Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[tilallr1]

Originally Posted by The Don

I thought the two new clips with Ob-Wan and Vader were fake...they are actually real?....

Yes ... yes they are.

[Merlinpants]

ILM did make a small change to the Luke sabre in Obi wans house scene. Fixed it!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irGnnyGyHwU&feature=related

[Blu-Runner]

Lol! :d

[Weirded Wonder]

Originally Posted by Jay444

I was hoping so. But the longer Lucasfilm stays silent on the subject, the worse it gets.

I'm guessing LFL has a marketing plan that doesn't cover debunking every video or comment that gets posted over the internet.

We're still 2 weeks away from the release and NOBODY has reviewed an actual copy of the release. Why make such a big deal about something that cannot be proven in any way.

Is it the badass article that sites a reliable source for the info. Well, who is the info and how did they obtain it? These supposed information people that work for the CIA are they being hunted and need to keep their identity a secret?

[iamsometal]

Originally Posted by Jay444

I was hoping so. But the longer Lucasfilm stays silent on the subject, the worse it gets.

I keep hoping to wake up and it was all a bad dream. I was so looking forward to buying the OT on blu-ray. I'll take Jedi Rocks and a Sarlacc beak any day to this travesty.

No. Buy. Ever.

[iamsometal]

Originally Posted by mrpink134

OMG do you work for GL? How can anyone be that much of a Lucas apologists, to always see a blind eye to what he has done.



Can you explain to me that Lukes Light Saber is Blue in the ESB? Don't say that he knew how to fix them because he didnt until Jedi

Stop please you are making yourself look foolish and making my head hurt by reading this nonsense.

Sorry man, you're wasting your breath. Beast is as delusional and disconnected from reality as Lucas is.

[The Don]

Originally Posted by Beard Esquire

I'm only kidding. There has not been a single shred to prove that these are in fact the blu ray releases, mere speculation... But it does not look good if you do not like these changes...

I read the Digital Bits article and don't mind the changes I have seen unless the Vader and Obi-Wan clips are real....but I'll just deal with them because I have no choice...

both of these clips sound forced..

[SellmeyourDVD]

Originally Posted by mrpink134

Stop please you are making yourself look foolish and mailing my head hurt by reading this nonsense.

Some people should really take their own advice.....

[Beast]

Originally Posted by Blu Titan

By the time the movies are released this thread will be over 30k posts. Probably the most popular thread about Star Wars in the Internet right now .

Popularity isn't always a good thing. And I'm sure a couple staffers will pull out thermal detonators at some point.

[HandyDandy]

NEWSFLASH.....


Still no word yet from Lucasfilm---Still no word yet from Lucasfilm....

Till then we can't confirm that these are real...

You people are getting bent out of shape cause of what some hack has done...

Reserve judgement till we know for sure...

Reserve judgement till we know for sure...

Don't get all bent out of shape for nothing..

END OF NEWSFLASH......

[mrpink134]

Originally Posted by SellmeyourDVD

Some people should really take their own advice.....

I loved how you changed my quote trying to prove a point. Its making not mailing.

[Beast]

Originally Posted by DarthMarino

It's actually very likely that no site or publication is even allowed to post a full detailed review until the release date. Lucasfilm has been doing everything they can to keep this thing under wraps. They've been very careful to only show selected scenes that they figured wouldn't cause an uproar. It's no coincidence that the only disc they were allowed to actually popped in at the media event was Empire which doesn't seem to have any major changes, if any. Basically, they want everyone to run out and buy this on Sept. 16th without knowing all the juicy details that have been uncovered over the past few days.

More nonsense. The websites who were invited only wanted to check out the etxras discs!

The most recent check discs for all the movies were there. And they watched a bit of two of the movies.

Go read the actual coverage. It was the choice of those who were invited what to focus on.

[Weirded Wonder]

Originally Posted by The Don

I read the Digital Bits article and don't mind the changes I have seen unless the Vader and Obi-Wan clips are real....but I'll just deal with them because I have no choice...

both of these clips sound forced..

I'm also wondering if this is a ploy by Lucas to get everyone in an uproar so that when the blus are reviewed and found out to be the 2004 versions without any new additions, but with fixes, everyone will be happy. Hoping they'll stop pining for the UOT.

