Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[dcowboy7]

Originally Posted by Beast

But honestly?

[Petyr_Baelish]

Originally Posted by bboisvert

I don't think this deserves any degree of overanalysis... but it's also entirely possible that his reaction to Ben's death seemed stronger because it was ON TOP OF the death of his aunt/uncle. Just within a very short (day or two?) timespan, he's lost everyone close to him.

He still had c3po

[HandyDandy]

These rips are not from the blu-ray's.
It has been confirmed that they have fixed a lot of the issues from the 2004 release.

UOT fanboys gotta love em.

[sevb36]

Has anyone watched these so-called leaks at the points where things were shown to be corrected? Like the ESB Wampa arm shot or the ROTJ saber cross? Those would give them credibilty as not just being HD TV recordings.

[jala12]

Until digital Yoda or any of the other mentioned fixes have been screencapped, I'll consider those shots fake, lol.

[al cos.]

Originally Posted by HandyDandy

UOT fanboys gotta love em.

Eh? What does the UOT have to do with this?

[IndyMLVC]

Originally Posted by HandyDandy

These rips are not from the blu-ray's.
It has been confirmed that they have fixed a lot of the issues from the 2004 release.

UOT fanboys gotta love em.

Well, clearly with that logic...

Unless YOU download them, you won't know if they're real or not. But I don't think we should just dismiss them because you don't believe it.

In fact, it's VERY easy to figure out if they're real or not: compare them to the HDTV rips.

Blu-ray:

German HDTV 1080p:

[Romansh]

Originally Posted by sevb36

Has anyone watched these so-called leaks at the points where things were shown to be corrected? Like the ESB Wampa arm shot or the ROTJ saber cross? Those would give them credibilty as not just being HD TV recordings.

At this point, it seems like all we have are screenshots of a hypothetical OT leak (with some evidence that it may actually be sourced from fake Blu-rays which have been around for some time), as well as a confirmed fake PT downloads (no digital Yoda). We're not quite there yet.

When true leaks become available, we should start seeing meaningful screenshots reasonably quickly, IMO.

[Lincoln6Echo]

Originally Posted by kingkong650

That final line was very rightly cut out. It makes Luke sound like a petulant child.

Having Anakin in the PT as a spoilt petulant brat was enough for me. One of the reasons I didn´t like the PT all that much is that Anakin is such an unlikable character from the very beginning of the second film right to the end of the third film so you really don´t care that he falls to the dark side at the end of Revenge of the Sith. He has no real character arc in that sense (he´s bad right from the start so there´s be no real change/character development there) and the prequels trilogy is all the worse for it IMHO.

I can agree with that for about 85%, but is that because we ultimately know what happens with Anakin, in that we already have a preconcieved notion that Anakin turns out to be a Dark Lord of the Sith?

[goldenrod]

Originally Posted by IndyMLVC

nope. These JUST came out.

I doubt these are legits, since color isn't the same as the star wars moments website



and door borders (Right of Beru in supposed leak) and behind/above owen (moments pictures) don't have the same sharpness

[al cos.]

Originally Posted by Lincoln6Echo

I can agree with that for about 85%, but is that because we ultimately know what happens with Anakin, in that we already have a preconcieved notion that Anakin turns out to be a Dark Lord of the Sith?

Nah, it's because "turning to the dark side" means "he's a hilarious douche and stays that way."

[IndyMLVC]

Originally Posted by goldenrod

I doubt these are legits, since color isn't the same as the star wars moments website
and door borders (Right of Beru in supposed leak) and behind/above owen (moments pictures) don't have the same sharpness

Well, since everyone here has denounced the Star Wars Moments website as being illigitimate, I guess it doesn't matter what that site has shown?

[Lincoln6Echo]

Originally Posted by IndyMLVC

Well, clearly with that logic...

Unless YOU download them, you won't know if they're real or not. But I don't think we should just dismiss them because you don't believe it.

In fact, it's VERY easy to figure out if they're real or not: compare them to the HDTV rips.

Blu-ray:
http://img52.imageshack.us/img52/303...conblurayl.png
German HDTV 1080p:
http://img844.imageshack.us/img844/8429/berun.jpg

They still haven't fixed Beru's vintage '70s denim jacket and flaired collars.

Isn't this about the only scene Beru's in in the film? If so, why couldn't they have composited in a traditional Tatooine robe? or something that wouldn't scream "Hey, we made this film in the mid-'70s and wasn't thinking far enough ahead in our costuming department."

[Lincoln6Echo]

Originally Posted by goldenrod

I doubt these are legits, since color isn't the same as the star wars moments website



and door borders (Right of Beru in supposed leak) and behind/above owen (moments pictures) don't have the same sharpness

Umm, focal points?

[Bestisamoron]

Originally Posted by Beast

Welcome back Elvis/Cowboy/RickDees.

And I have been Suspended a couple of times for off topic discussion in this thread.

So don't assume that they don't treat the socalled "PT-Lovers" the same way they do everyone else.

So tell me, just when did you see Star Wars, TESB and ROTJ again? How old were you?

[nathan_393]

Originally Posted by Lincoln6Echo

They still haven't fixed Beru's vintage '70s denim jacket and flaired collars.

Isn't this about the only scene Beru's in in the film? If so, why couldn't they have composited in a traditional Tatooine robe? or something that wouldn't scream "Hey, we made this film in the mid-'70s and wasn't thinking far enough ahead in our costuming department."

I've never even thought about that.

Interesting that people will complain about something like that...

I'd rather George didn't further tinker with anything from the original trilogy on Blu-ray. Not to open that can of worms again - I'm just a bit of a purist. At the moment, I'm pretty pleased with how things are going but the jacket is a minor point and should probably stay.

[IndyMLVC]

Btw...was this shown here before?
http://www.bluray-disc.de/hd-trailer...-at-at-trailer

[Bestisamoron]

Originally Posted by nathan_393

I've never even thought about that.

Interesting that people will complain about something like that...

I'd rather George didn't further tinker with anything from the original trilogy on Blu-ray. Not to open that can of worms again - I'm just a bit of a purist. At the moment, I'm pretty pleased with how things are going but the jacket is a minor point and should probably stay.

Well at least someone has some sense around here!

[Beast]

Originally Posted by IndyMLVC

Btw...was this shown here before?
http://www.bluray-disc.de/hd-trailer...-at-at-trailer

I think it was on one of the other site's articles. But always good to see it again. The Death of Veers deleted scene should be fun also.

[IndyMLVC]

Originally Posted by Beast

I think it was on one of the other site's articles. But always good to see it again. The Death of Veers deleted scene should be fun also.

Sorry. Nothing is organized. So hard to try and keep everything straight in between the bickering