Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[phansson]

Well, it just donned on me, Lucas probably made these changes so we would all talk about that instead of *****ing about the fact that he didn't give us a new transfer..

[iamsometal]

Originally Posted by opticzar

Awesome, I reached the end of the thread again!!

On topic discussion: What are the odds of a disc replacement program for ROTJ?

Sadly, the odds are about as good as, say, getting the UOT on blu-ray before Lucas kicks the bucket.

Or his daughter for that matter. Double

[dvdmike]

Originally Posted by Beard Esquire

Makes you wonder why we haven't seen TPM, doesn't it? At at least I wonder.

There are three sets available, the rips could just be from someone who only had access to the OT set

[Rhoq]

Originally Posted by opticzar

Awesome, I reached the end of the thread again!!

On topic discussion: What are the odds of a disc replacement program for ROTJ?

Zero. This is "Jedi" as Lucas now sees it.

[whaleman]

Originally Posted by greg_achen

Please tell me those "No's" added to right before Vader picks up Palpatine are fake. That scene was PERFECTION and always gave me goosebumps. Now it is utterly cringeworthy. I will accept Hayden at the end of Jedi and Greedo shooting first if it meant that Vader's redemptive moment was left alone.

Ewok eye blinks? New Jabba door? Ruining a once perfect dramatic moment? And yet, the one thing that is glaringly obvious and most people were praying for, consistent lightsabers, has been ignored yet again for this release. Lucasfilm's actions are mind boggling.

Please, please, please I hope the rumours of the "Nooooo!" in RotJ are not true. I think this would be the worst of all Lucas' changes for me. I agree with the above quote that this is worse than Greedo shooting first and Hayden at the end of Jedi. Oh man I hope this is not true.

[Weirded Wonder]

Originally Posted by teamneedle

eh, each trilogy can come separately, maybe they only got the OT

Could be.

[dvdmike]

Originally Posted by phansson

Well, it just donned on me, Lucas probably made these changes so we would all talk about that instead of *****ing about the fact that he didn't give us a new transfer..

Had been talked about at length in hear since the sets were aunnnounced

[jyenor]

I fear Star Wars under Katie Lucas. Her father refuses to the listen to the fanbase but Katie Lucas? She outright loathes anyone who says a bad word about her father and trashes them on Twitter. She is far more vindictive of a Lucas than her father.

Expect the worst when George kicks the bucket, Katie holds a clear grudge against those who trashed her dad.

[Barbossa]

The 1 star negative reviews are flooding onto Amazon.com:

http://www.amazon.com/Star-Wars-Comp...owViewpoints=1

[chip75]

Originally Posted by hobgoblin

As far as I can tell, it's just shot from further away?

They've shrunk our favourite droids to increase the scale of the shot. It must be the Rancor's entrance or Hutt's must really get big....

[balthazar_bee]

Originally Posted by IndyMLVC

George wouldn't re-make Citizen Kane. He would just digitally "enhance" it

Because the original version is sacred.

Remember what that soldier played by Forest Whitaker says in Platoon: "I don't know, brothers...but I'm hurtin' real bad inside."

There's no logical reason why changes like "No" should hurt the trilogy anymore than the myriad of other ridiculous changes.

And yet...and yet...

I have to believe this is a joke. It plays like a joke. A very cruel one.

And that Krayt Dragon yowl? It resembles a sound I made dancing on top of a parked car in my underwear on a moonlit night few weeks ago.

[Jumpman]

Why wouldn't she defend her father after the vile that's been spewed his way for 14 years?

[Petyr_Baelish]

Originally Posted by jyenor

I fear Star Wars under Katie Lucas. Her father refuses to the listen to the fanbase but Katie Lucas? She outright loathes anyone who says a bad word about her father and trashes them on Twitter. She is far more vindictive of a Lucas than her father.

Expect the worst when George kicks the bucket, Katie holds a clear grudge against those who trashed her dad.

Yes, shocking that she doesn't want other people saying bad things about her father. The rest of us welcome insults directed towards our parents.

[phansson]

Originally Posted by dvdmike

Had been talked about at length in hear since the sets were aunnnounced

Yes, I know, but now everyone isn't noticing the actual video problems with the transfer anymore. They are griping about the "noooo".

Remember how bad the 2004 color timing is? We are getting the same ol' transfer?

[jyenor]

EXACT same transfer. Matte lines and messed up sabers and all.

[greg_achen]

Originally Posted by whaleman

Please, please, please I hope the rumours of the "Nooooo!" in RotJ are not true. I think this would be the worst of all Lucas' changes for me. I agree with the above quote that this is worse than Greedo shooting first and Hayden at the end of Jedi. Oh man I hope this is not true.

You should see the clip of that scene uploaded to YouTube. It is even more horrible than I imagined. That scene in its original incarnation was filmmaking at its best. Now it is ruined.

[BMM]

Originally Posted by moviestar

do the despecialized versions also exist in 1080p?

the creator could work with the original PremiereHD broadcast sources and try an (almost) lossless encode, much better than using a 720p encode

The Despecialized versions in 720p look light years ahead of what the Blu-rays will look like in 1080p.....because they're actually PROPER versions of the films with the right colors.

[IndyMLVC]

Originally Posted by Jumpman

Why wouldn't she defend her father after the vile that's been spewed his way for 14 years?

She should defend him. That's her flesh and blood.

But it doesn't mean he doesn't deserve it. ALL of it.

[phansson]

Adywan, how is the blue in "a new hope", R2D2's dome, the escape pod lid, pretty much any blue in that whole movie. Is is still bright and over saturated? That bothered me more than anything in the whole movie.

[whaleman]

Originally Posted by balthazar_bee

I have to believe this is a joke. It plays like a joke. A very cruel one.

As of this moment, I have to hold out hope that this is a hoax. I tuned in late today, is the only evidence a youtube video? Is there any other reason to believe the "Nooooo!" is really in there? Anything official either way?