fixing them?

[Jumpman]

Someone posted a few pages back that there needs to be a book made out of this thread.

I think that needs to happen ASAP and it needs to be combined with the other various forums on this subject. Some of the comments have been EPIC across the net. I'm crying of laughter.

It'd be the greatest comedy book of all-time.

[Blu-Benny]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

No it's real. It's from a guy who known's a guy, who as a website, who as this cousin, who know this guy at a restaurant, who know this waitress, who serve breakfast every morning to the brother of the janitor at Lucasfilm

i can't get over all of the b!tching in this thread!!!

[Jumpman]

You don't think it is at all wrong that Lucasfilm literally point blank LIED to everyone by promising to fix the sabers/garbage mattes and then not fixing them?

The article clearly states that they fixes were done on a "case by case" basis. Not totally. On a "case by case" basis.

Technically, they didn't lie.

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by jyenor

You don't think it is at all wrong that Lucasfilm literally point blank LIED to everyone by promising to fix the sabers/garbage mattes and then not fixing them?

I am not the one with the problem over it, sorry it make's you mad but I don't have any trouble with what is going on....I am planning on getting my copy on the 16th early in the morning. I can see that you are not happy with it, you best weapon is not buying it and hit Lucas in the wallet.

[Blu-man08]

Deleted.

[EddieLarkin]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

Easy to fix, do not buy it!

I won't. But what about the people who dont frequent internet forums or go looking for pirate rips of BDs. They've heard in the press of all the nice fixes that have been made, and then they get a product that isn't what is advertised.

There's only so much you can defend this sort of behaviour without looking completely daft.

[jyenor]

Originally Posted by Jumpman

The article clearly states that they fixes were done on a "case by case" basis. Not totally. On a "case by case" basis.

Technically, they didn't lie.

Case by case for them means fixing the sabers in one single frame in the scene and ignoring every other frame in the entire scene. Which ironically makes it even WORSE. Instead of being a ugly white-green saber color in the scene instead of the correct blue it now goes from white-green then jumps to a light blue for ONE FRAME then back to white green. Which overall takes you out of the scene even worse than the DVD's white-green color for the whole scene.It's almost like they did it on purpose. They knew it was a issue and only fixed the single frame they took a screencapture from. It...makes no sense.

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by Blu-Benny

i can't get over all of the b!tching in this thread!!!

I am unfortunately the worst offender, I know I just love teasing

[EddieLarkin]

Originally Posted by Blu-man08

Certainly lying is wrong, but the whole Nazi comparison is extreme, out of line, and hyperbole.

*book burning comparison. ahem

[marlon dingle]

Originally Posted by EddieLarkin

2001: A Space Odyssey is pretty much unaltered Blu-ray perfection.

Wrong.

In the scene at the start with the monkeys, some of the backgrounds are obviously just walls with pictures on them cause you can see the joins where the pictures match up. So hardly perfection.

(Please take note of my humour before getting angry with me. Obviously 2001 is a blooming great Blu-Ray).

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by EddieLarkin

I won't. But what about the people who dont frequent internet forums or go looking for pirate rips of BDs. They've heard in the press of all the nice fixes that have been made, and then they get a product that isn't what is advertised.

There's only so much you can defend this sort of behaviour without looking completely daft.

The people who don't frequent forums and the Internet, unlike us don't do so because they have LIVES They don't care who shot first, what color are the lightsabers, that R2 is hidding behind a rock or that Vader is saying NOOOOOOOO in Return! Most of them will not even notice because they are nothing more then casual fans of Star Wars and not nut cases in need of serious therapy like the rest of us here in other forums

[jyenor]

Seriously how can someone not have a problem with this:

Luke's saber is blue in Ben's hut.

It is magically white-green on the Falcon then for a single frame JUMPS to being light blue again (just so they could take that screen shot to claim in their press release they fixed it!) then JUMPS back to being white green for the rese of the scene.

Then the next movie is magically blue again..