Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[Geoff D]

Originally Posted by roguejp

Isn't that just what they did on the Limited Edition DVD's

It's best not to feed him, fella. His avatar is literally that of a troll.

[chip75]

I'm very naïve, but is this good trolling or bad trolling? It's so over the top I'm not sure if it's supposed to be ironic or not? It's on par with stuff you see on YouTube, where everyone calls the guy a troll and he posts 800 comments later that he is in fact a troll and he's been fooling everyone with his magical troll ways, but has decided to "come-clean" for the good of the internet and our shattered psyches.

[Takeshi666]

Originally Posted by PeterTHX

Madly collected all the figures until 1981 or so and just...stopped.

And 17 years later, he proceeded to use them in his classic film, "Godzilla vs. Disco Lando".

Godzilla Vs Disco Lando - YouTube

[imsounoriginal]

Originally Posted by Sivle A

Where does all this PT hate come from? George got the OT films the way he finally wanted them to match the PT. And I have no doubt that the new films will also match the OT and PT the way George would have wanted them to. Only a fool would mess with greatness and what happened on the screen with the PT was pure magic.

Not so sure about that, seems like they're doing everything they can to move away from the PT and the way "Lucas would have wanted" the movies to be. Although after finally seeing the Episode VII teaser in theaters last week, it looked exactly like the prequels, so I dunno where all that "everything is practical, we're going old-school" talk came from. I'm not expecting much.

[Sivle A]

Originally Posted by chip75

I'm very naïve, but is this good trolling or bad trolling? It's so over the top I'm not sure if it's supposed to be ironic or not? It's on par with stuff you see on YouTube, where everyone calls the guy a troll and he posts 800 comments later that he is in fact a troll and he's been fooling everyone with his magical troll ways, but has decided to "come-clean" for the good of the internet and our shattered psyches.

Since when is giving an opinion being a troll? I don't get it but to each thier own I guess. I would assume anyone defending the PT trilogy or sharing thier love of the new editions of the OT is a bad thing? I just know that I love what I love and I truly believe George has done just about everything right. I hope the new films will meet those same high standards.

[Dwayne Hicks]

I like the CG'd special editions of OT better than the original versions in just about every way. So sue me! I also think the Lowry transfers hold incredibly well. Still a part of my reference disc group.

I also think that The Phantom Menace is a masterpiece and the most underrated movie of all time.

I'm ready to be stoned now, but it is the truth!

[Sivle A]

Originally Posted by Dwayne Hicks

I like the CG'd special editions of OT better than the original versions in just about every way. So sue me! I also think the Lowry transfers hold incredibly well. Still a part of my reference disc group.

I also think that The Phantom Menace is a masterpiece and the most underrated movie of all time.

I'm ready to be stoned now, but it is the truth!

I too love TPM. It's not quite as good as Clones best film in the series but it's real close.

[motorheadache95]

Originally Posted by Dylan34

I wasn't trying to be rude, or smug, or anything like that. It was just a question, followed by how I feel about the Criterion Collection. If I came off like that, I give my sincerest of apologies. That was not my intentions, believe me!

No, not at all, I agree with you. I've seen a few interesting movies from Criterion, but they're almost never the kind of movies I'd buy or be interested in watching more than once.

The snobby people I was talking about are like those types that pride themselves on their "unique and sophisticated" taste in movies, and think we're a bunch of plebs for not having the classics of the French New Wave in our collection of favorite films.

[HD Goofnut]

Originally Posted by motorheadache95

No, not at all, I agree with you. I've seen a few interesting movies from Criterion, but they're almost never the kind of movies I'd buy or be interested in watching more than once.

The snobby people I was talking about are like those types that pride themselves on their "unique and sophisticated" taste in movies, and think we're a bunch of plebs for not having the classics of the French New Wave in our collection of favorite films.

Just visit the Criterion and Twilight Time threads to see good examples of those.

[JamesKurtovich]

Originally Posted by Dwayne Hicks

I like the CG'd special editions of OT better than the original versions in just about every way. So sue me! I also think the Lowry transfers hold incredibly well. Still a part of my reference disc group.

I also think that The Phantom Menace is a masterpiece and the most underrated movie of all time.

I'm ready to be stoned now, but it is the truth!

Trolling used to mean somethin'...

[Harry Güchenschlong]

Originally Posted by Sivle A

I too love TPM. It's not quite as good as Clones best film in the series but it's real close.

HAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAA Now this is awesome

[Dwayne Hicks]

Originally Posted by JamesKurtovich

Trolling used to mean somethin'...

[Geoff D]

Originally Posted by chip75

I'm very naïve, but is this good trolling or bad trolling? It's so over the top I'm not sure if it's supposed to be ironic or not? It's on par with stuff you see on YouTube, where everyone calls the guy a troll and he posts 800 comments later that he is in fact a troll and he's been fooling everyone with his magical troll ways, but has decided to "come-clean" for the good of the internet and our shattered psyches.

Maybe it's more of Shia LaBeouf's "performance art".

[Gold Ranger]

Ewan McGregor might be helming an Obi-Wan Kenobi Trilogy!

I'd be down for that!

[Brightstar]

Originally Posted by Harry Güchenschlong

HAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAA Now this is awesome

TESB is and was and allways will be the best star wars film ever made

[filmmusic]

Originally Posted by Sivle A

Since when is giving an opinion being a troll? I don't get it but to each thier own I guess. I would assume anyone defending the PT trilogy or sharing thier love of the new editions of the OT is a bad thing? I just know that I love what I love and I truly believe George has done just about everything right. I hope the new films will meet those same high standards.

I'll tell you what:
If i saw in your collection all the bad B-movies I could understand it that you could consider the prequel trilogy best.
But seeing obviously that you have a taste and aesthetics in film, it's beyond me and I believe beyond every sane person, how do you consider the prequel trilogy better than the original trilogy and attack of the clones (which is always said to be the worst film of the series) as the best!

So, i really think it's a kind of gag or something of yours.

[Sivle A]

Originally Posted by filmmusic

I'll tell you what:
If i saw in your collection all the bad B-movies I could understand it that you could consider the prequel trilogy best.
But seeing obviously that you have a taste and aesthetics in film, it's beyond me and I believe beyond every sane person, how do you consider the prequel trilogy better than the original trilogy and attack of the clones (which is always said to be the worst film of the series) as the best!

So, i really think it's a kind of gag or something of yours.

In Order:

Attack of the Clones
The Phantom Menace
The Empire Strikes Back
Revenge of the Sith
Return of the Jedi
A New Hope


Anything wrong with that list? Does that look like a gag to you? These are the ones I "enjoy" the most in order! Of course we can argue the merits of each film all day but this is what I prefer to watch.

[roguejp]

Originally Posted by Geoff D

It's best not to feed him, fella. His avatar is literally that of a troll.

A good piece of advice, cheers .

[Harry Güchenschlong]

Come on, this is comedy gold

[filmmusic]

Originally Posted by Geoff D

It's best not to feed him, fella. His avatar is literally that of a troll.

Oh, you're right. Hadn't noticed that.
maybe the collection of all the Criterions is a fake one too..