[Beast]

Originally Posted by Beard Esquire

Hopefully they'll dub Sebastian's voice with Haydens... because it never made sense to me why Vader would sound that way when I saw it way back in 1983... That part always bothered me.

Unmasked Anakin sounds like that because of damage to his lungs from his injuries on Mustafar. Ya know, same reason why he's in the suit.

[Jay444]

Originally Posted by Beard Esquire

I'm guessing LFL has a marketing plan that doesn't cover debunking every video or comment that gets posted over the internet.

We're still 2 weeks away from the release and NOBODY has reviewed an actual copy of the release. Why make such a big deal about something that cannot be proven in any way.

Is it the badass article that sites a reliable source for the info. Well, who is the info and how did they obtain it? These supposed information people that work for the CIA are they being hunted and need to keep their identity a secret?

LOL, for real dude? These just aren't 'videos and comments' being posted on the internet anymore. Dark Horizons and Yahoo are pretty BIG sites, and not just some niche blu ray or star wars site/forum. The tone of the articles is not what I would call 'endorsing.' Lucasfilm's damage control should be out quite quickly on this one, as this does have the ability to negatively impact sales now (reaching much bigger audiences now, those who would have NO idea purchasing blindly, well, they now know). If it makes it to CNN, then they have a big problem. Especially if the footage is fake.

People posting on blu ray or Star Wars forums? No Problem! Yahoo and Dark Horizons?!? That is an entirely different ballgame. Not to mention the many that will post links to those two articles via social networking sites. Yeah, your friends who didn't care or know before, now they KNOW something is wrong. Consumers, who know something is broken or tampered with, don't buy. Don't under estimate the power of social networking and the bigger sites. Some may not care about the change, but others may. Regardless, they cannot stay quiet on this for much longer as the articles being written are being done in a negative tone (for the most part).

[The Don]

Originally Posted by Beard Esquire

I'm also wondering if this is a ploy by Lucas to get everyone in an uproar so that when the blus are reviewed and found out to be the 2004 versions without any new additions, but with fixes, everyone will be happy. Hoping they'll stop pining for the UOT.

I agree...that dragon yell or whatever just sounds plain silly to me....both scenes just completely contradict what I read at Digital Bits because they seemed like they were rushed and thrown together irresponsibly...

I won't believe that these changes are legit until I see them myself on Sept. 16...

[NMR1723]

Originally Posted by Jumpman

And this is why you'll be happy because you have choice. You can choose to not buy this set because of what you've kept. It's really that simple.

Hell, I'm in the market for the '06 Limited Editions just so I can have the theatrical cuts. I don't need them in HD.

You may want to hold off on those for two big reasons IMO:

1. The subtitles are cutoff at the bottom when you zoom the picture (and this is a necessity since they are non-anamorphic).
2. The audio sucks b@lls. It really does. It's a compressed stereo track and it's super tinny sounding. I have an LD rip with an uncompressed stereo track that sounds worlds better...but the picture is a bit softer.

I'm not a fan of the changes...but I'm still getting the complete saga. They're just fun popcorn movies now that I can watch with my son...they're not the movies that I loved when i was growing up anymore.

[HandyDandy]

9/16/11 Will be a day long remembered a day when the world realizes that a lone hack from a ***** ***** tricked the world into believing that this what Lucas has done....


This is what this person is doing right now

[Show spoiler]"These stupid people believed me they ACTUALLY believed me HAHAHAHA!!!!"

[Beast]

Originally Posted by iamsometal

Sorry man, you're wasting your breath. Beast is as delusional and disconnected from reality as Lucas is.

No. I simply just recognize these are only movies and am not going to have a foaming at the mouth fit about every tweak.

Sometimes I think people can't even think for themselves. That everything needs to be explained to them rather than thinking for themselves.

What do you want? The movie to pause and an animated Lucas to pop up and explain things to you? Instead of simply interpreting things for yourself?

[Citizen_Steve]

So, now we have a "NOOOOOO!!!" in each of the films except for Attack of the Clones. Right?

TPM: Obi-Wan (as Qui-Gon gets stabbed)

AOTC: ??? (did I miss it?)

ROTS: Anakin (when Mace tries to Kill Palps)
Vader (learns of Padme's death)

ANH: Luke (at Obi-Wan's death)

ESB: Luke (I am your father)

ROTJ: Vader (redemption)